News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google doesn't want to pay Sonos for technology it copied by tssva on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @06:29PM (#29899977)
You need to read the claims in the patent. That is what the patent actually covers. The claims include the controller presenting a UI but that is not the only claim in the patent. Besides that the abstract also supports the point of my post and not your original. You stated that the patent covers a particular presentation of a UI for doing so. It does not. It just states that a UI is presented and not the form of the UI which is exactly what I stated in my comment.
Re:Google doesn't want to pay Sonos for technology it copied by halpert on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @06:47PM (#29900141)
The claims almost all say "via the user interface." (Not a user interface btw) The figures also contain detailed descriptions of the user interface. I know it's a trope that software patents are bad, but a generally broad patent of "controller for controlling" could have been challenged. The user interface was the main issue with this.