News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sometimes The Bad Guys Win by Dove on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @04:14PM (#2971214)
> There is no shortage of evidence that he is real and acts in history.

I think it's clear from your response that you're not familiar with the broad apologetics topics I'm referring to. Tell you what, let me expand a bit, so you can see what some of the arguments are. These are the things I personally find persuasive.

The content and history of the Bible

    - The Bible is completely unique among works of literature in its origin.  
      It was written over the course of 1500 years, by many different authors,
      in three languages, on three continents, in times of war, peace, 
      famine, plenty, persecution, and exile.  It was written by soldiers, 
      shepherds, statesmen, scholars, fishermen, kings, statesmen, 
      religious leaders, social outcasts, prisoners, and wealthy men.  It 
      was compiled independently by several separate communities centuries
      removed from the authors. 

      - It nonetheless tells a consistent, coherent story, and its message
        develops consistently throughout.  It is a serial, not an 
        anthology.  That strikes me as pretty darn amazing.  You try
        to construct a serial out of famous works across multiple millenia, 
        continents, cultures, and walks of life. 

      - No one author or organization has ever even remotely controlled it.
        The only one who could have written it is God. 

      - It is unique among works of scripture in being able to make 
        these claims.  Other scriptures are the work of one author,
        one culture, one time.  

      - In short, the Bible has credentials appropriate for supernatural
        origin.  If God *did* write a book, the Bible is a reasonable 
        candidate.


    - The Bible is an ancient book, the most modern parts being about as
      old as Aristotle.   If you go back and read stuff from the era,
      it sounds pretty foolish.  I mean, you can see some interesting
      early ideas, but we've learned a lot since then.  What they say
      seems silly and outdated.   *But we're still talking about the
      Bible.*  Whoever wrote it had such an insight into humanity that
      still find it relevant and insightful after two millenia.  
      Even with all the changes in culture and knowledge in between.  
      That seems like a feat worthy of God. 

    - The Bible contains well-known prophecies that can be validated
      by history.  Specific old testament prophecy about Jesus 
      preceded his appearance by several hundred years.  (Even
      if you assume the dead sea scrolls are the originals, they 
      still precede him by centuries).   The book of Daniel
      contains prophecies about later political events in Greece
      that are so accurate that some scholars resort to 
      assuming they are backfilled from the time of Greece (but
      this is inconsistent with any other dating for Daniel). 
      The formation of modern Israel as a state (in 1948) fulfills
      old testament prophecy.  The destruction of the temple in
      70 AD fulfills Jesus' prophecy.  

    - The message of the new testament, the Gospel, is remarkable
      in its effectiveness and adaptability to human circumstance.
      Literally the same message that is effective for a 
      herdsman in Africa is satisfying to a scholar at Oxford.  
      Criminals, saints, retarded people, healthy people, smart
      people, illiterate people, any people anywhere.  Writing
      such an egalitarian yet relevant plan of salvation is
      an amazing feat.  It is accessible to everyone, yet
      no one is overqualified.  It is comprehensible to 
      everyone, yet no one finds it trite or obvious. 

    - The Bible is remarkable in its historical accuracy, in 
      terms of the described geography, the times and founding
      of nations, the names of kings, etc.  In fact, the 
      historical elements are so accurate that they have been
      used as a guide to locate dig sites in archeology.  Yet
      it goes from secular history to miraculous accounts
      in one breath, the two being integrated in the stories
      and hard to separate.  It is hard to account for such
      a mixture of highly accurate history with fantasy. 

The historical fact of Jesus' resurrection

    - The resurrection of Jesus is claimed to have taken place
      well within the lifetimes of the gospel writers, yet 
      even hostile witnesses of the era write accounts
      consistent with its occurance.  This would have been an 
      immensely difficult message to propogate at the time, 
      akin to claiming now that John F. Kennedy had risen from
      the dead.  Moreover, the claimed support for the fact 
      does not take an authoriarian form, but references
      local witnesses.  (e.g., not "Paul says so", but 
      "Ask around, lots of people saw him." )

    - The founding of Christianity took place in the midst of
      powerful forces wishing to discredit it.  As the 
      resurrection of Jesus was the central fact on which it
      rested, it must not have been possible to disprove,
      either by the Jewish (religious) authority or by the
      Roman (state) authority.  The heavily persecuted
      church was in no position to perpetrate a fraud. 

    - The psychological activity of the early church is 
      consistent with people who believed Jesus had risen from
      the dead, and is completely at odds with their own 
      recorded behavior after his death.  They literally
      went from scattered and demoralized to boldly inviting
      death. 

    - The choice of Sunday as a day of worship is completely 
      unexpected for people of a Jewish background, and is
      evidence of a major theological event occuring on
      a Sunday. 

    - Eleven of the twelve apostles (founders of Christianity)
      were killed for their faith.  The twelfth served life 
      in prison.  All of them went to their graves still
      claiming the resurrection was a reality. 

The experience of the modern church

    - Christianity as a religion was explosive at its founding
      and is today practiced worldwide.  Only two other religions
      can make such a claim, both of which are closely related
      to Christianity.  Something happened  thousands of years 
      ago, and everyone is *still* talking about it and reacting 
      to it.   If God ever did act in history, that scale of
      result is appropriate. 

