> People disagree with each other
Yes, and once upon a time people here on HN used either to respect that disagreement, or would discuss it. They used not to downvote for simple disagreement. That's part of the change. > Maybe they were just downvoting everything for fun.
Which again makes my point - you can do that in a city and get away with it, you can't do it in a village. > Because you got a downvote, you make a statement
> that HN is going to hell.
Do you really think I've said this on the basis of a single downvote? It's a trend I'm seeing.Sadly the boiled frog allegory is a myth, but using the analogy anyway, I think I can see the temperature rising here on HN, and it's respect, quality discussion and value that's being boiled out. I might easily be wrong and I might jut be remembering with advantages how HN was 2 and 3 years ago, but if I'm right, now's the time to start looking for a new place to have thought-provoking conversation with intelligent and knowledgeable people.
-- Edmund Burke (disputed - see http://tartarus.org/~martin/essays/burkequote.html and http://tartarus.org/~martin/essays/burkequote2.html for in-depth discussion)
Even PG is concerned that HN is declining - http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2403696 - so it's not just me.
But clearly concern for the community is irrelevant and regarded as off-topic, so I'll stop now.
So, the downvotes: your original comment could have been interpreted as sarcastic, which might be why it was downvoted. Worth noting that overall it was positively received, who knows, maybe someone just slipped on their iPhone?
Your other comments have two problems. Your tone is somewhat passive-aggressive, for example:
"triumph of evil [that is, comment quality may be getting worse]", "clearly concern for the community is irrelevant", "community is gone, and HN is something else", "respect, quality discussion and value that's being boiled out"
Coupled this with the unfortunate fact that I (and presumably other people) also recognise your username for often complaining that HN is getting worse.
That is probably why your meta posts are getting downvoted: you have made your point before, and unless you have something new to say, that makes it noise and the community norms are to downvote noise.
I composed a much longer reply, but it's probably jsut going to be regarded as noise, so I'll leave it at that.
Because you got a downvote, you make a statement that HN is going to hell. Honestly, I do not know how much more of an overreaction you could have crafted here.