News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to Write about Africa (2019) by rayiner on Monday January 03, 2022 @01:00PM (#29783884)
Blooming unstable governments on colonialism requires more evidence than is offered. Most people in the Indian subcontinent, where I’m from, perceive British colonialism as positive with respect to government, institutions, and rule of law. Former colonies like Hong Kong and Singapore have developed into thriving civilizations.
Re:How to Write about Africa (2019) by quadrifoliate on Monday January 03, 2022 @03:09PM (#29785964)
I am also from the Indian subcontinent. A lot of this derives from the fact that the British uprooted a bunch of existing monarchies, replaced them with Governmental institutions run according to Anglo-Saxon norms, and then left rather suddenly in 1947 saying “You run it” to a set of countries with geographical and population size comparable to Europe; with equivalent if not more linguistic and cultural diversity.

I think colonialism gets blamed because it's the closest external thing in time that can be blamed. Counterexamples like Singapore get bandied around, but the difference between a state the size of Singapore and something like India or Bangladesh is staggering enough to make the comparison essentially useless.

It is an interesting thought experiment to imagine what the consequences would have been of a more gradual transition away from British rule in the Indian subcontinent. My imperfect amateur historical study makes me think it would have been a net positive, but potentially would have led to partition into at least 5-6 different independent states before they did leave for good.

Re:How to Write about Africa (2019) by rayiner on Monday January 03, 2022 @05:38PM (#29788012)
My point is that India and Bangladesh were colonies as well, but they are quite a bit more functional than your typical African country.

You have a fair point that African countries have more diversity than Singapore, but that begs the question-what makes diversity a bad thing?

Re:How to Write about Africa (2019) by quadrifoliate on Monday January 03, 2022 @06:10PM (#29788407)
> You have a fair point that African countries have more diversity than Singapore

I don't say anything about African countries in my comment, that must be from upthread.

But I would think that most African countries are also at a scale different from Singapore's; enough to just make Singaporean solutions unworkable. This does not mean that it's a bad thing, just different. If one were to press the point, I'd say that scaling anything up is just harder – this applies to nation states just as it does to websites.

> India and Bangladesh were colonies as well, but they are quite a bit more functional than your typical African country.

I am not entirely sure this is true if you consider the rural parts. Rural India (with 65% of the population) has more in common with most African countries than it does with anywhere in the West. A large part of this is due to the fact that the British never had any interest in settling there in large numbers; and consequently never invested significant efforts into building infrastructure for the rural parts. They preferred to strike deals with existing power structures that allowed them to profiteer off the land. I could reasonably see African countries having similar problems given their relatively low population density in the 19th and 20th centuries.

Re:How to Write about Africa (2019) by selimthegrim on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @06:27PM (#29802477)
I remember reading the memoirs of an ICS official (Asok Mitra, not the Marxist economist but the chief census commissioner) around the time of Partition that claimed British leaving was worse for the rural areas at that time because at least they inspected and made sure public services were working.
Re:How to Write about Africa (2019) by ashwagary on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @06:34AM (#29793722)
There are obvious problems with comparing a continent to a country but most African countries have lower poverty rates than India.
Re:How to Write about Africa (2019) by chillacy on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @03:06PM (#29799588)
Even Lee Kwan Yee the Singaporean PM said that he was grateful that if Sg was colonized, it was the British instead of the French or Belgians for instance. The British established institutions and provided a smooth transition… compared to the French or Belgian colonies.
Re:How to Write about Africa (2019) by tptacek on Monday January 03, 2022 @02:44PM (#29785507)
Are you asking for evidence that colonialism was damaging to African governance? Or just for evidence that British colonialism was?
Re:How to Write about Africa (2019) by rayiner on Monday January 03, 2022 @05:40PM (#29788046)
I’m asking for evidence that colonialism caused African governments to be unstable. If Africa hasn’t been colonized, what would the continent be full of countries with stable governments today?
Re:How to Write about Africa (2019) by ashwagary on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @06:26AM (#29793671)
Sad this basic history is not known by the taxpayers that actually fund it... If a democratically elected African leader isnt willing to play ball, he is assassinated, usually by ex-colonial powers (Patrice Lumumba and dozens of others come to mind). So even if the locals want something better, mercenaries will be sent in to deliver the opposite.

