News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask YC: You are promoting me too mentality and not intell... by whalliburton on Saturday September 06, 2008 @11:47PM (#297230)
This observation was in regards to the http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=297080

Regardless of whether I am right, I am basically the only countering argument and reduced to a grayed out presence.

I do not care emotionally a bit whether I am read, this is an intellectual observation regarding YC's downvoting of anti-mainstream thought while promoting much of the same.

Re:Ask YC: You are promoting me too mentality and not intell... by tdavis on Sunday September 07, 2008 @02:07AM (#297333)
The man asked if people who lifted weights wanted to test his app. Debating the merits of weightlifting had nothing to do with that post. If he had included, "you should lift weights because it's really good for you" then perhaps your argument would have been relevant. As it stands it wasn't and I see no problem with down-voting posts based on irrelevancy.
Re:Ask YC: You are promoting me too mentality and not intell... by ojbyrne on Saturday September 06, 2008 @11:54PM (#297236)
You cared enough about it to post this (which seems a bit narcissistic, no matter what you say). I upmodded your original comment, so right at the moment it isn't a "grayed out presence" but I'm not going to upmod this.
Re:Ask YC: You are promoting me too mentality and not intell... by whalliburton on Sunday September 07, 2008 @12:11AM (#297248)
Maybe your right, but I just saw a greyed out post (my own) that seemed like the only good counter (again, maybe only because it's my own viewpoint). The rest of the discussion did not seem like MEAT, thus this post.
Re:Ask YC: You are promoting me too mentality and not intell... by ericwaller on Sunday September 07, 2008 @12:28AM (#297256)
Well, I don't think that comment should have been down voted, you were starting a discussion by disagreeing from experience.

I don't like the idea of down voting comments you simply disagree with as long as the content isn't harmful (I realize that "harmful" in this context is common pro-censorship vocab, I just mean that comments like "all root passwords should be set to 'password'" should be downvoted).

Re:Ask YC: You are promoting me too mentality and not intell... by ericwaller on Sunday September 07, 2008 @12:30AM (#297260)
It'd be interesting if a down vote were actually a special case of reply and required an explanation.
Re:Ask YC: You are promoting me too mentality and not intell... by Alex3917 on Sunday September 07, 2008 @12:11AM (#297247)
Why would you have an intellectual argument about an empirical question?