News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by tptacek on Friday December 31, 2021 @12:24PM (#29750165)
I love when web3 people say this, because it's revealing. There is really no application you can come up with that is less amenable to decentralized blockchain technology than identity. The hardest problem in identity isn't public key authentication (which we've had for 2 decades, and nobody wants) but account recovery. The absolute last thing any ordinary user wants is an identity that is cryptographically unrecoverable, or that functions like a bearer bond if compromised.

Account recovery isn't a basket of features like multi-sig wallets and threshold schemes. It's the assumption, so far baked in that most users don't even realize they're making it, that if something goes wrong with an account there is a human-mediated process for restoring access. A centralized authority is intrinsic to the concept! It has to be there from the beginning! You can't ask users to opt into it, because they're users and they don't know how any of this stuff works.

It's for this reason that Apple and Google control so much of Internet identity, and are going to continue doing so. Advocates of decentralized identity are poisoned by the experiences and preferences of a tiny but vocal sliver of users that (1) are deeply into this stuff and (2) do enough weird shit to occasionally get on Google or Apple's bad side and have bad/annoying experiences with account recovery. The problem is that these voices are not representative of the market, like, at all. Google does a better job of global Internet identity than any organization operating at any kind of scale. If you can't recognize why this might be true, and will be an enormous obstacle to adoption, you're not engaging seriously with identity.

The power that decentralized identity offers, normal people don't want. The things it takes away: necessities. It's a toy, not a killer app.

Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by kabdib on Friday December 31, 2021 @01:18PM (#29750822)
A while ago I worked on the 2FA access feature of a large online service.

The fun crypto-related and login-path stuff took maybe two weeks.

The remaining months were all about account recovery. It's really hard to do well, and unless you hire support staff it just won't work.

Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by Animats on Friday December 31, 2021 @02:41PM (#29751753)
The problem with identity is summarized in the "why your anti-spam idea won't work checklist"[1] We still don't have a solution to identity that prevents generating large numbers of fake identities, doesn't cost each user money, and doesn't require a central authority.

Blockchain systems are a demo of this. A blockchain just needs some number of players who are independent and not colluding. That ought to be simple, right? The best ideas the blockchain crowd has come up with to do this work by making playing very expensive. (That's what both proof of work and proof of stake do.) Even that didn't really work, as mining has become very centralized. A solution to identity has not emerged from that crowd.

[1] https://trog.qgl.org/20081217/the-why-your-anti-spam-idea-wo...

Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by dlubarov on Friday December 31, 2021 @01:44PM (#29751099)
You mention Google as a positive example, but they don't really have "a human-mediated process for restoring access". If you can't restore access with their recovery form, it seems the only option is to seek a court order, unless you have contacts at Google.

And I don't think it's just a matter of Google being cheap. If they had thousands of CSRs with the technical ability to reset passwords, I imagine we'd have a lot more cases of stolen accounts, using social engineering or bribery (as we see with SIM swaps).

Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by tptacek on Friday December 31, 2021 @01:49PM (#29751153)
The hard-landing process Google has is both human-mediated (which does not mean "you're hand-held through the process by a human being") and also iterated over time. Nobody had to figure out precisely what the account recovery process for Google was going to be a priori, because Google is a trusted third party and can adapt its recovery procedures as it needs to.
Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by annnoo on Friday December 31, 2021 @12:49PM (#29750469)
I completely agree with you, but I a small thought about public key authentication.

Today more and more people without a background in IT which got in the "Web3"/Crypto ecosystem get in touch with public key authentication mostly used with wallets like Metamask. It get's understandable and usable for the average user.

Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by tptacek on Friday December 31, 2021 @12:53PM (#29750527)
I don't see what that would get me that I wouldn't already have with Sign In With Apple, other than not being tied to Apple, which is one of the most important features of SIWA: if something goes wrong, there will be an ultra-annoying hard-landing customer service procedure that will, ultimately, restore access to my account.
Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by numair on Friday December 31, 2021 @01:44PM (#29751098)
I can turn this right back around on you.

> The power that decentralized identity offers, normal people don't want. The things it takes away: necessities. It's a toy, not a killer app.

Who are you to decide what “normal” people want, what a “necessity” is, what a “toy” is? And, moreover, are you sure account recovery is as important as you think it is? Maybe people would prefer to have accounts that have very little identity, that get thrown away without much care — you know, like how people use throwaways on here — than some One Absolute Source Of Recoverable Truth?

