Prices did go down 30%, but it took ten years, not one. http://gigaom.com/cleantech/solar-costs-dropped-30-over-last...
This is my problem with solar energy. It's getting better. It isn't price-competitive with coal yet. There are already lots of niche applications. But people can't maintain a healthy skepticism about it because it's such a feel-good technology.
To wit, the US government loaned $535 million to Solyndra at about the same time LBNL released that report. Now they're broke and the FBI raided their offices a few days ago. Where else could a company borrow half a billion dollars without ever showing a profit?
In comparison, the entire projected cost for the solar updraft tower that the Southern California Public Power Authority is building is under $30 million.
ETA - No replies yet, but plenty of downvotes. I hope to be corrected if I'm wrong, of course. I tried to find credible sources for what I've said here. I can't source my claim that solar power is an issue where people pay more attention to feelings than facts. You can't prove something like that. But people are downvoting, and they aren't answering...
links:
http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/washington/2011/02/solyndra-...
http://abcnews.go.com/Blotter/fbi-raids-connected-energy-fir...
on the updraft tower (which is an awesome piece of engineering):
http://www.scppa.org/pages/projects/lapaz_solartower.html
http://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/enviromission-se...
Nice job picking out-of-date numbers.
Moore's law for solar:
http://blogs.scientificamerican.com/guest-blog/2011/03/16/sm...
If the 2010 and 2011 data was on the charts it would show an even steeper decline.
ETA:
This?
Averaged over 30 years, the trend is for an annual 7 percent reduction in the dollars per watt of solar photovoltaic cells. While in the earlier part of this decade prices flattened for a few years, the sharp decline in 2009 made up for that and put the price reduction back on track. Data from 2010 (not included above) shows at least a 30 percent further price reduction, putting solar prices ahead of this trend.
An average of seven percent per year for 30 years, then a breakthrough year in 2009 (which is well-documented). Then the author -- whose resume includes Microsoft, a company doing "nanotechnology research," and writing some books about transhumanism -- claims another good year in 2010, and you claim a third in 2011.
In other words, the author wants to extrapolate an exponential trend 10 or 20 years into the future based on (at best) 3 data points, while ignoring another trend that's been operating ten times longer.
And he could be right. Technologies do change growth regimes sometimes. But you don't make that argument by talking about the magic of exponential growth. You make it by talking about why all the rules are changing now.
Instead, he says "manufacturers are learning how to reduce the cost to fabricate solar." He doesn't say how, or how long they can keep it up. Then he throws out a paragraph about increasing efficiency ("in the lab," which could mean anything). Then he goes back to electricity prices in 2030.
Obviously, I hope he's right. But that article doesn't do much to refute my claim that solar power is over-hyped by people people who seem to think hype is OK for a good cause.
You can't predict how great the 10th generation of a product will be without knowing how the other 9 were
In response, you call me out for attacking solar power (pointing out bad parts), and being inconsistent about it (pointing out good parts).
So this reply looks like an example of the black-and-white thinking about solar power that I was complaining about above. I say "looks like" because I don't understand your second sentence. I agree with the all the facts you brought up, but I don't see the point of mentioning them. Please correct me if I'm missing something.
That works out of $3500/kW, which seems to be on par with construction costs for recent nuclear power plants (according to Wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economics_of_new_nuclear_power_...)
Of course, limiting the comparison to construction costs is silly.
And an advantage of tidal compared to most (all?) other renewables is that it is completely predictable.
There are downsides, especially to do with ecological effects/damage during construction and operation.
Efficiently moving power from one place to another is the big problem - the 'smart grid' is forever over the horizon - but storage only becomes a big problem after we have switched a massive amount of our energy production to solar and we're a long way off from that. Until then we just need to build a better system to move power from constant output plants to areas served by transient power sources.
Umm, no. They do that because of customers and "night is colder".
Agriculture, specifically pumping water, is an example that supports your argument.
> Energy usage at night is far smaller than during the day, so much so that we have an excess at night because of all the plants with constant output.
Until we start charging lots of electric cars then....
NY: http://www.nyseg.com/YourHome/pricingandrates/daynighrate.ht...
VT: https://www.burlingtonelectric.com/page.php?pid=49&name=...
The difference is almost 30%.
And that's only the tip of the iceberg. When you look at the area around most ski hills, the mountain is sucking more electricity during snowmaking season than everyone else in the area combined. When you are that big, the power company shows up and negotiates everything. Rates, times, usage caps, etc. The mountain can afford to buy its own generators (or diesel powered pumps/compressors) so the power company has a good reason to cut them a deal, but like every negotiation both sides want something and the power company is looking for someone to buy its excess constant capacity.
The relationship is so tight that the power company will call up the mountain and offer a lower daily rate based on usage elsewhere and the mountain will make snow accordingly.
http://www.usatoday.com/weather/news/2006-12-10-vermont-snow...
Fair enough.
> it's published on the power company website.
Hold it - those cites just say that night rates are lower. They don't say that lower rates are "the sole reason why they are not making snow 24/7", let alone the only reason why ski resorts run their snow machines at night (which was the original claim).
I don't know what fraction of a ski-resort's expenses go to power for snow-making. Do you?
The fraction that goes to power goes to the question whether day-time vs night time actually makes a difference that matters. For example, saving 100% of 1% is only 1%. I doubt that a ski resort would risk pissing off customers to save 1%.
For example, it may well be that day-time made snow is inferior, or that the transion layer from day-time made snow to night time made snow annoys skiiers. (IIRC, most natural snowfall is at night.)
We would need to pump water in all lakes about 408m high to have 7 day worth of reserves for USA.”
http://physics.ucsd.edu/do-the-math/2011/08/nation-sized-bat...
So you actually only need to use 0.1% of all lakes.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pumped-storage_hydroelectricity
$ per m² is important, too. Reason is that, the lower prices get, the greater the fraction of installation costs that are not due to the price of the solar cells themselves. Those costs scale with panel area, not with power output, and they do not sink.
Density of power is what matters in the long run. We need a solution that produces the most power for the given space it occupies. Hence, it's not a question of 'if' we use fission, it's a question of 'when'.
Think about the insane size of the inverters you would need to power the grid off of a DC battery.
Instead you use cheaper types of energy during the night, and avoid the natural gas. Then during peak usage you fire up your natural gas battery and run a turbine.
Nuclear power is the future. Ideally, the reactor should be a long ways from any valuable real estate, like at least 90,000,000 miles.
Fortunately, recievers that receive beamed power from the big fusion reactor are dropping in price at a rate of 30% per year. That fact makes VC funding of thorium reactor technology problematic.