News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What teachers want to tell parents by tptacek on Thursday September 08, 2011 @02:22PM (#2975024)
If you think social policy should be premised on the idea that any random person is likely to be Michael Faraday, there probably isn't much productive discussion about policy to be had with you. That doesn't make you wrong, just an intractable absolutist.
Re:What teachers want to tell parents by maxharris on Thursday September 08, 2011 @02:58PM (#2975174)
I don't think that any particular random person, given only that information and nothing more, is likely to be the next Faraday. But I know for a fact that it is possible for any person to be, and that the same can't be said for any other type of living entity (e.g., a dog).

And for the record, I am a contextual absolutist, which is something altogether different than an absolutist.

Re:What teachers want to tell parents by hans00 on Thursday September 08, 2011 @03:38PM (#2975347)
"contextual absolutist" - nice oxymoron, Einstein.
Re:What teachers want to tell parents by maxharris on Thursday September 08, 2011 @04:01PM (#2975439)
Seriously, it isn't an oxymoron. To claim certainty in a given context of knowledge is foundational for both philosophy and the special sciences (such as physics, chemistry, etc.) Contextual absolutism amounts to saying, "Given all the things I know (this is part of the context), I am absolutely certain of this conclusion. I am aware that it is possible that I might come across yet more facts that might cause me to revise or even abandon my conclusion, but right now, I know this much."

(To conclude that something is possible, or probable, and not yet certain is itself an example of this process.)

To use your example, people often claim that Newton was proven wrong by Einstein. But I disagree. Newton's context included observations of the local solar system, and depended on the instruments of his time. His system still works in the majority of situations encountered today. Because the context hasn't changed appreciably in those situations, we can apply his mechanics and claim that they are correct. Conversely, GPS and particle physics and the like are out of bounds, contextually. For that, you must understand relativity, which is another truth that is absolutely true in a still wider context.

Of course, there is a price to pay for relativity, which is extra computational and pedagogical complexity. Indeed, this alone is enough to keep Newton around for millennia to come. Remember that knowledge is not an end in itself, despite what some may say. All knowledge is a means to some end. We don't all know the same things, and we can't anyway.

Finally, how could we ever get to the point where we can appreciate relativity, or engineer systems where it is necessary to know about that if we were to simply discard Newton's theory as "false"? Science (and indeed all knowledge) is all about what some deride as mere "scaffolding." But I don't deride it - and that's why I'm a contextual absolutist.

Re:What teachers want to tell parents by nitrogen on Thursday September 08, 2011 @04:10PM (#2975469)
IMO social policy should focus on the average case, but with easy-to-access exceptions dealing with the best and worst cases. Society is done a great disservice if gifted students are prevented from reaching their potential (thus preventing them from being as beneficial to society as they could) for the sake of the potential dropouts.