News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by user_7832 on Saturday January 01, 2022 @07:34PM (#29764449)
I'm curious on why you're pessimistic on hydrogen. I agree that cars are likely not the best use of fuel cells (heavy vehicles are able to utilize H2's strengths much more), but in a future based on renewables hydrogen allows you to store energy in a very dense way. Lithium batteries are acceptably heavy/expensive at small scales, but how do you think will supply vary to meet demand in the medium-long term without a chemical fuel (hydrogen/ammonia)?
Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by yholio on Sunday January 02, 2022 @03:51PM (#29773727)
Firstly, the energy density of hydrogen is a lie. Yes, the fuel itself has the highest know energy content per mass, but it's nearly useless as a gas.

To reach any useful volume density you need a high pressure COPV tank that weights an other of magnitude more than the fuel it contains. To generate electricity you need a bulky fuel cell with low efficiency, which in turn requires a very beefy cooling system, larger than the one used on an ICE vehicle since the fuel cell is so much sensitive to overheating.

If you add it all up, you get something that's comparable with a battery in terms of energy density, but with half the round trip efficiency, expensive and dangerous refueling, larger upfront costs and lower lifetime.

It's no surprise then that the range record for a hydrogen car is actually lower than the corresponding BEV car.

The only genuine advantage of fuel cells is faster refill, but with advances in battery chemistry and ubiquity of charging spots, this becomes less of an issue.

As for the mineral scarcity issue, fuel cells have it much worse, each requiring a small fortune in platinum or other rare minerals. The lithium content for batteries is dropping and a somewhat lower performance sodium ion chemistry is available, with practically limitless supply.

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by _hypx on Monday January 03, 2022 @02:39PM (#29785412)
A COPV has about 6% hydrogen by mass. At 33.3 kWh/kg, that’s ~2000 Wh/kg. This is far beyond the theoretical limits of li-ion batteries.

Platinum is not a critical component, only necessary in current PEM fuel cells. Future fuel cells should eventually do away with platinum altogether. As hydrogen is effectively limitless too this is never going to be a resource concern.

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by yholio on Monday January 03, 2022 @07:22PM (#29789130)
A typical Mirai fuel consumption is 0.76kg/100km in similar driving conditions with a Tesla doing 15kWh/100km, so real world fuel density is 20kWh/kg - with a corresponding decrease in COPV density. You would then almost halve that density to take into consideration the whole electricity generating system, cell + cooling + the supercap or NiMH assembly that handle transients and regen braking etc.

So the density advantage of Hydrogen is limited, half to a third the battery mass with comparable volume. Not a game changer in 2010, and certainly not now, when everything else is against it.

The much improved and high performance fuel cells have been just around the corner for two decades. In the meantime, BEV sales have outstripped H2EVs one thousand to one, growing exponentially every year. How could anyone even consider buying a H2EV when the reliability of infrastructure is a joke even in the most mature US market [1]? Considering electric chargers are becoming ubiquitous and anyone can install one in their own home?

I think one needs to smell the roses, it's not a festive occasion for H2EVs.

[1] https://www.motortrend.com/reviews/2021-toyota-mirai-long-te...

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by _hypx on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @01:26AM (#29792019)
Which is still something like 1200 Wh/kg. Worlds beyond li-ion...
Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by yholio on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @03:03AM (#29792497)
For the COPV alone. If we can ignore the associated hardware, a flask with some lithium could do 11kWh/Kg, if only it were to combust with the surrounding air in a spontaneous Li-Air cell.

Aside from mass, volume is fundamental on a terrestrial EV, it reduces storage capacity, comfort and range at highway speeds. That's why a Tesla can have two trunks, while the Mirai is limited to just 5 Kg of fuel.

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by _hypx on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @03:26AM (#29792637)
Even with everything included, that's still 600 Wh/kg or so. BTW, an EV with everything included really only has around 140-160 Wh/kg. It's still far short of what hydrogen can do.

The Mirai also stores around 186 kWh of LHV energy (220 kWh HHV). It's storing a fundamentally larger quantity of energy than comparable EVs.

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by yholio on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @05:29AM (#29793331)
Indeed, but it does so by filling every inch of space. There's no front trunk, and the backseats and trunk are relatively cramped. Further improving on that pits you against the laws of physics: even if you could, say, safely double the pressure in the bottles, you waste more and more energy - compression is already a big part of the round-trip inefficiency of H2EV.

Meanwhile, EV already exist today with similar range - Model S or Mercedes EQS, with something like 90% solar cell to wheel efficiency, and battery chemistries are only getting better.

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by _hypx on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @05:03PM (#29801216)
It’s a modified Lexus in the end. It’s not optimized. If well designed you’ll get more room and range compared to a similar EV. The Hyundai Nexo is an example. Also, not every EV has a frunk, like the EQS.
Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by Gwypaas on Saturday January 01, 2022 @08:02PM (#29764631)
Call it a solution in search of a problem. The best fuel cells today reach about 50% round trip efficiency. That's even a high estimate. That by physics defines the price difference between where you buy low and sell high. Without even counting the hydrogen storage, fuel cell itself and everything needed to make it function.

That number also defines the arbitrage marginal any other solution has against hydrogen. Be it batteries, over built renewables or geographically coupled networks.

Hydrogen as a feedstock for industry?? Definitely.

Hydrogen for airplanes? Likely synthetic hydrocarbons but we will see, the hydrogen has to come from somewhere. Same with long distance ocean transport.

Emergency reserve of power for a nation state? Just use fossil fuels.

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by user_7832 on Saturday January 01, 2022 @09:50PM (#29765282)
Yeah I agree with what you say (especially your last part), that its use is likely to be much more for some industries than others; for eg. for Battery EVs particularly outside North America iirc a much smaller battery can do 95% of trips, so hydrogen makes very little sense for a family car. Though the person I was replying to was more pessimistic in general.
Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by michaelt on Sunday January 02, 2022 @05:41AM (#29767594)
Well, Europe needs some way to store renewable energy in the summer for use in the winter. Especially if they plan to move all transport and heating off hydrocarbons, without using nuclear. And storing energy during summer for use in winter needs a battery 100x larger than storing it in the day for use at night.

I don't know what solution our leaders have in mind for this - but I can imagine the costs of gas and battery storage scale differently.

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by iso1210 on Sunday January 02, 2022 @08:27AM (#29768530)
You need a large amount of electricity for a short term event - say a festival or a building site. You wheel in a hydrogen generator, powered by hydrogen from renewable electrolysis, job done.
Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by _hypx on Sunday January 02, 2022 @07:39AM (#29768253)
The best fuel cells already reach >70% efficiency.