Re:File Hosting Service Hotfile Sues Warner Bros. For Copyri...
by sdz on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @11:24AM
(#2991851)
Fair enough, the real rights owner may have uploaded the books and videos themselves. I just think there's some irony here that Hotfile suddenly cares about copyright.
Re:File Hosting Service Hotfile Sues Warner Bros. For Copyri...
by pyre on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @11:34AM
(#2991900)
Then you must also find irony in Warner's actions. They care so much about copyright and the law, but they can't even follow the rules.
Re:File Hosting Service Hotfile Sues Warner Bros. For Copyri...
by dspillett on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @11:53AM
(#2991999)
They care about protecting their own content and using the law to do so where possible - you can not logically infer from that fact that they care about copyright or the law more generally.
Re:File Hosting Service Hotfile Sues Warner Bros. For Copyri...
by rmc on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @02:03PM
(#2992609)
The WB & MPAA marketing message is that they care about the law generally, and creativity generally.
Re:File Hosting Service Hotfile Sues Warner Bros. For Copyri...
by seabee on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @01:48PM
(#2992522)
Are there alternative means of protecting your content?
Re:File Hosting Service Hotfile Sues Warner Bros. For Copyri...
by dspillett on Wednesday September 14, 2011 @09:56AM
(#2996254)
No.
I was questioning the assumption that because they use the law this way they are necessarily bothered one way or the other about the laws and regulations as they apply in contexts other than this one.
Re:File Hosting Service Hotfile Sues Warner Bros. For Copyri...
by dexen on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @11:37AM
(#2991916)
This is half of the harm WB did: people like me and you started believing Hotfile is somehow evil, disregarding the law and whatnot. We don't know that, we just subscribe to the black propaganda.
Behind WB's ham-fisted tactics may well be conflict of interests: if WB are to distribute multimedia themselves, they sure would consider Hotfile competitors and want to slow them down.
Re:File Hosting Service Hotfile Sues Warner Bros. For Copyri...
by Karunamon on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @11:35AM
(#2991905)
Hotfile has been in full compliance with the DMCA. Warner Bros, on the other hands...
Re:File Hosting Service Hotfile Sues Warner Bros. For Copyri...
by njharman on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @01:09PM
(#2992350)
There's no suddenly about it. Did you read the article? Hotfile created the tool WB is using to remove content. Hotfile is not responsible for their users. They are a hoster and under relevant law, DMCA, have specific responsibilities, which they seemed to have complied with.
(...) and surely the real rights holders would want their intellectual property removed from Hotfile if they knew about it.
You don't know if the uploader of the books has license to publish them, and you cannot act under assumption they lack one.