Nobody denies lockdowns have damaging effects in other areas.
That leaves a discussion about what kinds of lockdowns are worth the benefits they bring. But seems to me the sub isn't geared towards finding that truth?
Just to check in with you - and this is honestly meant as a check-in and not an insult: do you realize how unabashedly privileged you sound? I ask this first because I know that for me, I often don't realize when I make statements that reflect my own privilege, and I find that when that happens, it's almost always a chance to learn something new and important. I hope that is the case here.
Let's look at how lockdowns _actually_ interdict spread:
I'm reasonably affluent. Long-time remote worker in a fairly elite engineering position. I am able to sit in my home and order everything I need delivered to me. I live in a two-generation household, and I'm the oldest. We are all at low risk for adverse outcomes from SARS-CoV-2. In fact, for us, the risk is statistically difficult to distinguish from any other year's circulating pathogens.
Meanwhile, the person delivering things to me (and thus entering and leaving dozens of restaurants and stores every day to obtain the things for me and my affluent neighbors) is far more likely to live with a higher-risk relative and also more likely to live in a three-generation home (which is a fairly dire situation in light of this pathogen).
Let's imagine that my delivery worker lives with his 82-year-old grandmother with untreated high blood pressure. For her, in contrast to me, the risk this year is _nothing_ like that resulting from a typical year's respiratory pathogens. It's perhaps as much as 100x higher. Her risk of hospitalization - which she is also less likely to be able to afford - may be as high as 10%, compared to my small fraction of a percent.
As the months go on, I'm "protected" from infection. Instead of being able to adjoin the cohort of the highest spread acuity and then isolate (which I believe is my civic duty as a low risk person, to protect my higher-risk neighbors), I have to wait a year or more for my inevitable infection.
But that's not the end of the world, right? I had to mostly socially isolate and work remotely for a while, cancel a bunch of trips, etc. But all in all, nothing to cry over.
Now: what about my delivery driver and his grandma? For them, my delay in getting infected comes at an enormous cost. Namely, it increases the overall chance that the high-risk members of their family will be infected. They might possibly be able to interdict infection across their three-generation household for a few weeks, but not for years.
Now perhaps you see the actual first-order impact of lockdowns: they don't simply "slow the spread", they actually break one of the most important tools humans have in our collective ability to fight infectious disease: our social proclivity to facilitate differences in spread acuity _by risk_. We are actually very good at ensuring that young, healthy people share pathogens and develop community immunity quickly.
By preventing that, we protect only those privileged enough among us to isolate more-or-less indefinitely. In other words, lockdowns don't change spread acuity, they just shift its stratification from being by risk (which is great for preventing adverse outcomes) to being by socioeconomic status (which is arguably the worst possible approach if the goal is to prevent adverse outcomes). My friend Jay Bhattacharya at Stanford refers to this situation as "let it drip" (a play on words in the face of "let it rip", a sophomoric slogan used by opponents of traditional vertical risk stratification).
So, what we're saying is that we can observe not only the collateral consequences of lockdowns (which of course are devastating), but also an undesirable impact in first-order effects: lockdowns which are long enough to decrease spread acuity in the low-risk tier also increase first-order death in the high-risk tier.
This is the reason that lockdowns (previously referred to as "quarantine of the healthy") are advised against in the published pandemic plans prior to 2019. By all means, go to Google Scholar (or your search engine of choice for scholarly material) and drive yourself down this memory lane. You'll be astounded and almost certainly come out the other end a lockdown skeptic.
What I'm saying is, is that lockdowns technically work. Keep everyone inside (including the delivery guy) and spreading will be reduced. Let's take this one step further. What if we could (hypothetically) isolate the entire planet for 1 month. We might just completely irradicate a whole bunch of deceases. But of course it would come at a cost.
Lockdowns are just one of the tools we have at our disposal. There's no doubt they work. Viruses don't spread telepathically. This in itself is nothing to be skeptical about. The only question is if the benefits outweigh the costs. A better name for the sub would perhaps have been: /r/lockdownpolicyskepticism
I doubt we'd eradicate any disease which is a significant threat to humankind with a month of isolation, for two reasons:
* In the case of many pathogens, there are extreme outliers who remain contagious for months (and of course with others, such as some retroviruses, it is normal to remain contagious indefinitely).
* There are sufficient animal reservoirs for many pathogens (including SARS-CoV-2 and influenza and many other respiratory pathogens) that, no matter how long humans isolate, they'll be exposed rapidly upon emergence.
> There's no doubt they work.
I'm not sure how you can say this, when a giant chorus of experts from all of the world's foremost institutions of medical research have expressed exactly this doubt.
I appreciate the exercise of your hypothetical, but even in the extreme case you present, it's far from clear that it will have an impact which reduces adverse outcomes. And in the real world, with its imperfections? I see no reason to believe that lockdowns have any positive impact, first- or second-order.
There's no doubt. It's scientific fact that the virus cannot spread when its host doesn't occupy spaces that other people do. Besides it being a "rain is wet" kind of thing, it's also backup up by scientific research.
The discussion is about what flavor of lockdown offers sufficient benefits that outweigh the costs. And if such flavors can be enforced.
