News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

Offer HN: Let us critique your project?

tl;dr: We'll give you a lot of thorough design/copy editing advice for your project if you let us use the report as a sample.

We're starting a little service doing thorough, robust critiques of websites, focusing on startups. We'll go through all aspects of each site pre-login, all of the marketing pages, explanations, etc.

I'm hoping to find a few sites we can critique for free in order to get sample reports/testimonials before we start to charge. Our office is made up of an art critic and a writer who also design and build web projects, and I think we're pretty good at this sort of advice. We actually did a trial run on an unnamed YC company that liked the advice and is planning to implement most of it but wasn't comfortable with us using them as an example because they're in the midst of raising funds.

We only ask that if you find the critique useful you write a short note about it and let us use your report as a sample. Leave your email in a comment and I'll get in touch to get your website and a little info about what your goals are.

Thanks in advance for helping us out!

---

About the reports:

-

A critique in three parts

-

The Big Picture

• What, in general, is your site really communicating?

• What’s working, what isn’t working? How professional is the experience of your site?

• Who are you trying to target, and how well is your site calibrated to talk to them?

• Most importantly, how well is your site meeting your UX goals?

-

Visual Details

• Which specific elements need reworking?

• How can the layout, color palette, typography, spacing, etc. be improved?

• Every detail of your front end is reviewed in Google Chrome.

-

Copy Editing

• Writing well is a key element of professional presentation and successful marketing.

• We’ll edit up to about 1500 words of copy on your site for clarity, tone, persuasiveness, spelling and grammar.

( 30 comments | 15 points | on HN )
Re:Offer HN: Let us critique your project? by ColinWright on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @05:39PM (#2971594)
OK - although I'm unlikely to be able to act on any of your advice soon, I'd be interested in the content and style of your report.

http://www.mathsjam.com/confindex.html

You might choose the super-site (as it were), but it's that page (and it's descendants) I'm particularly interesting in ATM.

I'm adding an email temporarily to my profile.

Cheers.

Re:Offer HN: Let us critique your project? by ForrestN on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @05:44PM (#2971619)
Thanks, got your email. Will have something for you soon.
Re:Offer HN: Let us critique your project? by ColinWright on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @07:34PM (#2971991)
Interesting report, very interesting.

I'll be looking at it more closely tomorrow (it's gone midnight here) but I will certainly be passing this on to some friends and colleagues.

An interesting and useful service. I'll be saying more in my email reply tomorrow, but I wanted to give you a prompt positive and public response.

Thank you.

Re:Offer HN: Let us critique your project? by ColinWright on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @06:54PM (#2971891)
Cool - thanks.
Re:Offer HN: Let us critique your project? by robfitz on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @05:21PM (#2971503)
Howdy. I'm finishing up a community/portfolio site for small game developers. I think I'm probably too early for it to be useful to you (just about to put up a quiet v1 and it's not terribly startuppy in its current form), but would be more than happy to be reviewed if it's relevant for you.

(email in profile)

Re:Offer HN: Let us critique your project? by ForrestN on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @05:23PM (#2971510)
E-mailing now. No one's too early! We don't care about what the project is, we just want to demonstrate that we're helpful.
Re:Offer HN: Let us critique your project? by pkamb on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @06:48PM (#2971868)
Have at it, my assistive technology mISV:

