News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Are We in a Bubble? by abeppu on Saturday January 08, 2022 @02:47PM (#29855425)
> yet we are in the middle of pandemic, millions get sick every day, inflation 30yr high

> is the economy is broken? should we be expecting a crash/crisis soon?

The question assumes that the real conditions on the ground are going to change the values we assign to stuff, but what if those are no longer meaningfully coupled?

Ford sold about 20% fewer vehicles at the end of 2021 than at the end of 2019, but its stock price is 2.5x what it was then. Ford is producing less actually useful stuff, but we pretend it's more valuable.

What if the economy is "broken" but not in a way which produces a "crash"? Prices are higher now, but many companies have improved margins; they're raising prices faster than their costs are increasing. Money is moving faster from the population at large to companies/investors. If the rich can keep getting richer by siphoning more out of everyone else, and the rich are the ones that own stock, real estate, invest in startups etc, then a lot of metrics can show those assets as increasing in value even if the median person's income or wealth are declining in real terms.

If the economies experienced by the rich and everyone else are decoupling, then I think the question is less "are we in a bubble" and more "will we enact reforms to decrease wealth and income inequality?" and at least in the US given structural political issues, I think the answer is "No."

Re:Ask HN: Are We in a Bubble? by fivea on Saturday January 08, 2022 @02:56PM (#29855511)
> What if the economy is "broken" but not in a way which produces a "crash"? Prices are higher now, but many companies have improved margins; they're raising prices faster than their costs are increasing.

There is a less charitable and more realistic explanation for that: quantitative easing injected a massive amount of cash into the economy, and low/negative interest rates are pushing said investors towards riskier investments to park all that cash. Consequently we see a massive volume of institutional investments in things like real estate, the stock market, and even crypto.

Re:Ask HN: Are We in a Bubble? by abeppu on Saturday January 08, 2022 @03:09PM (#29855638)
I'm fine with the claim that a lot more money was pushed into the asset classes you listed, but I don't really see how that interacts with the quote you picked about companies with improving margins. A company's stock being over-valued doesn't seem obviously related to their price-setting power?

And anyway, the result of that rush of money into stocks and real estate still seems to have had the result that the rich got richer. Yes, the Fed will raise interest rates in coming months, and perhaps eventually that will slow inflation. But I have every expectation that many companies will continue raising prices and reporting record profits for some time after their costs decline. And as interest rates increase, banks will reflect those higher rates in their loan products, but not their savings accounts, etc.

Re:Ask HN: Are We in a Bubble? by fivea on Sunday January 09, 2022 @06:13AM (#29862270)
> I don't really see how that interacts with the quote you picked about companies with improving margins.

Companies are being valuated with total disregard about their results.

The whole stock market is currently in deep memestock territory. We are seeing a single low-output car maker being valued more than the whole car industry altogether even though they exclusively serve a car market niche that only amounts for a single-digit market share of the global auto market.

Real estate is suddenly seeing an influx of institutional investment that hiked the demand so much it priced out the vast majority of families.

In crypto, everything is unashamedly driven by a mix of speculation and capital flight to an asset that's believed to be resilient to inflation and crashes.

We're fooling ourselves if we believe that we saw such a massive hike in efficiency in the past few years, specially given the global context. What we're seeing is a massive influx of free cash into the hands of institutional investors who are now desperate to park it somewhere.

Re:Ask HN: Are We in a Bubble? by bb88 on Saturday January 08, 2022 @06:35PM (#29857836)
Dotcoms in the late nineties. Mortgage speculation in 2004-2008ish. QE started in 2009.

Blaming it all on QE seems a little disingenuous. There's been way too much money floating in the system for a long time now.

Re:Ask HN: Are We in a Bubble? by lumost on Saturday January 08, 2022 @03:46PM (#29856022)
The tricky piece in the US is that it's unclear how long the current system can be sustained. As the wealthy become wealthier, debt loads must increase. Eventually, the debtors must curtail spending or fail to pay off the debt. In aggregate, this creates a financial crisis as debt is not paid back, and the creditor takes the loss.

