This is not a troll, and it is not inflammatory. It is reasonable discourse and an opposing view. These kinds of things are required for intellectual honesty.
It's especially ironic because the post starts out with a quote from pg:
I actually worry a lot that as I get "popular" I'll be able to get away with saying stupider stuff than I would have dared say before. This sort of thing happens to a lot of people, and I would really* like to avoid it*
Whichever moderator killed that link, and anyone downvoting this guy - high quality discussion allows reasonable minds to disagree. Censoring it because it is about pg is perpetuating the very problem pg describes.
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=982832
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1048849
Kindof hilarious actually. idlewords finishes by calling pg a "weenis".
Yes I thought the crude insults were indicative of the quality of the post as a whole.
Maciej was mocking Paul's use of the same name-calling he professes to despise.
(That probably sounds like some kind of passive-aggressive complaint about the fact that hans00 got banned, so let me add that after looking through his comments I think his net contribution was solidly negative on account of his gratuitously obnoxious tone.)
Also, the linked blog post didn't strike me as very convincing. The points that were potentially valid ("Start with purpose" paragraph and reference 4) were underdeveloped and most of it read like a rant.
Probably worth linking to here.
While I enjoy pg's writing and I think the essays convey a good message in spirit, I do think there's quite a substantial populist aspect to some of them.
I'm glad I read all of them, but if I had to choose, I'd probably get On Lisp in deadtree format first.