News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:‘Hard’ skills from PhDs remain relevant beyond academia by lordnacho on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @01:27PM (#29716374)
Honestly it sounds a bit desperate. I'm not dissing the idea of getting a PhD, I think it's a big achievement. But this sort of argument is the kind of thing I heard when I finishing my undergrad, and it wasn't convincing then either.

Grant Applications:

Very specific academic "skill" which is intimately tied to the bureaucracy of the university system of your particular country or region. It also has a lot to do with things that aren't even in the application: who you know and what they think of you. Whatever org you join later will have some other way for funding to come down, and there are so many varieties of org that you'll just have to learn on that job.

Analyzing Data:

That's definitely useful, but there's general and specific. There are lots of people who can't do it, and by doing a PhD you definitely show people that you are capable. But, and it's a huge but, you will be spending a heck of a lot of time poring over the evidence on some very specific area of science, with its own conventions and paradigms. When you go and do something else, that won't be relevant. People will of course see that you are generally intelligent, and that's great, but you'll have to learn whole new fields at your next gig. Your issue then is that it's possible to show general intelligence and ability to learn deep material without doing the whole PhD. In fact plenty of people will look at a Bachelor's and conclude the person is smart enough to learn how derivatives work, or how the advertising business works, and so on.

Presentations:

There's simply no less efficient way to learn presentation skills than to do a hard science PhD. It doesn't make any sense, a PhD takes a lot of work and how much of it is actually doing presentation specifically? Yes, I know they do presentations as part of it. But the kind of presentation skill you want is what your typical smooth talker is good at: confidently being able to talk about something that everyone can relate to. Think Obama or one of those Apple-guy-on-stage things. Are you going to learn that on your PhD? From what I hear, science fields are very very specific and although you are presenting, there's a fair bit of focus on the substance, plus you are presenting to people who are also insiders. If you want to just be less nervous and uhm-and-aw less, there are better ways to practice.

There are of course good reasons to get a PhD, such as a desire to learn that specific field. But the cost/benefit of doing it in order to learn generally applicable skills seems off to me.

Re:‘Hard’ skills from PhDs remain relevant beyond academia by throwawaygh on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @02:50PM (#29717250)
I generally agree with your thesis that the case here is desperate. However,

> a PhD takes a lot of work and how much of it is actually doing presentation specifically? Yes, I know they do presentations as part of it. But the kind of presentation skill you want is what your typical smooth talker is good at

Step zero of "smooth talk" style rhetoric is to start with the audience and work backwards to the speech.

Doing/understanding something complex and difficult, and then digesting it down to something that a diverse (if specialized) audience can understand, is quite different from what "typical smooth talkers" do. In fact, it's literally reversed. Your message -- the unvarnished complicated truth -- is fixed.

Giving an eloquent speech to a friendly general audience on an easy topic is a good skill, particularly in sales/fundraising/etc. But it's quite different from the communication skills one learns during a phd.

There are many jobs in which the phd-style communication skills are more important than sales-style communication skills. Generally positions where there's a team of folks working on a "hard" and rigid truth that doesn't care about you. E.g., leading/helping/consulting with a team of technologists to understand and solve a hard problem with a physical device or piece of software. "Uhms" and "ahs" don't matter, eye contact is optional, but cleanly communicating about complex ideas with other experts is necessary.

Re:‘Hard’ skills from PhDs remain relevant beyond academia by hiptobecubic on Friday December 31, 2021 @01:41AM (#29745621)
I think you wrong to separate these things. I have sat through a pretty wide variety of presentations, from non-technical HR fluff no one cares about to deep technical designs involving correctness proofs etc. The main difference between the two is how many people are familiar enough with the topic to be able to get any value from the presentation at all. As far as the skills needed by the speaker to present the content effectively, it's almost exactly the same. Yes you need to understand the material yourself, but if you are boring and articulate poorly and don't understand how to relate the audience, it doesn't matter if you're presenting rocket designs or sales fluff. No one is going to remember it 20 minutes later.
Re:‘Hard’ skills from PhDs remain relevant beyond academia by rbartelme on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @01:34PM (#29716447)
"Grant Applications:

Very specific academic "skill" which is intimately tied to the bureaucracy of the university system of your particular country or region. It also has a lot to do with things that aren't even in the application: who you know and what ? they think of you. Whatever org you join later will have some other way for funding to come down, and there are so many varieties of org that you'll just have to learn on that job."

I think the country/region part you mention is most relevant here, but I disagree with the overall assessment of grant writing being irrelevant. If you work in a start-up or the R&D division of a company, there's still grant money to be had. This lets companies pursue high risk projects while not jeopardizing overall revenue.

Re:‘Hard’ skills from PhDs remain relevant beyond academia by lordnacho on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @02:47PM (#29717209)
> start-up or the R&D division

Well certainly a large R&D division is similar to a university, but if you go that way, of course it makes sense to have a PhD. The question is whether the skill is applicable to things that aren't basically the same thing.

For start-ups, getting funding does not look like a university grant application, surely? At least I've heard many many versions of what people did, and none of them sounded much like what my PhD friends did.

Re:‘Hard’ skills from PhDs remain relevant beyond academia by hyperbovine on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @01:42PM (#29716521)
> Grant Applications: Very specific academic "skill" which is intimately tied to the bureaucracy of the university system of your particular country or region. It also has a lot to do with things that aren't even in the application: who you know and what they think of you.

Honest question: how many grant applications have you written, and to which funding agencies? Your experience does not resemble mine at all.

Re:‘Hard’ skills from PhDs remain relevant beyond academia by lordnacho on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @02:29PM (#29717019)
Absolutely none, just looking over the shoulders of friends. Happy to hear what you think.
Re:‘Hard’ skills from PhDs remain relevant beyond academia by selimthegrim on Tuesday December 28, 2021 @02:49PM (#29717235)
My friend in physics who has written multiple federal grant applications supporting multiple people tells a similar story to GP.