White noise generator / 'broadband alarm':
> White-noise / broadband alarms offer advantages over the typical tonal alarms:
> * Broadcast a range of frequencies making them easier to locate
> * Sound is more confined to those in the area who are most at risk
> * Reduces noise disturbance and noise pollution in surrounding community
> * Are available with adjustable sounds for specific environments
* https://www.worksafenb.ca/about-us/news-and-events/campaigns...
* https://www.heavyequipmentguide.ca/article/24957/backup-alar...
* https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/ottawa/new-back-up-alarm-snow...
The people who set the requirements (e.g. insurance companies) care about safety effectiveness.
The obvious answer here is to use one type of beeper in quiet environments (e.g. warehouse forklift) and one beeper for loud environment (scrapyard forklift). Of course that opens the door to subjective decisions (the inspector may have to judge whether a beeper is appropriate) and gaming the system (a workplace could run loud machinery at reduced speed) and the vast majority of the people trying to handle workplace safety are coming at it from a perspective where that is a non-starter. You see this any time the subject of "required" PPE and the health and safety implications of it when worn in extreme and non-typical workplaces. People get tied in all sorts of ideological knots when it becomes clear they can't just sling one size fits all solutions at problems.
Any solution that doesn't do an equal or better job will lead to more workplace injuries and deaths. Do we want that?
It's a trade-off. As someone who was around large construction equipment with all those beeps for some time, I would love to have a different solution.