http://www.onehandkeyboard.org

Contact me at support@thatdomainabove

Re:Offer HN: Let us critique your project? by ForrestN on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @06:54PM (#2971889)
Emailed, thanks!
Re:Offer HN: Let us critique your project? by martinshen on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @07:29PM (#2971973)
I'd love to get some advice for our startup UpOut.com link: http://www.UpOut.com email me at [email protected]
Re:Offer HN: Let us critique your project? by ForrestN on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @07:34PM (#2971993)
Sent, thanks.
Re:Offer HN: Let us critique your project? by ForrestN on Thursday September 08, 2011 @11:00AM (#2974159)
UPDATE: Thanks everyone, We've definitely got plenty to work with. Wasn't expecting such a strong response. I wish we could get to everyone, but it's taking quite a bit of time to complete each report because we're being so thorough. As soon as we have things set up, I'll make sure to follow up with a link to the service.
Re:Offer HN: Let us critique your project? by diolpah on Thursday September 08, 2011 @11:31AM (#2974276)
Ah, I was hoping for my request to be fulfilled. Such is life on Offer HN. Do you have an ETA for availability of the service and a preview of what the pricing will be?
Re:Offer HN: Let us critique your project? by ForrestN on Thursday September 08, 2011 @12:01PM (#2974400)
I'll send you an e-mail, and we can work something out. Apologies for getting your hopes up. Still thinking through pricing, if anyone interested in the service has any advice.
Re:Offer HN: Let us critique your project? by symphonyapp on Thursday September 08, 2011 @07:29PM (#2976118)
I can see you're already swamped, but I'd love to get some feedback. Our app is called Symphony Pro (http://www.symphonypro.net/). It's the premier app for creating and editing sheet music on the iPad.

Email me at [email protected]

Re:Offer HN: Let us critique your project? by callmeed on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @09:31PM (#2972242)
Sounds cool. You can do it for Cilantro (cilantrosites.com).

Email in profile.

Re:Offer HN: Let us critique your project? by ForrestN on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @10:02PM (#2972316)
Sent!
Re:Offer HN: Let us critique your project? by klaut on Thursday September 08, 2011 @04:22AM (#2973093)
Hi, thanks for this offer. I would love to use your advice on this little project: http://www.thebookingbee.com
Re:Offer HN: Let us critique your project? by mootothemax on Thursday September 08, 2011 @07:28AM (#2973428)
I'd love to see what you say about http://tweetingmachine.com :-) (and hopefully implement some improvements)
Re:Offer HN: Let us critique your project? by efadeev on Thursday September 08, 2011 @07:49AM (#2973482)
Very interesting, could you do this for http://askbot.org, please? My email is evgeny.fadeev at gmail. Thanks!!!
Re:Offer HN: Let us critique your project? by efadeev on Thursday September 08, 2011 @07:50AM (#2973487)
The askbot product demo is at http://askbot.org/en/questions
Re:Offer HN: Let us critique your project? by dsharpdiabetes on Thursday September 08, 2011 @01:36PM (#2974845)
If you want any more case studies, I'd love to hear your thoughts on http://dsharpdiabetes.com
Re:Offer HN: Let us critique your project? by limedaring on Thursday September 08, 2011 @01:29AM (#2972746)
Re:Offer HN: Let us critique your project? by Macshot on Thursday September 08, 2011 @11:01AM (#2974163)
I'm very interested to see what you have to say about NoBadgift.com. You can reach me at [email protected]
Re:Offer HN: Let us critique your project? by robbiea on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @09:43PM (#2972274)
the site is postamigos.com

contact me at robbie@thesiteabove

would love to get your feedback.

Re:Offer HN: Let us critique your project? by Dramatize on Thursday September 08, 2011 @02:00AM (#2972797)
I could use some feedback on http://rumplo.com
Re:Offer HN: Let us critique your project? by cl8ton on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @05:33PM (#2971555)
network AT diphur.com ... thanks!
Re:Offer HN: Let us critique your project? by ForrestN on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @05:45PM (#2971621)
Sent you an e-mail, thanks.
Re:Offer HN: Let us critique your project? by luvcraft on Thursday September 08, 2011 @11:00AM (#2974158)
Re:Offer HN: Let us critique your project? by twidlit on Thursday September 08, 2011 @12:54AM (#2972680)
eric AT piclyf DOT com. very interested in your POV
Re:Offer HN: Let us critique your project? by diolpah on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @09:53PM (#2972296)
Thank you for offering to do this. Two of the sites we operate that we'd love some external feedback on are http://www.ties.com/ and http://www.scarves.com/ - I can be contacted via the email address in my profile.