Re:Ask HN: Should we be considering a HN 9/11 ban?
by ryandvm on Thursday September 08, 2011 @10:43AM
(#2974081)
Why would a site that ostensibly operates under democratic rule need to ban anything?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Ask HN: Should we be considering a HN 9/11 ban?
by gojomo on Thursday September 08, 2011 @11:04AM
(#2974176)
I don't think HN has ever claimed to operate by "democratic rule". Community input is leveraged – via both the voting/flagging mechanisms, and discussions and solicitations of ideas. But rule is by YC/PG.
Re:Ask HN: Should we be considering a HN 9/11 ban?
by pnathan on Thursday September 08, 2011 @10:47AM
(#2974097)
Agreed. Banhammers should be used sparingly and in obvious cases.
Re:Ask HN: Should we be considering a HN 9/11 ban?
by sp332 on Thursday September 08, 2011 @10:48AM
(#2974098)
It's not undemocratic if most of us agree. e.g. Democratic countries ban murder. See: tyranny of the majority.
Re:Ask HN: Should we be considering a HN 9/11 ban?
by TomOfTTB on Thursday September 08, 2011 @10:52AM
(#2974112)
His point is the majority can just not vote things up where as a ban would be have to be implemented by pg based on the opinion of a subset of the majority. So since voting provides the majority with a means to eliminate the 9/11 posts why would a ban be necessary.
Re:Ask HN: Should we be considering a HN 9/11 ban?
by philwelch on Thursday September 08, 2011 @12:55PM
(#2974663)
Frankly, that worked fine for years but recently HN has been going to shit. Being more conscientious as a community about encouraging intellectually stimulating discussion and discouraging demagoguery and sentimentality is something worth talking about.
Re:Ask HN: Should we be considering a HN 9/11 ban?
by gacba on Thursday September 08, 2011 @10:50AM
(#2974107)
Agreed, the very concept seems reprehensible amongst this group. Unless John Graham-Cunning is suddenly losing faith in HN community for being able to self-police itself on this kind of drudgery, then I say we let it be.