News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jack Welch: China losing competitiveness. Must Create '10... by ajross on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @02:55PM (#2970883)
No, that's just wrong. The people at the bottom certainly don't lose.

Japan was at the bottom (of industrial economies) in the post war world and leveraged those low wages to re-industrialize and get to the top. China did the same thing in the 80's and 90's, and is now seeing upwards wage pressure as they approach a first-world level of economic activity.

Next up will be the Indias and Vietnams of the world. Hopefully eventually subsaharan africa will get there.

This is a good thing, overall. Yes, working conditions at "the bottom" are often huge problems (though again: remember the comparison is to abject poverty). And yes, rapid change causes people to lose jobs elsewhere faster than they can be replaced, and that sucks for those people.

But to argue that chasing cheap wages is inherently bad is isomorphic to arguing that poor people should always be poor, and that's much less palatable to me.

Re:Jack Welch: China losing competitiveness. Must Create '10... by tadfisher on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @04:59PM (#2971427)
Japan and China also had an advantage over the Industrial Revolution countries in that all of their capital didn't have to be created anew. It took 150 years for the US to get to where Japan got in under 60.