News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Loving Someone with Depression by azalemeth on Sunday January 02, 2022 @09:09PM (#29776526)
I did this. It was, by far, the hardest decision of my life.

Years later I still silently feel guilty beyond anything and wonder deeply if it was the right choice. The reaction of my friends, parents and colleagues was something along the lines of "at last!" as they only saw me as a martyr who always "compromised" and put up with large costs, financially, emotionally, and with no reward other than being yelled at a lot; sleeping on the sofa every night. I felt very, very bad about leaving, but I just could not cope and wondered what would happen for the rest of my life either.

As far as I can tell, my departure promoted her to re evaluate her life, and explore other hobbies and activities. I chose to believe that this has been a net force for good for both parties. I just wish someone would tell me that I did the right thing, and am not a monstrous human, failing a partner in their hour (well, decade) of need.

Re:Loving Someone with Depression by throwawayboise on Sunday January 02, 2022 @10:57PM (#29777168)
A relationship is a two party deal. If one party isn't holding up his/her half, for whatever reason, including mental illness, and isn't taking steps to improve, there isn't much to be done. One person alone can't make a relationship work.
Re:Loving Someone with Depression by kayodelycaon on Sunday January 02, 2022 @09:16PM (#29776564)
As far as I can tell, you tried as much as you could and failed. If you don’t take care of yourself, you now have two people in trouble.

In my book, you did the right thing. (I’m bipolar, if that helps.)

Re:Loving Someone with Depression by bachmeier on Sunday January 02, 2022 @10:17PM (#29776932)
> failing a partner in their hour (well, decade) of need

Genuine question here. What do you mean when you talk about "failing a partner"? It seems like everyone in this type of relationship hesitates to leave because they think they'll damage the other person.

It doesn't sound from what you've written that your partner was doing so well when you were with them. Have you considered that maybe part of the depression was caused by their relationship with you? (Obviously I'm not saying that is the case, but reading your post, you seem to be of the opinion that your relationship was a good thing for your ex-partner.)

Re:Loving Someone with Depression by spaetzleesser on Monday January 03, 2022 @12:27AM (#29777652)
"As far as I can tell, my departure promoted her to re evaluate her life, and explore other hobbies and activities. I chose to believe that this has been a net force for good for both parties. "

That has been my experience too when I left my partner.

Re:Loving Someone with Depression by ceedan on Sunday January 02, 2022 @09:21PM (#29776599)
It sounds like you did the right thing
Re:Loving Someone with Depression by ciphol on Monday January 03, 2022 @07:51AM (#29780251)
You did the right thing, as the apparently unanimous consent of every you know indicates.
Re:Loving Someone with Depression by kingkawn on Monday January 03, 2022 @01:07AM (#29777860)
You did the right thing.
Re:Loving Someone with Depression by DoreenMichele on Sunday January 02, 2022 @11:22PM (#29777306)
FWIW: I'm genuinely confused that you believe she was better off because you left, yet you feel like a monster and crave some kind of outside validation.
Re:Loving Someone with Depression by PinkMilkshake on Sunday January 02, 2022 @11:43PM (#29777411)
I thought having multiple conflicting emotions/beliefs/desires was like 99% of the human experience and the source of almost all art, philosophy, etc. (I'm being somewhat hyperbolic)
Re:Loving Someone with Depression by ineedasername on Sunday January 02, 2022 @11:52PM (#29777461)
I'm not confused at someone being conflicted about a past action, especially a very hard decision. It also seems rational to hope that any negative consequences were minimal.
Re:Loving Someone with Depression by DoreenMichele on Monday January 03, 2022 @12:02AM (#29777516)
I'm an internet stranger. I know nothing of their life but what they have said here and me patting them on the head is unlikely to be of any help.

But sometimes reflecting back to someone what they just said about their own life is helpful for them.

Perhaps not in this case, given the downvotes and pile on of replies.

Anytime you try to help, it risks going sideways. I'm prone to trying anyway.

Chalk it up to longstanding bad habit (insert wry smile).

Re:Loving Someone with Depression by quickthrower2 on Monday January 03, 2022 @01:49AM (#29778072)
Easy to come across the wrong way online where if you said the same thing in person with tone and emphasis it may be ok.

I’ve fallen for that trap a few times and so now I even delete comments before posting as if I think “maybe my intent wont come across correctly here”.

I think the problem with the comment (the one starting FWIW) is it comes off a bit sarcastic even if you didn’t mean that.

