The alternative would be for people to always rely on a search engine to actually get the sites they want and never really enter URLs by hand. We are not that far from that, to be honest. There are many people who will search for the site name and click the first link rather than type in the url. Sometimes their search comes up as a suggestion before they press enter, but it's still the same idea of not relying on the actual DNS name.
Re:Alternative DNS Roots
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Saturday January 15, 2022 @01:41AM
(#29944192)
The idea I implemented as an experiment at home is DNS names that contain encoded information. For example, the TLD contains a number that represents a certain trademark class of good/services. Subcategories are encoded in domain, subdomain1, subdomain2, etc. becoming more specific as one reads from right to left. Thus one can perform searches only on the domainname (and optionally the URL). This is faster and easier than searching the contents of web pages. Another portion of the domain name is a public key. For some types of content, this works well. It is like searching a directory.
That's more or less how yahoo! directory worked (obviously not at the DNS level), however, google showed that crawling the contents and indexing everything, while certainly a lot more complex, it is a lot easier to use. So, while that idea is probably better and more discoverable than the current DNS system, it seems more likely to me that the replacement for DNS will be free text search.
At some point, browsers will finally manage to get rid of the address bar and have everything working fully operated via suggestions/search. Then, DNS will become sort of irrelevant for the web.
Re:Alternative DNS Roots
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Sunday January 16, 2022 @11:32PM
(#29963333)
Sounds plausible however I am not much of browser fan, while I really do like the speed and size of DNS software, so I will always be experimenting with different approaches. The world of the web browser is dominated by advertising and surveillance. Unless that changes, I care little about what the web browser may or may not do in the future. I am more interested in relatively small DNS software.
Neither are telephone numbers … being exactly a user-friendly thingie but there we go.
Re:Alternative DNS Roots
by technothrasher on Friday January 14, 2022 @08:50AM
(#29934376)
Phone numbers are the IP addresses. Your contact list (or the yellow/white pages in days long past) is the DNS server for them.
Re:Alternative DNS Roots
by Tijdreiziger on Friday January 14, 2022 @06:21AM
(#29933110)
Vastly more user-friendly than .onion names, I'd say :P
Only by the virtue of being a less combinatorial options of the few, 10 to 15 digit telephone number that is.
That's why people have phone books and contact lists.
Re:Alternative DNS Roots
by southerntofu on Friday January 14, 2022 @08:16AM
(#29934057)
Onions are globally unique and secure. It would be interesting to add a "social" human-meaningful layer pointing to those unique/secure names, much like the GNS project tries to do.
I’m immediately reminded of Tor .onion names, though those aren’t exactly user-friendly…