Re:Gambler’s Fallacy and the Regression to the Mean
by psyc on Saturday January 08, 2022 @12:28PM
(#29853855)
> Why should this be discarded?
Well, it's a restatement of the Gambler's Fallacy, but I'll taboo using that as an argument because it begs the question (but for reals!)
I thought about this for a while, and here's the best I can do for right now. It's like winning the MegaMillions lottery on Saturday, and then winning $1 on a scratch ticket on Sunday. You'd go running around screaming on Saturday, but you wouldn't on Sunday. (Would you?) Because the impossible already happened. Hitting $1 on a scratch-off is never remarkable (unless you're 8), including on the day after you won the MegaMillions. It's just a somewhat anti-climactic coincidence.
Well, kind of. There are 2^6 patterns with 6 tosses, and only a few of them have some recognizable pattern (are compressible). HHHHHH is the worst of them. It might be "equally likely" to any other 6-toss pattern seen from a fair coin, but it's also a great example to make one suspect a totally rigged (same sided H) coin.
Now, on average a fair coin would have roughly balanced H and T. So the (much more numerous and thus probable) series where H and T are mixed (e.g. HTTHHT..., HTHTHH..., etc...), are more probable than a large streak of H.
>The probability that there will be one T somewhere in the sequence is a lot higher than the probability that there will be no T. That's only because there are a lot of somewheres for the T to be, but only one way for there to be no T.
A, my sentiments exactly!
>But once you have already seen 99 H, you still have precisely zero information about the next fair flip, and there's no way around it.
That's my argument: you don't have zero information.
You know that the next fair flip is random - sure.
But you also have the information that large series of tosses end up balanced in the long run, which is a kind of push (given fairness) towards making a T after tons of Hs increasingly likely.
Why should this be discarded?