Re:Loving Someone with Depression by DoreenMichele on Monday January 03, 2022 @10:13AM (#29781503)
It's certainly not sarcasm.
Re:Loving Someone with Depression by ineedasername on Monday January 03, 2022 @01:01PM (#29783888)
Reflecting back might sometimes be useful, but your particular phrasing came across as condemnation. The implication, to my reading, was judgemental: you thought they were appropriately feeling guilty but seeking outside encouragement to reject that feeling. If you're going to try your hand at prodding someone to self reflection, a more encouraging tone may be more useful. Otherwise you risk wounding someone who, in this case, is already struggling with something.
Re:Loving Someone with Depression by DoreenMichele on Monday January 03, 2022 @01:07PM (#29783955)
you thought they were appropriately feeling guilty but seeking outside encouragement to reject that feeling.

No, that's not remotely my intent at all.

Most people raise children on either a guilt model or shame model. I raised mine on the basis of enlightened self interest.

Understandably, many people read in accusations of guilt where none exist. They've been trained that way.

I'm only replying in hopes it provides some clarification for the person I originally replied to. I care not at all what others think of me or my motives etc. But I sincerely wish that their takeaway is "You don't need outside validation if you can see with your own eyes that it was for the best." and not "Here is some random internet stranger just adding to your pain because the world is an awful place full of awful people."

Thank you for giving me the opportunity to try to clarify that detail.

Re:Loving Someone with Depression by ineedasername on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @04:20PM (#29800708)
>No, that's not remotely my intent at all.

Glad to hear that.

>Most people raise children on either a guilt model or shame model. I raised mine on the basis of enlightened self interest.

Glad to hear that too

Understandably, many people read in accusations of guilt where none exist. They've been trained that way.

Could you elaborate on that training? If that's what I'm doing, I'd like to understand the mechanism by which I came to that habit.

Re:Loving Someone with Depression by DoreenMichele on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @05:18PM (#29801419)
It's a set of default mental models that a person gets inculcated with early in life and repeatedly reinforced over many years. There's no quick and dirty cure.

If you want to sort out how you may be projecting guilt (or projecting guilting behavior) onto other people and how that came to be, you might start a journal.

On HN, the guidelines ask that we assume good faith and take a charitable reading. If you work at that, it's a good exercise in how to sort out who is actually bringing their baggage to the conversation and when it is you, yourself, bringing the baggage.

A good rule of thumb is to observe patterns of behavior. Consider the history of the person speaking whom you seek to judge and consider your own patterns.

I sometimes downvote something on HN and then wonder if it's me, if I really have enough info to judge the comment or if I'm being lazy and reactive without adequate info to properly judge it. If I think "I don't really know that they are behaving badly like I think they are. I'm kind of leaping to conclusions here." I will reverse the downvote.

I usually am trying to understand a comment as best I can from their point of view while respecting myself and why I see it that way. Sometimes it's just not worth hashing out.

There isn't enough time in the day to really understand every random internet stranger, their life story, their personal history, their culture. Sometimes it's better to just drop it as the least worst answer I have in an imperfect world and an imperfect life with a limited amount of time on this earth.

There are people who spend years in therapy tracking down the defects in their own patterns of thought. It's not something that typically gets fixed in a "once and done" fashion.

Though sometimes it does get fixed that way. Sometimes just having the right thing said does make a person go "I did not know that about myself (or about how life works)." And they are permanently changed for the better without a lot of drama.

I feel like this is probably what people mean when they speak of seeking enlightenment -- that magical aha! moment that doesn't hurt and makes everything better forever.

Best of luck in your journey.

Re:Loving Someone with Depression by ineedasername on Monday January 03, 2022 @12:59PM (#29783874)
Reflecting back might sometimes be useful, but your particular phrasing came across as condemnation. The implication, to my reading, was judgemental: you thought they were appropriately feeling guilty but seeking outside encouragement to reject that feeling. If you're going to try your hand at encouraging self reflection, are more encouraging tone may be useful. Otherwise you risk wounding someone who, in this case, is already struggling with something.
Re:Loving Someone with Depression by BHSPitMonkey on Sunday January 02, 2022 @11:47PM (#29777433)
When somebody says "I choose to believe ___", it means they are not actually convinced of that thing (i.e. that it is hopeful/wishful thinking).

For what it's worth, GP, I think you did the right thing too.

Re:Loving Someone with Depression by Talanes on Monday January 03, 2022 @12:01AM (#29777513)
Not GP, but when you really WANT to believe something and are aware of that fact, it can be hard to separate out whether that thing is actually true or if you've just subconsciously convinced yourself it is.
Re:Loving Someone with Depression by noduerme on Monday January 03, 2022 @02:22AM (#29778238)
Most of your posts on HN amount to guilting people and accusing them of things, mixed with heavy doses of self-validation. (Earlier today you were starving in a street because of capitalism, no?) So the idea that someone could feel both guilt and relief at the same time shouldn't be foreign territory.