For me, they replaced getting a second car when my partner started working a bit further away. I've even found myself walking the full hour+ to the office I'm in these days if I leave early enough, depending on my mood as I get to the scooter.
I also worked at a place, and I think this is common, where such rides are reimbursable. Car ownership costs are not.
How many people are moved by shared scooters over its lifetime and how much energy went into its production and maintenance? Depending on the answers to these questions, shared scooters could certainly be worse in general. These seem to be the sort of questions the original study is trying to address.
I agree. Mobility pretty much directly correlates with QoL. It's a trip to the bar, to see grandma, to the supermarket that doesn't screw you on price, to the job you don't hate.
But people are gonna get some ideological whiplash because they're so used to slinging around tropes about induced demand being bad.
Its just saying emissionAmount(method) < emissionAmount(otherMethod)
results might surprise you
That seems counter-intuitive. If I had to get somewhere not served by public transport, I would simply drive there. Having a conveinient way to get an e-bike once I get to the closest transit stop is the thing that would make me consider not taking the car.
Did these guys get public funding for this?
I skimmed the article and I commented.
walking
using a non-motorized bike
or not making the trip at all.
They werent using public transportation, rideshares or cars to begin with, so it isnt reducing them. Thats the full extent of the study and it quantified that.
So therefore, worse.