News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask YC: You are promoting me too mentality and not intell... by jrockway on Sunday September 07, 2008 @02:47AM (#297356)
It is all about who participates in the voting. On Reddit (and Digg, I guess), the voting is done by retarded 9-year-old fanbois, and as a result, rewards ideas and comments that appeal to that demographic. Highly rated comments there are often some of the worst material I've ever read in my life. It often makes me pray for my own death. Correspondingly, some good ideas and arguments are often downmodded to -10, even though they are fine comments.

Over here, it's not as bad. I think the demographic here is the more thoughtful and secure type. We realize that someone disagreeing doesn't invalidate your own opinion or beliefs; it's just something more to think about. Plus, some especially bad comments are killed outright, which discourages future abuse. (Most of the things that get killed here would be +1000 on Reddit, so you can see why things are different between the sites.)

And BTW, I usually don't get dowmodded here for having the "wrong" opinion here. Sometimes I am shocked, like with this one:

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=294691

I swear, anywhere else that would have been downmodded to oblivion. (Even though it is not a troll, I really think that.) Instead, people replied disagreeing with me. Excellent.

The system ain't broken yet.

There are no comments on this comment yet.