Similarly, assassinating George Washington and the founding fathers would've affected the trajectory of the US and it would seem silly to ask why...

Re:How to Write about Africa (2019) by kspacewalk2 on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @09:32AM (#29795130)
Lumumba's assassination took place 60 years ago. One would think that's ample time to at least partially recover from its aftermath, since assassinations during civil strife are hardly unique to the Congo, especially as a new state. While Belgians took part in the assassination, it wasn't like it took place in a peaceful country, out of the blue. There was a power struggle over who will be the Congo's strongman, and Lumumba/pro-Soviets lost. So in this case, different groups of locals wanted different kinds of betters, or at least what they thought would be better.

While it's certainly true that a number of new African states fell victim to the twists and turns of the Cold War (both sides having partook quite liberally), your theory fails to explain what happened to the states where there was little to no interference.

The Congo is actually a perfect example of having relatively soft colonial rule (the Belgian state took over from the king in 1910s and gradually made the colonial rule a lot less brutal than the horror of the Congo Free State) being replaced way too suddenly with... something. Since there was nothing that could pass for a semi-coherent national elite to speak of, even compared to most other African colonies, it's no wonder the Congo fell into conflict almost immediately. It would be rather odd if that didn't happen, Cold War or no Cold war.

Re:How to Write about Africa (2019) by ashwagary on Thursday January 06, 2022 @06:32AM (#29822294)
>your theory fails to explain what happened to the states where there was little to no interference.

I'm excited to hear about these African countries that had complete autonomy, please name some.

>While Belgians took part in the assassination, it wasn't like it took place in a peaceful country, out of the blue.

One must have an extremely warped world view to be able to look at Belgium and Congo on a world map and handwave away the assassination of a popular leader due to his antiexploitative economic views.

Some here buy the false narrative that most westerners are in Africa doing charity, I can tell... The reality is Africa is the largest net creditor to western nations and Africans have been forced to send charity TO Europe and the US for a few centuries now. Almost every foreign-funded assassination is tied to resource theft, your framing seems to ignore that Elephant in the Room on purpose.

Re:How to Write about Africa (2019) by sangnoir on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @04:07PM (#29800526)
> ...your theory fails to explain what happened to the states where there was little to no interference

Which ones would those be? If you could name a couple, I'd be willing to research and point out interference in the past 2 generations, if any.

Re:How to Write about Africa (2019) by rayiner on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @12:35PM (#29797415)
Just another form of “it’s the white people’s fault.” Doesn’t seem like nearly enough CIA assassinations happening for that to be the reason.
Re:How to Write about Africa (2019) by tptacek on Monday January 03, 2022 @06:10PM (#29788413)
I don't know, but I can't help but notice that your examples of colonies considered long-term beneficial are all British, and, obviously, Africa was not colonized exclusively by the British. It wasn't the British who, in the 20th century, chopped off the hands and castrated rubber farmers who couldn't make their quotas.

For that matter, India gained independence in 1947; Singapore in 1959. Africa was colonized into the 1970s.

Re:How to Write about Africa (2019) by rayiner on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @12:39PM (#29797459)
> It wasn't the British who, in the 20th century, chopped off the hands and castrated rubber farmers who couldn't make their quotas.

So is that the reason governments in African countries are unstable? Castrated rubber farmers?

Re:How to Write about Africa (2019) by sangnoir on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @04:16PM (#29800651)
I know you're being snarky, but the answer is yes. Once a country establishes a norm that the authority is never to be questioned (under pain of castration), subsequent governments will follow the same path and no one will question it - rather, no one can question it and live to tell the tale. It is not uncommon for colonial laws to be preserved for use against political enemies, so now it's not rubber farmers getting castrated, but journalists who show "traitorous behavior" or an opposition leader that "insults the president".

The only authoritarian countries that overcome that hurdle are those lucky to get benevolent dictators who go undertake genuine reform to decentralize power.