News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:File Hosting Service Hotfile Sues Warner Bros. For Copyri... by sp332 on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @03:42PM (#2993170)
Nope, any request that fulfills DMCA requirements has to be obeyed. Any exceptions risks losing safe harbor, and that means you're responsible for all content on your servers.
Re:File Hosting Service Hotfile Sues Warner Bros. For Copyri... by bediger on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @04:03PM (#2993265)
You're responsible for all content, if you blink at one DMCA takedown? I dunno, that seems a bit extreme.

Is this for real, or is this just a lawyerly, overly cautious opinion? Are there cases where this has happened? Does the DMCA itself have wording to this effect?

Re:File Hosting Service Hotfile Sues Warner Bros. For Copyri... by sp332 on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @04:15PM (#2993323)
Normally, you would have to take responsibility for the data on your servers. Legally, there is an exception if you disclaim responsibility for all user-generated content, then you just take the content down and whoever has a problem has to work it out with the user directly. This exception is known as "safe harbor", and there are very specific rules about who gets to claim it. https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Online_Copyri...

Basically, as soon as you take responsibility for any of the user-generated content, you can be held liable for all of it. Either you're responsible for the content on your servers or you're not, you can't really pick and choose.