What's happening today is that central banks are lowering interest rates to prevent the above reckoning from occurring. The wealthy get wealthier, debt loads increase, and interest rates fall. The orthodox economic belief would be that this will either create inflation and or a currency crisis as the economy structures itself around money printing. The surprise has been that inflation hasn't occurred outside of asset prices.

I suspect that this strictly leads to one of two outcomes.

- The economy rolls back all worker gains for the last century, with workers effectively forced to rent all assets and live paycheck to paycheck.

- Asset inflation eventually turns into real inflation via taxation, government spending, worker wage demands or changes in the spending habits of asset holders (Carnegie and Rockefeller eventually spent the majority of their fortunes). In this scenario, wages and prices are likely to catch-up with assets.

Re:Ask HN: Are We in a Bubble? by Qub3d on Saturday January 08, 2022 @08:32PM (#29858846)
> The surprise has been that inflation hasn't occurred outside of asset prices.

But it has occurred. People were originally calling it "short term" but its clear that the 6-7% inflation seen at the tail end of 2021 was very real.

As to your two outcomes:

I'd like to believe that the second one is what is sort of happening, with the "great resignation" of blue-collar and otherwise "unskilled" workers (its a term of art, I understand some of the jobs in this pool require a lot of finesse). Unfortunately, I also see lots of push from the top of the economic strata for the first outcome; most notably in the attempt to move from car ownership to ridesharing.

Re:Ask HN: Are We in a Bubble? by fivea on Sunday January 09, 2022 @06:31AM (#29862361)
> But it has occurred. People were originally calling it "short term" but its clear that the 6-7% inflation seen at the tail end of 2021 was very real.

I'm not sure those are related. I bet that was just one of the unintended consequences of stimulus checks in the US economy.

Keep in mind that poverty in the US is increasing like wildfire. In 2019, about 69% of Americans reported having less than $1000 in a savings accounts.

https://www.yahoo.com/now/survey-69-americans-less-1-1719272...

That falls well within living paycheck-to-paycheck territory, if not even below. This means the vast majority of Americans cannot afford luxuries or even basic necessities. Things haven't got better for the average Joe since 2019, too.

Then all of a sudden the whole country received a comparatively huge check in the mail to freely spend however they feel like it.

Expectedly, this sudden increase in disposable income and purchasing power will reflect in a hike in demand for the things being tracked by inflation índices. Increases in consumer demand lead to higher consumer prices, and thus inflation indicators go up.

Re:Ask HN: Are We in a Bubble? by lumost on Sunday January 09, 2022 @08:11AM (#29862902)
These could be more coupled than you would assume. When the government borrows freshly printed dollars and freely distributed the money, the velocity of money ticks up. When it’s borrowed for stock buybacks the velocity of money ticks down.

Effectively Covid stimulus may have forced the government to step in, releasing the inflation QEs been brewing.

Re:Ask HN: Are We in a Bubble? by fivea on Sunday January 09, 2022 @12:57PM (#29865681)
> Effectively Covid stimulus may have forced the government to step in, releasing the inflation QEs been brewing.

Not quite. QE created inflation in assets that are not a part of inflation indicators, at least directly, like stock and real estate. QE resulted in phenomena like Tesla's utterly absurd meteoric valuation during the past year.

There are some markets where QE and stimulus checks, such as rent prices, which mixes an increase in disposable income on the demand-side and a need to validate inflated investments in real estate on the supply-side.

Re:Ask HN: Are We in a Bubble? by Joeri on Saturday January 08, 2022 @03:46PM (#29856017)
Ford sold about 20% fewer vehicles at the end of 2021 than at the end of 2019, but its stock price is 2.5x what it was then. Ford is producing less actually useful stuff, but we pretend it's more valuable.

I've always heard the argument that stock price is not based on the current value but on future earnings. If the market perception is that Ford is better placed now than 2 years ago to make money in the coming decade, it should be valued higher. Similarly companies that are laying the groundwork for massive earnings post-pandemic should see a corresponding value uptick in the stock market.

Re:Ask HN: Are We in a Bubble? by Qub3d on Saturday January 08, 2022 @08:34PM (#29858865)
The maxim I was told by my dad, who I think got it from someone like Warren Buffet, is that, "In the short term, the stock market is a voting machine; in the long term, it is a weighing machine"

So for the day-to-day, week-to-week, etc movement of an asset or market, its primarily driven by the immediate feelings of the sellers and buyers. Longer term, however, its historically been fluctuations on top of a lower-frequency trend based on fundamentals.

