I got news for ya bud. There's weapons everywhere, and governments have the resources to make them, thorium reactor or not. Extremists have the drive to source them, thorium or not. Hell, Brevik proved that. Should we ban fertilizer too?
I've been a Thorium advocate for a long time and have commented about it on HN.
You know what the single largest impediment to rapid adoption of Thorium to solve some of our energy problems? It's the existing nuclear power industry.
Since 2008, Sen. Orrin Hatch, R-Utah, and Sen. Harry Reid, D-Nevada., have introduced bills that would direct thorium research begin at the Idaho National Laboratory. We had prototype plants built in the fifties that ran as late as the seventies. There was even a Thorium powered jet fighter in the early fifties. They need $200 million to commercialize the technology and produce a sample pilot plant blueprint and have been met by a wall of lobbying by firms such as General Electric opposing the bill.
you can't have your yellowcake and eat it too : if the propeller heads want to feed uranium-cycle waste to thorium reactors, there's an implicit WMD risk, both the risk of diversion for weapons production as well as providing a rationale for the ongoing operation of dual-use enrichment and reprocessing plants. Thorium fuelled reactors could also be used to irradiate uranium to produce weapon grade plutonium.
And the use of thorium as a nuclear fuel alone doesn't solve the WMD proliferation problem. Irradiation of thorium indirectly produces uranium-233, a fissile material which can be used in nuclear weapons. The US has successfully tested weapons using uranium-233. France is suspected of it. India's thorium program prolly has a WMD component - given they refuse to allow IAEA safeguards to apply.
but the worst threat of the thorium reactors is that we'll be fooled into judging the real threats and impacts currently posed by the uranium fuel cycle on the ambitious standards promised by the thorium advocates. The nuclear industry has been over-promising and under-performing for too long - we can't afford to allow their promises for tomorrow to deter focus from today's bitter realities.