News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by tzs on Friday December 31, 2021 @12:08PM (#29749980)
In the case of my bank, I'd expect to walk into my local branch with my driver's license, passport, birth certificate, and any other official ID I have, and convince them that I am the same tzs who owns the account and have them set me up with new account keys.

What I wish is that there was some way to tie my other accounts, directly or indirectly, to my bank. My bank account is the most recoverable account I have, because they can handle me showing up in person with ID.

Other accounts just know me by my knowing the account password and/or being able to receive emails at the email address associated with the account. If either of those is compromised I can lose the account with no way to recover.

If there were some way I could have my bank verify my identity to my email provider, and tell my email provider that if account recovery is ever needed on my email account to re-verify with my bank that it is really me requesting the account recovery it would be much safer.

(If you are using an email address at a domain you own, then replace email provider with domain registrar).

Then no matter how badly I'm compromised (as long as it is not by someone with sufficient resources and interest to be able to get past an in-person identity check at my bank), I've always got a path to recovery.

Worst case, first recover the bank account in person. Then recover the email account using the bank account. Then recover compromised accounts that are using the email account for verification.

Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by gitfan86 on Friday December 31, 2021 @01:57PM (#29751246)
So what you are suggesting is that the bank has full root privileges to change credentials associated with an account. What is the point of having a decentralized database if the bank can change ownership of accounts as they see fit?
Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by Animats on Friday December 31, 2021 @03:04PM (#29751993)
In-person account recovery is tough. A friend of mine runs a branch of a major bank. She regularly meets with customers who need to recover their account identity. A sizable fraction of the people who show up trying to do that are attempting something scammy.

If there were some way I could have my bank verify my identity to my email provider

Major banks can do their end of that. They will notarize documents and provide signature guarantees for established customers. Now, having obtained a notarized statement guaranteed by a major bank that you own your identity, how do you submit that to Gmail?

Banks don't really want to be in the authentication business anyway. It's an unprofitable sideline, and takes up a lot of staff time.

Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by abeppu on Friday December 31, 2021 @12:24PM (#29750166)
The bank still has a dependence on trusted authorities when it assumes your ID documents are legit. Rather than asking banks to confirm your identity for other accounts, I think we should ask governments to extend their practice of providing physical ID documents to providing online identification services. States have worked with Apple on "digital drivers licenses" that live on your phone, but the idea is still that you show them to someone in meatspace. Why shouldn't they provide an online service?

Of course, all this depends on the assumption that your ID should be who you are IRL, rather than the model where we can all make up several independent pseudonyms for different purposes.

Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by throwaway473825 on Friday December 31, 2021 @12:48PM (#29750462)
Many European countries have government-provided online identification services.

Estonia's implementation is usually regarded as one of the best: https://github.com/open-eid

Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by tzs on Friday December 31, 2021 @02:14PM (#29751429)
> The bank still has a dependence on trusted authorities when it assumes your ID documents are legit. Rather than asking banks to confirm your identity for other accounts, I think we should ask governments to extend their practice of providing physical ID documents to providing online identification services.

Sure, that would work too. Or even do both. The point is to have some place I can go in person to have my identity verified for a third party such as an email provider or domain registrar. Then set up the email or registrar accounts so that account recovery requires such a verification.

I wouldn't have to tie everything back to the in person verification. Just things that I want to be sure I can recover if I lose them via accident or hacking.

Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by UncleMeat on Friday December 31, 2021 @04:38PM (#29752788)
This is sort of what happens when you use OpenID with Google. The "break glass to recover account" flow at Google does literally involve photographs of government issued ids and other human process like that.