News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Radeon RX 6500 XT is bad at cryptocurrency mining on purp... by dragontamer on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @04:46PM (#29898496)
I'd expect otherwise actually.

RDNA is far more efficient at gaming. GCN was compute-focused (higher TFLOPs, but weaker in practice). Case in point, micro-benchmarks show that VRAM latency is ~100 nanoseconds on RDNA, but ~300 nanoseconds on GCN.

RX 6500 XT is aimed at roughly the same specs as the RX480, but should perform slightly faster in practice, along with Raytracing support, Infinity Cache and therefore faster VRAM latency (probably faster fill-rates and other microbenchmarks important to gaming), all at 107W instead of 150W.

---------

As such, Rx 480 would be a better mining card, while 6500 XT would be a worse mining card, but better video game card.

Its still stupid for AMD to market their cards like this, but they're not lying... (and whatever argument marketing wants to make... well... that's their job. It all looks stupid to me but I can't honestly call them out on it since it is true...)

-------

Turns out that video-gamers who want more uniformity and less jitter between frames want higher-clock speeds (notice the 2000+ MHz clock speed on 6500 XT) rather than raw TFLOPs (Rx 480 ran a slow clock of ~1000MHz but had many more compute units / SIMD units computing in parallel).

Width of GPU leads to more variance, because its harder to load-balance your parallelism. If you have a narrower GPU (fewer compute units) at higher speeds, its easier to reach more consistent frame times / less jitter.

Re:Radeon RX 6500 XT is bad at cryptocurrency mining on purp... by NikolaNovak on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @05:14PM (#29898895)
Further, given the prices of RX480 and modern video cards, even if they were on par, if you can actually GET RX6500XT for $200 today, then:

1. It sucks from big picture perspective, as we are "back where we were 5 years ago"

but

2. It's great from pragmatic perspective, as we are otherwise today in "Wish I could afford a card from 5 years ago" / "there's no such thing as a budget GPU" stage.

Re:Radeon RX 6500 XT is bad at cryptocurrency mining on purp... by YXNjaGVyZWdlbgo on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @05:18PM (#29898966)
If we look at the benchmarks of the 5500XT vs the RX480 I expect it to maybe be 5-8% faster if at all. AMD basically released this card 3 times now but this time they scrubbed the whole encoding feature set.
Re:Radeon RX 6500 XT is bad at cryptocurrency mining on purp... by dragontamer on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @05:25PM (#29899098)
> AMD basically released this card 3 times now but this time they scrubbed the whole encoding feature set.

Do you not see the difference between GCN, RDNA, and RDNA 2?

At a minimum, this RDNA 2 6500 XT has raytracing cores that the two previous versions do not have. I'd assume that most video gamers care more about the raytracing feature (especially as more and more games are using it) than H265 encoding.

Remember: Raytracing instructions were invented on RDNA2. The 5500 doesn't have it, and the 480 doesn't have it.

-------

I mean, seriously. Would you rather have the existence of this card? Or the non-existence? If you want something faster, that's why the 6800 exists. This 6500 XT is for people who want a barely-gaming ready card at the cheapest possible price. If that's not your use case, then don't buy the card.

But every now and then, I build a computer for a child who doesn't play many video games, or for some uncle/aunt who doesn't know much about computers. I never like the idea of going iGPU only, because these people inevitably find at least one weird game that they like to play. So I like to put in a $100 to $200-class card in there. Not expensive enough to break the budget, but high enough that it'd perform decently on 10-year-old games and maybe a few indie-games.

Re:Radeon RX 6500 XT is bad at cryptocurrency mining on purp... by YXNjaGVyZWdlbgo on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @05:28PM (#29899146)
Are you suggesting that you could use Raytracing at all in modern games on a low end card like the RX 6500 XT? If you would use it you would lose the marginal performance increase of the updated architecture. Also content creation is a big point for younger generation if it is livestreaming, recording clips or general gameplay. This will both not be doable with this card if you don't have a good cpu. There is no discussion that more cards are good in the market we have right now. The card is 50% over MSRP right now at most retailers.
Re:Radeon RX 6500 XT is bad at cryptocurrency mining on purp... by dragontamer on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @05:30PM (#29899181)
> Are you suggesting that you could use Raytracing at all in modern games on a low end card like the RX 6500 XT?

Yes?

Minecraft Raytracing and Quake Raytracing are rather low-specs and probably would run on an RX 6500 XT. You might have to drop down to 720p but it probably would run.

Re:Radeon RX 6500 XT is bad at cryptocurrency mining on purp... by terafo on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @06:06PM (#29899713)
Are you kidding? These are fully path traced games and they are extremely hard to render. RDNA2 cards are worse in raytracing titles than Nvidia cards. For example 6900xt is half as performant in Minecraft RTX compared to 3090(18FPS vs 40FPS) according to LTT tests(testing was in 4k). And according to random tests I saw on Youtube. RX6600 outputs around 6fps with RTX enabled in 1080p, and it's basically 50% stronger. Not sure about 720p, but I would be surprised if it 5500XT gets to 10FPS at that resolution.
Re:Radeon RX 6500 XT is bad at cryptocurrency mining on purp... by ElectricalUnion on Wednesday January 12, 2022 @08:22AM (#29905993)
> Minecraft Raytracing and Quake Raytracing are rather low-specs and probably would run on an RX 6500 XT.

[citation needed]

Strictly speaking, it will "run", but if it run well that's another thing entirely.

It was the reason why the meme for heavy game morphed to "but can it run Minecraft RT?" for a while.

Re:Radeon RX 6500 XT is bad at cryptocurrency mining on purp... by YXNjaGVyZWdlbgo on Tuesday January 11, 2022 @05:39PM (#29899315)
Minecraft release 18 November 2011. Quake release June 22, 1996.

They may have frankensteined the engines to support ray tracing but these are not modern games at all.