Re:Ask HN: Are We in a Bubble? by zemptime on Saturday January 08, 2022 @03:13PM (#29855681)
There's a complex of people in Washington dedicated to defending the mechanisms which allow for the siphoning like FTD's (failure-to-deliver's), asset lending with no return dates, what is effectively asset lending by other legal names, and other things like exemptions for market makers being allowed to provide naked positions in the name of "liquidity."

This complex of people has a name (!) - "The Blob." It's the amorphous bureaucratic mass of people who will send vague and threatening letters to people actually attempting reform ("Dear Mr. Young Senator, we recommend you don't pursue your inquiry into naked shorting further, or it will be bad for your career.")

Then you have, diametrically opposed to the Blob, the $GME apes. Forget for a second about the mother of all short squeezes, "dying brick and mortar," "nfts," etc. The property worth paying attention to here is how antifragile and self-correcting the ape community is. Here you have tons of random, highly distributed and highly passionate people apprehending the real nature of our financial, media, and political institutions. You have a system where when the Blob pulls a fast one, a set of people who got in for a squeeze/quick profit are converted from a set of ambivalent retail traders into an intolerant minority whose focus has shifted from profit to "If we haven't achieved systemic change, we have failed."

The fight for reform is well underway. There's so much more to be said here but I'll end with this: even if you don't care or believe in $GME, believe in the apes. They're the individuals putting their skin in a the game and exposing themselves to harm for what they believe is right. Pay attention.

Re:Ask HN: Are We in a Bubble? by abeppu on Saturday January 08, 2022 @03:38PM (#29855941)
> converted from a set of ambivalent retail traders into an intolerant minority whose focus has shifted from profit to "If we haven't achieved systemic change, we have failed."

> They're the individuals putting their skin in a the game and exposing themselves to harm for what they believe is right. Pay attention.

I'm not familiar with this part of the story. Can you point me to more info? What are the actual goals of the systemic change being pursued, and how is it being pursued?

Re:Ask HN: Are We in a Bubble? by AutumnCurtain on Saturday January 08, 2022 @04:30PM (#29856496)
I would save your time. The "apes" are bagholding on a pump and dump. The reason they want "systemic change" now is because the fortune they promised GME investors would make has never and will never materialize, and the only way to continue evangelizing is to sell the stock of a failing physical video game retailer as your ticket to some kind of brave new world.
Re:Ask HN: Are We in a Bubble? by zemptime on Sunday January 09, 2022 @09:44AM (#29863642)
I'm personally attracted to this investment not because of squeeze potential but because I believe they're going to corner the online used games market & open up new business models for smaller game devs. First mover in a major way.

https://gmedd.com/

If you truly believe what you're spouting here, then - have you shorted it?

Re:Ask HN: Are We in a Bubble? by zemptime on Saturday January 08, 2022 @04:27PM (#29856477)
I can't directly speak for the autonomous groups of people in loose orbit around https://old.reddit.com/r/Superstonk/ who can be labelled the apes (I know for sure there are other groups but this is an easily accessible one), but what I've observed:

Goals:

  Elimination of FTD's, period. Market participants who FTD regularly are ejected.
  Information symmetry between blob & retail - true regular reporting on short positions, Swaps, other derivatives. Teeth for this.
  Increase in reporting penalties to be less than a cost of doing business.
  T+3 Settlement to T+0.
  Widespread usage of implementations like IEX to eliminate profitability of low-latency arbitrage.
How:

  Routing orders through IEX
  Exiting brokers who are simply bad for retail (Robinhood)
  Withdrawing equities from the DTCC accounts and broker dealer system as a vote of no-confidence (GME recently stated 5m+ individual had directly registered their shares w/ transfer agent as of Oct 31... and put it on their 10-Q, making them only company I'm aware of to have done that in past year).
  Suing brokers/applying regulation pressure to those who don't allow basic rights (direct share registration from europe)
  Actual monitoring of which brokers are dipping their hands in their customer's cookie jars (see: Fidelity a couple months ago suddenly posting 10m+ shares available to borrow in a very illiquid stock. Where could those have come from? Customer's cash accounts? Oh, it's not *lending*, it's *posting as collateral*? etc)
  Signal boosting for existing, honorable efforts: Dennis Kelleher @ https://bettermarkets.org/ / Susanne Trimbath
  Awareness & localized support of legislation
  Filing FINRA complaints, getting in touch with compliance officers, actually watching & asking.
The beauty and confusion here is, you just have a lot of people learning and teaching each other. Over time, they learn more and do more things.

