News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:LucasFilm Tells Darth Vader that Return of the Jedi Hasn’... by jessriedel on Monday September 12, 2011 @10:21AM (#2987375)
The point wasn't the amount of good being done with the money, it was the size of the sacrifice being made as it affects the life of the donor.

Likewise, suppose I donate 5% of my income to charity A which is 100 times as effective at saving lives as charity B. My neighbor, of similar means, donates 50% of his income to charity B because of his mistaken belief that charity B is just as good. Now, I may know he's making a mistake, and there's no way I would choose to send my money to charity B, but my neighbor is still more honorable for making such a large sacrifice for something he thinks is right.

Re:LucasFilm Tells Darth Vader that Return of the Jedi Hasn’... by thebooktocome on Monday September 12, 2011 @11:30AM (#2987624)
That's a truly bizarre definition of honorable. If that's actually what being honorable actually means to people, then I no longer want to be there.

In my book, you don't get any points for merely thinking you're right. You only get points for actually being right.

Re:LucasFilm Tells Darth Vader that Return of the Jedi Hasn’... by chc on Monday September 12, 2011 @01:43PM (#2988159)
It makes no sense to judge people or award "points" for things wholly outside their control. As human beings, we aren't capable of perfect knowledge, and we don't have total control over most situations. So judging people on "actually being right" has limited utility. You may as well decide to slap a random stranger in retaliation for the weather being inclement.

For example: If Gandhi had been assassinated earlier, would that have made him a worse man?

Re:LucasFilm Tells Darth Vader that Return of the Jedi Hasn’... by khafra on Monday September 12, 2011 @12:43PM (#2987913)
He didn't say "effective." He said "honorable."