News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: We built an app for reading articles saved for l... by shkliarau on Monday December 27, 2021 @01:32PM (#29705227)
It is on-topic :) Thanks for saying that, I felt a bit like that when designing it but the feedback we’ve gotten so far was really positive. Might consider something less in a good sense overwhelming for the next version
Re:Show HN: We built an app for reading articles saved for l... by tnjm on Monday December 27, 2021 @01:39PM (#29705317)
While this isn't for me as I don't use iOS daily, I wanted to say that I'm impressed with your response to feedback.

And, for what it's worth, I saw the landing page on desktop and it felt nicely done, and the animations had a purpose.

Re:Show HN: We built an app for reading articles saved for l... by shkliarau on Monday December 27, 2021 @02:14PM (#29705736)
Ha, thanks! Just trying my best, first time (or maybe second) posting here
Re:Show HN: We built an app for reading articles saved for l... by tailspin2019 on Monday December 27, 2021 @04:18PM (#29706886)
It’s really nicely done on the whole!

My feeling is that there is just a bit too much motion happening at once. I think the issue is that as you scroll (I’m on an iPhone) your eye is drawn to the content that has just scrolled into view but the content below then starts to animate too early, so you’re distracted by the motion happening below the content that you’re trying to read.

This happens multiple times (for each content block…)

I think you probably just need to delay the start of the next animation until you’ve scrolled down a bit further, and perhaps even reduce the amount of movement? It doesn’t need much motion to still give that dynamic feel.

It’s so close to being quite an awesome landing page otherwise!

Edit: also while we’re all here playing backseat designer…. The first animation of the iPhone showing some sort of archiving sequence seems to run too early for me - I don’t really understand what it’s demonstrating. By the time I’ve scrolled the iPhone into view, the archive overlay has already popped out and I didn’t get chance to see what the screen before that was showing. So it’s slightly confusing (though it looks nice!)

Re:Show HN: We built an app for reading articles saved for l... by shkliarau on Monday December 27, 2021 @04:39PM (#29707095)
Thanks a lot for such a detailed reply! I agree with a lot of your feedback but I’m limited by Readymag which I used to create the site which doesn’t allow me to set animations quite right but I’ll try again :)