News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Krugman on BitCoin by 2arrs2ells on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @03:39PM (#2971058)
If money is decreasing in value, it gives people a huge incentive to do something with it - buy something or invest. As long as the decrease to the value is small (1-3%) and predictable, this is a good thing.
Re:Krugman on BitCoin by tptacek on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @03:43PM (#2971078)
Since deflation is an obvious tax on investment and purchasing, arguments that increases in the value of a currency are "obviously" a good thing serve as a sort of litmus test for why people are interested in things like Bitcoin.

The subtextual motivation for Bitcoin advocacy has always been "it's a speculative asset and I hold a position in it". Everything else is just rhetorical cover.

The unfortunate reality is that even by reasoning through Bitcoin's programmed-in deflation, we're dignifying Bitcoin. Bitcoin itself is a sham. The original paper may have been a good-faith contribution to the state of the art in cryptocurrencies, but the "economy" is a trap; a realistic-looking distributed transaction clearing system built on a deliberately volatile wholly synthetic "asset" that exists for the purpose of creating pump-and-dump scams.

Re:Krugman on BitCoin by JoachimSchipper on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @03:55PM (#2971129)
I wouldn't be so sure that the (original) Bitcoin people are running a pump-and-dump scam - there is very little evidence either way. And there are plenty of people who genuinely seem to believe that Twitter causes and/or wins revolutions: love of technology, libertarianism and something we'll call optimism do occur together, and cypherpunks are not the least vulnerable.
Re:Krugman on BitCoin by tptacek on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @03:57PM (#2971136)
To be clear: I'm not saying the original design was a scam. Only its realization as a real system people can interact with and spend money on.

This whole system is morally no different than Zynga tomorrow setting up a system to trade options on Farmville tomatoes.

Re:Krugman on BitCoin by JoachimSchipper on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @04:12PM (#2971201)
To be clear: I think that some people really do believe that Bitcoin is going to overthrow the monetary system and free us all from the evil government. I also think that quite a few more people believe that Bitcoin can only go up (designed for deflation, right?)

"Bitcoin is a scam" is simply not enough to explain stuff from the Bitcoin bulletin to open source GPU mining software - hard work by obviously capable people, and not even remotely the most effective way to become rich.

Mind you, I think the "true believers" are incorrect, sometimes naive and occasionally downright stupid; but declaring them "evil" leaves quite a few unanswered questions. [EDIT: Even if the speculators are probably in the majority.]

(Also, I wouldn't be surprised if EVE had a foostone contract future market...)

EDIT: also, there was nothing wrong with the system design. A bit uninspired, maybe; current research involves zero-knowledge exchanges and the like.

Re:Krugman on BitCoin by Steko on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @05:51PM (#2971646)
The people that recommended Madoff's fund to their family and friends were probably well intentioned too. And the fund probably wasn't a Ponzi scheme from the beginning either but in the end a scam is a scam.
Re:Krugman on BitCoin by Amincd on Thursday September 08, 2011 @07:01PM (#2976033)
People trading goods and services cannot be a sham. Your definition of a sham is "something I believe will depreciate".
Re:Krugman on BitCoin by sesqu on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @04:07PM (#2971179)
I don't really buy this argument. People invest to increase their capital, not to stop it from decreasing. When inflationary pressure is actually tangible, money becomes a hot potato that no one wants, and poof, there goes the economy in a blaze of hyperinflation.

Arguing that inflation is good is tantamount to arguing that illiquidity is good. If I were to argue for inflation, I would go with some other angle, like that capital should evaporate after a lifetime.

Re:Krugman on BitCoin by caf on Thursday September 08, 2011 @01:10AM (#2972714)
In between "hot potato that nobody wants to hold" and "gold brick that nobody wants to relinquish from their grasp" lies the happy medium that we need.
Re:Krugman on BitCoin by SkyMarshal on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @09:18PM (#2972218)
Inflation != hyperinflation. You're conflating the two in your argument.
Re:Krugman on BitCoin by sesqu on Thursday September 08, 2011 @02:05AM (#2972809)
Yes. When the argument for inflation is that rational actors should not want to hold on to money, I will conflate it with the scenario where rational actors should not want to receive money.