The actual fix is exactly what the original comment states: a version is not a number.
You expect Microsoft Exchange to stop being used some time in the next 20 years?
Even more likely, we'll have new protocols the current version doesn't support, so the bug will have been long fixed or noticed.
But in your alternate timeline the issue would only have been hit in 2043, and since in our timeline it was not noticed before it was hit, there is no reason to believe it would have been noticed in the alternate.
So the exact same issue would have occurred, a few years later.
I fail to see why that would be an improvement.
> Even more likely, we'll have new protocols the current version doesn't support, so the bug will have been long fixed or noticed.
That is a completely unsubstantiated assertion.
I never suggested it was any improvement except for the advantage of time; although I shouldn't have used the word 'correct'. Signed 32-bit dates have a well known limitation that people will likely hunt and fix over the next 20 years. But yes, its all unsubstantiated, no doubt there.
The real main point of my post you first replied to is that it doesn't matter that the version was stored as an integer. The failure happened when they used their own format and didn't confirm it was properly bounded. Everyone here is having a hard time grasping how their data is stored and processed at the low level - your 'string' is still just an array of 8-bit bytes.
Storing an only-increasing number as any form of integer is a perfectly acceptable, and efficient way for a computer to compare and process. Version numbers are one of those. Phone numbers are obviously not.
Everything in software takes data in one form and processes it into another. There are no 'strings', there are no version numbers. There is only binary. They simply did not give enough space to store it, thats all.
DNS is a perfect example, which stores serial numbers internally as an unsigned 32 and has worked for decades and will continue to. But they chose the format of YYYYMMDDnn which will last far longer than a 2 digit year.