I don't think English as a duck typed system works either. You can make a logical leap in an argument and nothing crashes. Many people have made very successful careers based on logical leaps, in fact.
But you can't make leaps with computers. If you forget to tell the computer which file to load, it either crashes, or nothing happens.
The key line for me is "... it's hard to use metaphors in writing. It's simply more abstract." I have this working theory that abstraction in programming language is more or less equivalent to metaphor in person language. The core idea behind metaphors is to create a convenient lie that helps expose some aspect of what you're talking about by comparing it to some other domain. Consider my last paragraph. English has no type system. Telling you that it's duck typed is a lie, in the sense that it isn't true. But as a metaphor, it's convenient because lets me unify two ideas (programming languages and regular languages) under one aspect (things that have degrees of rigor). Similarly, having an abstraction over local files and network files lets me take two things that are accessed very differently, and let me pretend they're the same. It's a lie, but it works.
I'm not really sure how the abstraction==metaphor relation holds under closer scrutiny. I'm also not certain that it's particularly useful in terms of helping me make better programs, but I like it.