Re:Breakthrough: The Secret to Making Processors 1,000 Times...
by jackfoxy on Saturday September 10, 2011 @06:52PM
(#2982711)
How about L1 cache (or even just L3 cache) measured in gigabytes? That won't increase the execution speed of individual instructions, but your effective processing power would increase dramatically.
Re:Breakthrough: The Secret to Making Processors 1,000 Times...
by ori_b on Saturday September 10, 2011 @07:31PM
(#2982785)
The problem is that as cache size gets bigger, the associative memory lookup gets slower. There's a tradeoff.
Re:Breakthrough: The Secret to Making Processors 1,000 Times...
by spp on Saturday September 10, 2011 @08:03PM
(#2982838)
What? Why is this, isn't memory indexed for direct access?
Re:Breakthrough: The Secret to Making Processors 1,000 Times...
by ori_b on Saturday September 10, 2011 @08:18PM
(#2982864)
We're talking about cache, where the addresses of blocks in cache do not have a 1:1 mapping with addresses in memory.
Read the section on associativity: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CPU_cache
Re:Breakthrough: The Secret to Making Processors 1,000 Times...
by sparky on Saturday September 10, 2011 @08:39PM
(#2982887)
You get to choose your associativity, you could build a direct-mapped 1GB L1 cache if you wanted. More fundamentally, a memory's access time grows with its capacity because the average and worst-case distances from a bitcell to the read/write port are longer.
Re:Breakthrough: The Secret to Making Processors 1,000 Times...
by rbanffy on Saturday September 10, 2011 @09:25PM
(#2982952)
If you pack enough memory in the same package and connect it to the CPU through a bus that's fast enough, on-chip memory that used to be used for caches can get promoted to main memory and off-chip RAM becomes a fast cache for your SSDs and a way to synchronize context between different chip stacks.
Put the GPU and VRAM on the stack and all you need is a couple HDMI ports going out of the chip.
Re:Breakthrough: The Secret to Making Processors 1,000 Times...
by keeperofdakeys on Saturday September 10, 2011 @11:42PM
(#2983136)
Cache is already about as fast as you can get without significant compromises in size. L1 cache runs at speeds fast enough that increasing the size (and average seek time), or increasing the distance the signal has to travel, will decrease access times significantly. So it doesn't become about how 'fast' the bus is, or how much memory you can pack on.
Re:Breakthrough: The Secret to Making Processors 1,000 Times...
by rbanffy on Saturday September 10, 2011 @11:58PM
(#2983167)
Putting a good chunk of memory between the processor and the external memory bus would allow interconnection through a much faster bus than the external one, reducing the penalty of a cache miss.
Re:Breakthrough: The Secret to Making Processors 1,000 Times...
by sliverstorm on Sunday September 11, 2011 @01:06AM
(#2983262)
The two of you are arguing about different things. You are arguing the point of increasing cache to reduce misses. The other guy is arguing that increasing cache size will degrade cache performance as a unit. These are distinct arguments.
Re:Breakthrough: The Secret to Making Processors 1,000 Times...
by sliverstorm on Saturday September 10, 2011 @07:08PM
(#2982731)
This makes me think of an interesting question- the back side of a die is raw silicon. How do you stack die and still interconnect? Do you sink metal through the bottom of the wafer?
Re:Breakthrough: The Secret to Making Processors 1,000 Times...
by sparky on Saturday September 10, 2011 @08:35PM
(#2982880)
Yes, through-silicon vias are metal-plated holes that go clear through the wafer ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Through-silicon_via ).
Stacking stuff means you should be able to run cooler for the same amount of processing power.
1000x? I think that's probably BS. But I can see this being a significant win.