News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Paxos by tombert on Thursday January 06, 2022 @03:54PM (#29829994)
> Lamport did comment on it (via email) saying that understanding Paxos is less important than proving it works (via TLA+).

I suppose that's not wrong; if I know for a fact that something is going to behave how I expect it too, I don't generally care how it works. I can treat the algorithm as a black box and just go from there.

That said, I dont' completely agree. If I am implementing Paxos in NewLangOfTheMonth, it's likely that a straight one-to-one port of another version will not fully work due to tiny differences in the language semantics. If I don't understand Paxos, then it's unlikely I'll be able to correct any mistakes in the implementation.

Re:Paxos by uvdn7 on Thursday January 06, 2022 @07:52PM (#29833127)
Yeah I agree. I think understanding the protocol makes it much less likely to introduce protocol level bugs during implementation. E.g. why certain steps need to be done in certain order.
Re:Paxos by skrtskrt on Thursday January 06, 2022 @06:02PM (#29831836)
Agreed, being able to trust it is probably what I want in order to use it at my job to get shit done - being able to understand it/implement it is what I want to do on my own time.

Unless you're one of the rare group who gets paid to implement it in x language/library/technology, it's more of a mental exercise than anything, something nice to go "ahhh cool!" when you understand it, then move on.