I've interviewed enough programmers to know that the average talent level is absurdly low. But there are amazing people out there, at every level of seniority, who do 5 times more work than average, and keep doing it.
If you pay only a "little bit" more than market rates, you'll lose these people late in the hiring process, when they take an offer for 40% more at another company.
I generally put in twice the effort as a my boss on almost daily basis, I expect to be what he is now in half the time he took to be.
Why not just flatly pay them on the amount of work done, regardless where(location) they work.
The grim reality is that there is just no meaningful way to objectively measure the "amount of work done" by coders and the likes.
Let's imagine an absolutely top-notch consultant with excellent hard and soft skills that mesh nearly perfectly with your current and projected needs.
How much would you offer them if they lived in NYC, Detroit, or San Juan, PR?