News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:All of Wittgenstein is now public domain by belfalas on Saturday January 01, 2022 @02:36PM (#29761828)
"If you agree that there is a hand, we will grant you all the rest..."

From the tiny book "On Certainty" by Wittgenstein. Really interesting and thought-provoking.

Re:All of Wittgenstein is now public domain by lkbm on Saturday January 01, 2022 @03:03PM (#29762084)
More context: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Here_is_one_hand

TL;DR:

Descartes (and others): We can't know for certain that the external world exists.

GE Moore: "Here is one hand, and here is another. There are at least two external objects in the world."

Wittgenstein was pointing out that this doesn't address any of the actual claims. (I think "agree" is a confusing word to use in the translation. "Know" would work better.)

EDIT: I'd also like to throw this Moorean SMBC sub-comic because I love it and it's relevant: https://www.smbc-comics.com/comics/20100512after.gif -- from https://www.smbc-comics.com/?id=1879

Re:All of Wittgenstein is now public domain by johnisgood on Saturday January 01, 2022 @03:17PM (#29762237)

  Here is one hand,
  And here is another.
  There are at least two external objects in the world.
  Therefore, an external world exists.
As if there would not be hands in a simulated world!
Re:All of Wittgenstein is now public domain by dlkf on Saturday January 01, 2022 @03:57PM (#29762684)
The Cartesian begins with a hidden assumption - let's call it the internalist assumption - that in order for me to know that "here is one hand," there needs to be no possibility that we are in a simulated world (for if it's possible I'm in a simulated world, then I don't really know that here is one hand).

Moore's point is: why is the internalist assumption any better than the assumption that here is one hand?

Re:All of Wittgenstein is now public domain by scoofy on Saturday January 01, 2022 @05:03PM (#29763316)
The point isn't about the external world. It's about deduction vs induction, the point is about axioms. Axioms are arbitrary, thus deductive reasoning is ultimately arbitrary.

If there is a hand then everything else falls out deductively. Using induction, it's trivially true that there is a hand.

Using deductive reasoning to prove an inductive proposition is ultimately a waste of time, using inductive reasoning to create a correct framework for deductive reasoning is ultimately unknowable. Both of these together is how we live our lives and create our standard model, which is ultimately imprecise at best, and wrong at second best.

This is Moore's point, that we are wasting our time trying to deductively prove the existence of an external world when it's trivially provable. We may not get accurate axiomatic framework, but we can never get that anyway.

Much of the point of philosophy is properly delineating between these two methods of reasoning. Much of analytic philosophy is finding areas where language blurs the two.

Re:All of Wittgenstein is now public domain by MaxBarraclough on Sunday January 02, 2022 @07:58AM (#29768366)
It seems to conflate the existence of a hand with the perception of a hand (specifically an 'external' hand). Neither implies the other.
Re:All of Wittgenstein is now public domain by HEmanZ on Saturday January 01, 2022 @03:50PM (#29762604)
My thought on this, what's the difference to an agent between a real world an a simulated one? Why aren't all worlds effectively simulated?
Re:All of Wittgenstein is now public domain by galaxyLogic on Saturday January 01, 2022 @06:44PM (#29764097)
You are basically asking if it's possible to know whether we live in a simulated world or not.

That is a good question. One possible answer would be "It depends on the quality of the simulation". If we are living in a simulated world there could be a simulated drug the so-called red pill which allows you to see the execution of the simulation.

If we started seeing Fortran source-code in the sky and the code would seem to be about running a world-simulation, and we would also see data-expressions in the sky that curiously described the world we experience outside of us then I think we would be pre-disposed to think it looks like we are simulated beings in a simulated world.

Re:All of Wittgenstein is now public domain by MaxBarraclough on Sunday January 02, 2022 @07:55AM (#29768351)
> Fortran source-code in the sky

Held together with Perl, don't forget. https://xkcd.com/224/

Re:All of Wittgenstein is now public domain by johnisgood on Saturday January 01, 2022 @05:02PM (#29763310)
There is no difference. It would only matter if you could wake up from the simulated one. Everything in this world seems real, and since I have not waken up to confirm that this is not even real, I might as well just consider it real and go on with my life.
Re:All of Wittgenstein is now public domain by number6 on Saturday January 01, 2022 @04:08PM (#29762809)
At least simulated by our brain. Most would say filtered but what is the difference?
Re:All of Wittgenstein is now public domain by tympious on Saturday January 01, 2022 @10:09PM (#29765395)