I'd say probably most valuable at this point in time is the mixture of identified and pseudonymous journalism increasing financial literacy/awareness of just how... pardon my french, fucking bad, the existing incentive structures are w/r/t regulators. Good example: https://upsidechronicles.com/2021/09/05/how-wall-street-shor...

Suspect most valuable long-term will be the mass direct registration of shares in individuals book names rather than beneficiary ownership through a broker. If/when the apes have directly registered all available shares, 1) any significant amount of continued trading volume in lit markets is fraudulent and you have a slam-dunk legal case. 2) GME could legally exit participating in the DTCC and move onto a crypto-run automated market maker which meets all of the above goals. Any synthetic GME positions floating around would have to be immediately and forcibly closed, and there's a lot of material research on how the real number of shares floating around might be on the order of magnitude of 1 billion. Big problems for the blob.

Re:Ask HN: Are We in a Bubble? by wolverine876 on Saturday January 08, 2022 @04:10PM (#29856317)
> but what if those are no longer meaningfully coupled?

This is said in every bubble. The laws of economics cannot be repealed, but people keep imagining it's different this time.

In the dot-com bubble, people were saying that profits didn't matter anymore. You might think that's an exaggeration, but if you think such exaggerations are impossible, look around you.

Re:Ask HN: Are We in a Bubble? by jdkee on Saturday January 08, 2022 @09:07PM (#29859116)
S&P 500 price-to-earnings about double historical average would indicate at least over valuation of stocks.

https://www.multpl.com/s-p-500-pe-ratio

Re:Ask HN: Are We in a Bubble? by hiq on Monday January 10, 2022 @05:25PM (#29883714)
I think the cyclically adjusted version is even more telling: https://www.multpl.com/shiller-pe
Re:Ask HN: Are We in a Bubble? by ip26 on Saturday January 08, 2022 @08:01PM (#29858591)
Ford is the only legacy US auto with a convincing entrance into EVs. Has their market cap risen for no reason- or is the market predicting they will take share from their less agile competitors?
Re:Ask HN: Are We in a Bubble? by uh_uh on Saturday January 08, 2022 @04:03PM (#29856227)
But now even the rich are pulling out. Musk, Bezos, Zuck have all upped their stock sales. Zillow also stopped ibuying. At least some non-permabear participants think that something is brewing now.
Re:Ask HN: Are We in a Bubble? by abeppu on Saturday January 08, 2022 @04:49PM (#29856694)
Isn't Musk's increased stock sale to facilitate the exercise of expiring options? That doesn't seem like "pulling out".

Zillow stopped ibuying, but a lot of post-hoc analysis seemed to explain that ibuying can do poorly even if real estate is doing well, because the owners most likely to sell to Zillow were ones with properties that were overvalued by Zillow's model, due to attributes that the model didn't consider.

Re:Ask HN: Are We in a Bubble? by uh_uh on Saturday January 08, 2022 @04:57PM (#29856783)
The narrative was that Musk is selling stocks to cover his taxes. But he's selling more than that: https://www.cnbc.com/2021/11/16/taxes-arent-the-only-reason-...
Re:Ask HN: Are We in a Bubble? by avrionov on Saturday January 08, 2022 @06:18PM (#29857668)
Musk can't just sell shares. People like him file a schedule with FCC in advance and sell based on the schedule. His tweets were misleading.
Re:Ask HN: Are We in a Bubble? by uh_uh on Saturday January 08, 2022 @07:55PM (#29858548)
So? You can still infer whether he's doing that to cover taxes or not.
Re:Ask HN: Are We in a Bubble? by rhacker on Saturday January 08, 2022 @03:24PM (#29855793)
the 20% drop is highly likely anticipation for the lightning. why buy ice when you can buy a bev?