Re:The Clojure Mindshare (2019)
by dragonwriter on Friday December 31, 2021 @03:52PM
(#29752419)
> But by today's standards, Lisp a pretty antiquated language which still hasn't caught up to modern trends (static types,
Typed Racket exists, as does syntactic support for static type declarations in Common Lisp (though whether implementations do anything with declarations is up to them; some, however, do offer compile-time checking.)
> asynchronism,
Racket has asynchronisn via both the thread API (which aren't OS thread, but asynchronous tasks with mailboxes) and via promises (promise/force in Racket is pretty much all the good parts of async/await without the bad parts; future/touch provides a similar API for operations that are parallel rather than merely asynchronous.)
> very poor tooling (lack of IDE's)
Racket, CL, and Clojure all have dedicated IDEs; a number of Java-focused IDEs support Clojure as well.
Clojure is designed to leverage the JVM ecosystem, so that's clearly not the case for Clojure unless
your standard for a library ecosystem is something beyond what the Java world has. (Similarly with ClojureScript and JS.)
But, sure, there's no Lisp-first platform as popular as the JVM, .NET, JS, or CPython.
Typed Racket exists, as does syntactic support for static type declarations in Common Lisp (though whether implementations do anything with declarations is up to them; some, however, do offer compile-time checking.)
> asynchronism,
Racket has asynchronisn via both the thread API (which aren't OS thread, but asynchronous tasks with mailboxes) and via promises (promise/force in Racket is pretty much all the good parts of async/await without the bad parts; future/touch provides a similar API for operations that are parallel rather than merely asynchronous.)
> very poor tooling (lack of IDE's)
Racket, CL, and Clojure all have dedicated IDEs; a number of Java-focused IDEs support Clojure as well.
> library ecosystem (building websites, parallelism, GUI, etc...)
Clojure is designed to leverage the JVM ecosystem, so that's clearly not the case for Clojure unless your standard for a library ecosystem is something beyond what the Java world has. (Similarly with ClojureScript and JS.)
But, sure, there's no Lisp-first platform as popular as the JVM, .NET, JS, or CPython.