News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Turns Out Schrödinger, the Father of Quantum Physics, Was... by luma on Friday January 14, 2022 @09:56AM (#29935174)
I like hwere your head is at but I think God can take the blame on that one, who did so without Mary's prior consent.
Re:Turns Out Schrödinger, the Father of Quantum Physics, Was... by gjsman-1000 on Friday January 14, 2022 @10:01AM (#29935242)
"And Mary said, “Behold, I am the handmaid of the Lord; let it be to me according to your word.” And the angel departed from her."

- Luke 1:38

She gave her consent.

Re:Turns Out Schrödinger, the Father of Quantum Physics, Was... by joshgrib on Friday January 14, 2022 @10:22AM (#29935523)
It seems like the angel tells her in Luke 1:31 that it's happening whether she wants it to or not

> "You will conceive and give birth to a son, and you are to call him Jesus"

It's nice that she accepts it afterwards, but that's definitely not how consent works, and it doesn't seem like she was given any other option

Edit: I saw your other comment saying "there's other evidence of god respecting free will and he probably would have been fine with it if she didn't want to". The bible is full of contradictions so there may be evidence of a respect for free will somewhere else, but this specific story seems to contradict that

Re:Turns Out Schrödinger, the Father of Quantum Physics, Was... by gjsman-1000 on Friday January 14, 2022 @10:27AM (#29935603)
There's a difference between prediction and commanding.

It's like when a father tells his daughter she'll get married and have three sweet little children. That doesn't mean it's immediately set in stone and she's forced to.

Re:Turns Out Schrödinger, the Father of Quantum Physics, Was... by joshgrib on Friday January 14, 2022 @10:42AM (#29935799)
I can agree with that, but as far as we see in the text it is a command - she's never told she has another option and we as the readers aren't given any indication that she thinks there is. I get that there's a charitable interpretation here if you look for it but I'm trying to just go based on what it says in the book
Re:Turns Out Schrödinger, the Father of Quantum Physics, Was... by krapp on Friday January 14, 2022 @04:48PM (#29940916)
At least we can all agree YHWH was a bit more more polite about it than, say, Zeus would have been.
Re:Turns Out Schrödinger, the Father of Quantum Physics, Was... by freedom2099 on Friday January 14, 2022 @10:14AM (#29935425)
But he was god… could she really be in the position to refuse? It’s like Monica and Bill Clinton… a poor intern with a powerful president! That is why it is usually forbidden for a person in power to hit on an underling!
Re:Turns Out Schrödinger, the Father of Quantum Physics, Was... by gjsman-1000 on Friday January 14, 2022 @10:19AM (#29935480)
As I said below, a cursory look at Christianity teaches the God respects human free will. It's partly why so much evil is in the world. If Mary had refused (which she could have), he would have respected that decision. The Jewish people would have needed to wait longer for their messiah, and it might not be the year 2022 right now.

Also, God is not a human, and is not subject to the human weakness that a position in power has for underlings.

Re:Turns Out Schrödinger, the Father of Quantum Physics, Was... by freedom2099 on Friday January 14, 2022 @10:48AM (#29935877)
You assume that Mary has not felt any pressure to accept such request from god? It’s not like Old Testament god is a nice guy… I would be terrorised to disappoint him! So no… Mary was in no condition to refuse!
Re:Turns Out Schrödinger, the Father of Quantum Physics, Was... by fleurjs on Friday January 14, 2022 @10:34AM (#29935705)
God is at fault for giving free will to humans.
Re:Turns Out Schrödinger, the Father of Quantum Physics, Was... by gjsman-1000 on Friday January 14, 2022 @10:36AM (#29935729)
Well, funnily enough, he put us in a Garden where we had everything we could possibly want and we had free will, but had no knowledge of what evil was. However, because we had free will and he didn't want little robots, he put a tree in it with fruit that would give us that knowledge if we freely choose it, but warned us of the consequences. We chose the knowledge. And we made that choice pretty quickly off the bat too, Adam and Eve hadn't even had any kids yet when they made that decision.

And now, thousands of thousands of years later (in the grand scheme of things according to the Bible), a Hacker News commenter complains that God shouldn't have given us free will to make that decision and we would have been happier staying robots. Philosophically profound that is.

Re:Turns Out Schrödinger, the Father of Quantum Physics, Was... by fleurjs on Friday January 14, 2022 @07:29PM (#29942349)
Not a complaint but a fact.
Re:Turns Out Schrödinger, the Father of Quantum Physics, Was... by WithinReason on Friday January 14, 2022 @10:46AM (#29935853)
God was in a position of power. Infinite power.
Re:Turns Out Schrödinger, the Father of Quantum Physics, Was... by harperlee on Friday January 14, 2022 @10:09AM (#29935354)
Pretty sure it was accepted by Mary by standard account.
Re:Turns Out Schrödinger, the Father of Quantum Physics, Was... by xwolfi on Friday January 14, 2022 @10:23AM (#29935538)
You bet she gave consent to Joseph, she even lied and said she was impregnated by an angel to her parents when she had to explain the result. To someone today that would be laughed off and sent to court, but at the time they ran with it... simpler times :D
Re:Turns Out Schrödinger, the Father of Quantum Physics, Was... by gjsman-1000 on Friday January 14, 2022 @10:26AM (#29935578)
Oh right, as if he didn't do miracles left and right, raise from the dead, and predict the fall of Jerusalem 40 years before it happened. That's your hangup with the story?
Re:Turns Out Schrödinger, the Father of Quantum Physics, Was... by joshgrib on Friday January 14, 2022 @11:00AM (#29936060)
It was pretty commonplace to lie to avoid the social persecution of having a baby outside of marriage. This was still fairly common even recently - a young girl would go to a nunnery and them come back with a child "they adopted". There is also no evidence of any miracles aside from games of telephone played over centuries.

We also have plenty of equally verified accounts of virgin births from other religions going back even further than Jesus. So if we're believing any claims of virgin birth followed by claims of miracles, then the Christian god must surely be lying by saying they're the only god

This seems like a nice little summary of all the other similar claims: https://www.smh.com.au/national/there-s-nothing-new-about-vi...

> Claims of divine intervention aside, virgin births may have a more human explanation – a tragic demonstration of the extreme measures women have been forced to take to save themselves and their reputations.

Re:Turns Out Schrödinger, the Father of Quantum Physics, Was... by joshgrib on Friday January 14, 2022 @10:15AM (#29935431)
Oof I never really realized that the Christian god is canonically a rapist
Re:Turns Out Schrödinger, the Father of Quantum Physics, Was... by gjsman-1000 on Friday January 14, 2022 @10:18AM (#29935473)
Christianity teaches that God respects human free will. It's partly why so much evil is in the world. If Mary had refused (which she could have), he would have respected that decision and we might be living in year 1970 right now.
Re:Turns Out Schrödinger, the Father of Quantum Physics, Was... by joshgrib on Friday January 14, 2022 @10:49AM (#29935889)
Christianity may teach that today, but it isn't what the story is. Do you have any evidence from the text showing that she had another choice?

God also murders tons of people in the bible without consulting them, which definitely cannot be done while also respecting their free will