News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Web OS? Are You Dense? by jrockway on Sunday September 07, 2008 @04:11AM (#297390)
I don't think that desktop apps are going anywhere -- but web apps are going to look a lot more like desktop apps very very soon.

I think it's safe to say that applications written in dynamic languages (like Javascript) that communicate with the Internet regularly are going to become more common. And a lot of these apps are going to run in something like Chrome or XULRunner.

A "desktop app" is a pretty simple distinction. You go to your "desktop" and load the app. From there, the app can read/write the file system, talk to the Internet, read the keyboard and mouse, communicate with special hardware devices, etc. Web apps are going to be very much like this very soon. And then there will be no difference between a web app and a desktop app.

Re:A Web OS? Are You Dense? by jbert on Sunday September 07, 2008 @02:58PM (#297644)
> And then there will be no difference between a web app and a desktop app.

So why choose to write a "web app" in that case? What distinguishes the two - what is the defining characteristic of a web app? (One comes on a CD, one is downloaded - no) (One is written in C++, one is written in a vm-hosted language - no).

Is it just that you use HTML/JS to write the app?

Re:A Web OS? Are You Dense? by jrockway on Sunday September 07, 2008 @11:37PM (#297973)
One distinguishing factor is that the "authoritative" copy of the data is on "the server", not on your disk. Web apps may not have full functionality unless connected to the 'net. (Think about how apps that use Gears work now.)
Re:A Web OS? Are You Dense? by jbert on Monday September 08, 2008 @08:48AM (#298241)
That's an interesting criterion, but there are plenty of "traditional" desktop apps who keep data server side (any thin-client DB program using ODBC, subversion clients, etc).

Even IMAP email clients I suppose.

So is a web app "something which keeps primary data on a server, and uses the HTTP protocol to read+write it"?

Re:A Web OS? Are You Dense? by blackmac on Monday September 08, 2008 @11:16AM (#298401)
I think recently desktop apps started to look much more like web apps. I believe that's the right direction, as web apps are "usually" more focused on the one thing they do best and appear less cluttered. Under the hood you might be right though - see Gears, which enables web apps to do a lot of those desktop things.