> I mean, does anyone really think that science grads are less business ready than business grads, and if so, why?
Yes, yes, a million times yes. A science education includes absolutely no training in finance, management, organization, public speaking, etc. While it is true that there are scientists who are great at public speaking or business, in almost all cases these individuals were good in those areas before they became educated in science. Furthermore, in my time working in research, I've come to appreciate that science graduates are absolute luddites in every realm of technology that is not directly involved in their own research. Anecdotally, I've watched researchers working on promising cures for Parkinson's have trouble logging into their Windows XP machine and others working on cancer-fighting nanoparticles unable to connect a printer to print their manuscripts.
Basic research can never compete in a capitalist economy because the profits of most research activities are realized on time scales greater than an individual lifetime and there is no monetary incentive (only altruistic incentives) to invest in something that will only pay out when you're dead.
So? Scientists often tackle problems that they don't have training in.
There seems to be 2 parts to the myth:
1) Scientists aren't suitable for business. I think this is crap. Mathematicians can do engineering and financial stuff, just not the final sign-off (which requires a licensed professional). Ecologists can analyse a company's strategic position, based on stuff like competition, symbiosis, and other buzz words that they actually understand. Psychologists could work in marketing. This is true for many pure research areas. It's may not be so true for applied research, like biochemistry - a lot of that could be very domain specific, but the tools they use could be applied elsewhere (if the number of graduates and number of research jobs doesn't match).
2) Scientists are doing more valuable work, they just aren't being rewarded. This is sometimes true, but sometimes not.
- former Ph.D. student in History.
History teaches all sorts of wonderful analytical skills that I use all the time as a start-up founder - it's great training for what I do.
However, by the time you make it a significant way into a Ph.D. program, you get ruined culturally - you end up thinking you're going to get a job in academia, or you're a complete failure.
Switching careers after your mid 20s feels like an impossible undertaking (it's not hard at all, but we're talking about feelings here), so you keep on slogging it out.
If you do come across some all-but-dissertation from a good program who actually wants to try new things, snap them up.
People with Arts degrees don't whinge about the lack of "Historian" positions, they just get jobs where they can utilize their amazing skills at churning out 5000 word faux-essays about why their cherry-picked positive paragraphs outnumber the negative paragraphs they threw in for "balance" (arts hater, sorry, but haters gotta hate). Maybe they are HR officers, or Marketing Stooges, or Strategic Analysts, or Project Officers, or even Software Engineers.
There seems to be an utterly moronic disconnect betweens science students who want a job with "research" in the title, and businesses who don't want to reach out to smart, hard-working, honest candidates.
Science students do have skills - the ability to read massive amounts of technically difficult work (for example, research articles, government regulations), math skills, statistics skills, and a deep understanding of physical and / or biological processes.
I understand that they don't want to head-hunt full professors into C-level positions, but surely there's some scope for people crossing over.
I mean, does anyone really think that science grads are less business ready than business grads, and if so, why?