    - The modern church is filled with people who will say
      an encounter with Jesus changed their lives.  Not just
      spiritually; practically: reformed criminals, selfish
      people who have become generous, crazy people who
      have become sane, etc.  Whatever else you can say
      about the gospel, it clearly *works*.  This sort of
      impact is appropriate for God's central message.

    - The modern chuch still experiences miracles and divine
      intervention. (Controversial -- I reference my own
      experience here.) 

    - Many famous heroes of history reference Christianity as
      the source of their ideas.  For example, church organizations
      were central in the abolition of slavery.  

    - Many famous Christian apologists began as atheists who 
      became convinced of the truth of Christianity through
      (initially hostile) study.  G.K. Chesterton, C.S. Lewis,
      Lee Strobel, to begin with.  In fact, I would say this
      is more the rule than the exception.  This flow of 
      immigration is appropriate for an intellectually sound
      message.

The Origin of the Universe

    - The more distantly one goes back in cosmic history,
      the more remarkable are the coincidences that that make
      human life possible.  If this universe wasn't designed
      for us, then there must be a HELL of a lot of other, 
      barren universes out there. 

    - "First Law" -- As natural laws are simply descriptions
      of regularities in nature, they cannot indefinitely
      explain themselves.  The moon orbits because of gravity,
      gravity is caused by something else, etc., but it cannot
      be turtles all the way down.  

    - The laws of the universe are awfully beautiful, certainly
      beyond anything we could write.  If the universe was
      designed, it certainly is the work of a superintelligence
      of God's calibur.
Re:Sometimes The Bad Guys Win by Dove on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @04:17PM (#2971225)
That's just off the top of my head; apologetics is a big field.

Of course, all of these and more warrant a lot of study and consideration, and if you go somewhere like infidels.org, you will find answers for all of them (of varying quality). As I say, there is no such thing as proof. But there can be compelling evidence.

I think the most forceful thing to me is really the comprehensive case. Almost across the board, I think the Christian worldview is significantly more intellectually satisfying than the atheist one. Literally, better explanations. The universe looks like God created it, and happily that's what I believe. The atheist explanation has a lot of unverifiable stuff about parallel universes and a lot of "I don't know, I don't have to explain everything." The Bible looks like God wrote it, and happily that's what I believe. I haven't read an atheist explanation for it yet that sounds like the author has actually read the basic history. The Church looks like God runs it, and happily that's what I believe. The atheist explanation makes it pretty clear they have no idea what church even is. My mystical experience looks like communication with God, and happily that's what I believe. The atheist explanation involves waffling and ghosts. Or sometimes aliens.

If it was just one thing, I might say it was a fluke. If those cases that I say look like God's work were vacuous explanations (in the sense that God can do anything), it would be dumb. But look, if you get into the evidence, the Christian worldview is just . . . better. Intellectually, it's way better.

The only advantage to atheism is that you get to look like you're superior to everyone else. If you're a Christian, a lot of people think you're crazy, dumb, or both. I honestly think atheism is sold on pride. And maybe hatred for God, the church, and Christians, at least to judge from the rhetoric. It sure as heck ain't the evidence. If you follow reason wherever it leads, and don't care who ridicules you, you wind up as a Christian. Lots of folks have done just that.

Re:Sometimes The Bad Guys Win by JoachimSchipper on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @05:31PM (#2971544)
[Sorry for entering this far-too-long thread; your message popped up in "comments" and looked interesting; I'm just making a side comment.]

Your criticism that many atheists don't really "get" Christianity is, I think, correct. Certainly, something like Dawkin's "The God Delusion" is a wonderful rallying cry, but hardly an earnest and respectful attempt to convince the other side.

Nonetheless, your own characterization of the atheist side is not entirely fair either. People like Dawkins and the late James Randi are passionate, but passionate scientists - Randi really would have paid his prize for a repeat of many of the miracles described in the gospels, and Dawkins does (did?) try to fairly weigh the evidence, as a scientist should. In fact, an unambiguous miracle in Randi's labs, replicated a few times, would convert a significant fraction of today's atheists: they aren't committed to hating God, they've just drawn a negative conclusion after earnestly considering the evidence.

The level of debate from either side tends to be low, but remember that a prepared and intelligent person winning a debate with an idiot doesn't really prove the truth of the debated position either way. No matter what you believe, there are (some) intelligent, truth-loving and earnestly convinced people on the other side of the divide[1]; it's good to have some idea about how these people can be so wrong.

[I'm a first-generation atheist and consider studying religion(s) to be a bit of a hobby.]

[1] (Actually, don't forget about the Muslims, Jews, Hindus, etc; there are more than two parties in this debate.)

Re:Sometimes The Bad Guys Win by Dove on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @05:47PM (#2971627)
Well said.

I am aware that much of the venom projected at Christians by atheists is a result of the worldview, not the cause. By some accounts, our willful ignorance is endangering civilization. I'd be mad, too.

And I think some of it is just. A lot of secular critiques of the church as being mindless and anti-science . . . are right. And there are religious scholars making the same argument.

My take that atheism is about pride and hatred -- that's a personal judgement based on experience. It seems to me that most of the folks I talk to are atheists because of emotional issues they have, not because of evidence. But I certainly acknowledge that such a generalization is not a rule.

And it certainly, certainly is the case that the universe is a big and mysterious enough place that smart, honest people can disagree.

And honestly, I wish we'd talk more. I think our worldviews would be richer for it.