Humans have thrown things away forever. If anything, it is absolutely abnormal to want eternal persistence.

Also, the whole thing that public key identity has existed and “nobody wants” is utterly laughable when you look at the actual usage metrics on web3 wallets. If that entire industry does nothing else, the fact that it’s made 19 year old art students feel cool for knowing how to handle their public and private keys is enough innovation for one cycle.

Not sure why the crowd on HN is so irrationally religious about this issue. It’s not bike-shedding, but it’s definitely something similar.

Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by meheleventyone on Friday December 31, 2021 @01:54PM (#29751211)
> Who are you to decide what “normal” people want, what a “necessity” is, what a “toy” is? And, moreover, are you sure account recovery is as important as you think it is? Maybe people would prefer to have accounts that have very little identity, that get thrown away without much care — you know, like how people use throwaways on here — than some One Absolute Source Of Recoverable Truth?

The person being replied to literally suggested it as a single source of truth. For everything from HN to your bank account. So you’re tilting at the wrong windmill!

I think one thing the crypto fad has proven is that even experienced people can’t keep hold of their keys properly. You’re always one mistake from an irrecoverable situation.

Why would I want creds that once compromised not only were irrecoverable but also affected my entire life?

If you want easy, temporary identity then the current situation is pretty great.

Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by numair on Friday December 31, 2021 @02:21PM (#29751503)
> The person being replied to literally suggested it as a single source of truth. For everything from HN to your bank account. So you’re tilting at the wrong windmill!

The parent I replied to is competent enough to know that there is an easy way to have that “recoverable account” he is obsessed with: custodial wallets. You know, like the custodial accounts that are the defining feature of Web 2.0.

People who don’t understand the innovation of being able to choose between custodial and non-custodial, and how that’s a big deal that many appreciate beyond the opsec requirements, sort of expose their own weaknesses.

Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by 8organicbits on Friday December 31, 2021 @02:46PM (#29751814)
I can see that login via private key is cool for some people, and being able to login via a private key some other party maintains for you would work for "normal" users. But I could also implement that without bringing in a block chain, right? Wouldn't we expect that Google and the current authN providers just implement that if it ever became popular?
Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by UncleMeat on Friday December 31, 2021 @04:35PM (#29752751)
> But I could also implement that without bringing in a block chain, right?

Not only that, but they have! Signature-based authentication existed 20 years ago. Register with a public key. Sign a message with your private key to authenticate. Modulo some small details to prevent things like replay, you are done. The only thing that the blockchain brings is that now lots of people have asymmetric key pairs where their public keys are published somewhere widely accessible.

Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by meheleventyone on Friday December 31, 2021 @03:42PM (#29752338)
So the answer is web2!
Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by aardvarkr on Friday December 31, 2021 @01:56PM (#29751243)
I’m confused, you didn’t respond to the person’s argument. Way to go missing the forest for the trees. “Normal” is the >90% that hasn’t even heard of key signing and no amount of screaming at them will convince them to care.
Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by numair on Friday December 31, 2021 @02:24PM (#29751540)
No, you’re the one who is missing the point. An ever-growing number of highly engaged young people are using wallets and engaging in key signing without even thinking about it. And what those people do today, becomes the norm tomorrow.

I had meetings with newspaper executives in 2007 where I told them “everyone will get their news on Facebook soon.” They couldn’t understand what I meant, because they didn’t think “normal” people would ever use such things. A lot of comments on HN regarding web3 remind me of those conversations. This will all be so embarrassing in 10 years.

Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by tptacek on Friday December 31, 2021 @03:13PM (#29752065)
Facebook tells the opposite of the story you're trying to sell, of people flocking to a highly centralized space to get a single feed of news.
Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by pcwalton on Friday December 31, 2021 @05:13PM (#29753056)
There are lots of things that highly-engaged young people have done that don't catch on in the long run. Given the problems that Web 3 has, I see it as a lot more likely that Web 3 will go the route of fidget spinners than the route of Google.
Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by digitailor on Friday December 31, 2021 @02:49PM (#29751848)
I think you could go even further and add that a lot of power users who you'd think would want decentralized identity don't want it either, for the same reasons you mention.