No one has to propose it openly since the threat is implicit. Regardless of what is said at the moment of creation of the domain, all that a would-be censor has to do is wait [Internet-memory-erasure-period] and say "hey, we created XXX because all the porn is supposed to only be here" and viola.
ZOMG !!!!111oneone!!!
--
1 - voila is the English language word equivalent to voilà. Voilà is French and so should be italicised to indicate it's a foreign word. There's no need to use voilà as one can use voila. Viola!!!!!oneone11!
Windows: Alt-0-2-2-4 = à. Go Microsoft!
Regardless, I could see this being used as an excuse to shunt porn sites to .xxx, even if doing so wouldn't actually solve anything.
As part of a filter I imagine $domain.$tld would get a highscore if $domain.xxx exists.
What threat? There is no threat at all. It is not implicit or explicit. It is just another TLD for them to move into and make $$$.
Meta tags are an application level concept and so they have to be implemented at that level via browsers or HTTP proxies, or deep packet inspection.
DNS based filtering can be done more simply via network layer devices without having to look at the application level content. So DNS filters would work even if the website content was encrypted, for example.
From an administrative point of view it is much easier to control and manage network infrastructure than it is to control individual browsers or application level gateways.
This is one reason why global top level domains are a bad idea, there is no clear legal jurisdiction for them unlike country code domains. A legal framework can be built around xxx.us, for example, because it would map to an existing legal jurisdiction. The same can't be said for .xxx or meta-tags in documents served from arbitrary domains/locations.
The XXX in the URL makes the content filtering human readable. That is hugely important, and a service that can only be provided by a TLD.
That said, I agree that this is nothing but a new way to heckle money.
Content filters abide by it, and it doesn't disrupt existing business.
.xxx is just an effort to make money with another new TLD. It doesn't make the web safer and it doesn't make content-filters simpler or more accurate.
Since no one is proposing forcing sites to use .xxx, those concerned with truly making the web safer should really be looking for the most effective way to get wide penetration of a labeling solution, and a meta tag is about as simple as simple gets.