This was Yahoo in late 90s early 2000s. They had a human curated directory search where one could look up something like "kayaking" and find a bunch of sites on kayaking. Then if you wanted to search on keyword it was outsourced to AltaVista and later Google. Altavista results were terrible and were almost nothing more than a keyword search (IE the word you were searching appeared on this page). Google got much better at the general search and this was history.
I think the death of the directory search dramatically dropped the number of self-curated, informative sites from a domain expert that were common in the early internet. Now instead of making a website, many people are on content silos like Reddit/FB
Re:Search engines and SEO spam
by ocdtrekkie on Monday January 03, 2022 @01:22PM
(#29784194)
I do still think we could adapt this model on top of content silos... assuming we can index them! Consider that one could also, rather than just ingesting Reddit content, we ingest new posts from particular users who write quality posts on Reddit.
Assuming a method also existed for an author to authenticate themselves with the search engine, one could also enable an author to help identify their content across multiple platforms, as well as suggest other quality authors to consider.
I think a really good search engine would still algorithmically search it's index, but the content library should be human-curated with a goal of ingesting content via author, not via platform. Once a given author was human-approved as a quality source of information, content they produce could be automatically ingested going forwards, and conditionally re-reviewed by a human if there were reports the quality had decreased.