Do I understand correctly that you are saying, for example, that lockdowns will somehow eliminate a virus from animal reservoirs? Or stop spread within a household? Or ameliorate rare but important cases in which a host remains contagious for much longer than is typical?
Horizontally interdiction is sometimes possible with pathogens with spread via the fecal-oral route, or STIs, or arboviruses, or hemorrhagic fevers, etc.
But a highly contagious respiratory pathogen with robust, worldwide animal reservoirs? I do not agree that it is "scientific fact" (whatever that phrase even means) that mere separation of humans can achieve a reduction in adverse outcomes (setting aside, as you rightly acknowledge, the collateral effects).
But you seem to be under the impression that there exists no form of lockdown that works. That's simply not true. We've already seen various real-world examples of successful lockdowns. China did them. New Zealand did so successfully in 2020. Italy did them when they were first hit.
Lockdowns simply work. The virus cannot spread between people that are isolated from each other. That's simple scientific fact. It's scientifically known how the virus transmits itself.
Take a simple experiment. 2 rooms opposing sides of the planet. 1 person in each room. 1 person infected. 1 person uninfected. There's simply no way the infected person can infect the uninfected person. They would need to get into contact with each other to allow the virus to spread.
If you keep the entire population locked up. If you implement a total curfew. Police the streets so that everyone stays inside. There is no doubt spreading will be reduced significantly. But we don't want to live in China.
So the question isn't if lockdowns work. They work perfectly. The question is what form of lockdown outweighs the costs to warrant putting them in place.
> We've already seen various real-world examples of successful lockdowns. China did them. New Zealand did so successfully in 2020. Italy did them when they were first hit.
This is absolute, total nonsense. Neither China nor New Zealand have implemented anything resembling a successful strategy in anything but the very short-term. Both are still dealing with this virus, and are _further_ from endemic equilibrium than Florida and Sweden (which also made terrible mistakes obviously).
> Take a simple experiment. 2 rooms opposing sides of the planet. 1 person in each room. 1 person infected. 1 person uninfected. There's simply no way the infected person can infect the uninfected person. They would need to get into contact with each other to allow the virus to spread.
I don't understand how you can tell this story when it is so obviously empirically false.
There were _zero_ infected people only two years ago. Now there have been billions of cases.
It seems that you don't really fully believe in germ theory? Or something?
In your experiment, I guarantee the uninfected person will eventually become infected, via contact with animal reservoirs if not the normal course of living and making contact for routine purposes such as acquiring food and medical care.
I'll give you an even more strident experiment: take two people, both uninfected with H3N2, no demonstrable cases at all in the entire world in the human population (such as happens some years with influenza near the equinox or during a period of strong viral interference). What do you think will happen? Obviously both of them will become infected because of the enormous and enduring reservoir in the bird population.
Now consider that coronaviruses are even more infectious and have a wider diversity of animal reservoirs.
Seriously: how do you think pandemics emerge? Even though there is an endemic H3N2, pandemic H1N1 (or other influenza A subtypes) still break out, starting with _zero_ cases. Or do you deny that pandemic influenza is still possible?
Horizontal interdiction does not work with respiratory pathogens. Not on small or large scales. Pathogens which are sufficiently deadly can burn themselves out without being transmitted to an available susceptible, but this is a different phenomenon.
> If you keep the entire population locked up. If you implement a total curfew. Police the streets so that everyone stays inside. There is no doubt spreading will be reduced significantly.
In such a scenario, you're correct that spreading in the community will likely be less acute, but spread within households will likely be more acute. And then what? The virus will be no nearer to endemic equilibrium than when you started. So you'll have to facilitate the same acute spread you blocked in the first place.
> So the question isn't if lockdowns work. They work perfectly.
This is just a completely indefensible position in light of the data. No nation on earth has eliminated the virus, nor achieved endemic equilibrium with a lockdown in place. Every place that has done testing has found positive animal reservoirs. Just... stop.
> The question is what form of lockdown outweighs the costs to warrant putting them in place.
This is true, but it's not only the collateral damage that is to be measured. It is also the first-order effects, such as more acute spread in the household, delayed endemic equilibrium, etc. In addition to the collateral damage, lockdowns appear to cause more adverse outcomes _from the pathogen in question_.
I think New Zealand was free from Covid for maybe 1 year? I wouldn't call that short-term. While many countries were locked down, they were enjoying parties and festivals. If they would've kept themselves isolated from the rest of the world, they'd still be Covid-free.
> In such a scenario, you're correct that spreading in the community will likely be less acute
Yes, so that was the point. Lockdowns work to reduce spreading. We are in agreement.
> , but spread within households will likely be more acute.
Spreading within households would only occur for those households containing an infected person. This wouldn't be a very large percentage of the total households. 2 ~ 4 weeks later those households would've been recovered. A significant reduction would've been achieved. But it would come at great costs. And would only delay the inevitable once everything opens up again.
And do you think covid is worse than or same as the flu?
Not that you asked me- I would classify it as "different" than the flu, that it affects different individuals differently, and that the original variant was definitely something more scary than the flu. Especially due to the novelty of the spike protein. Now- I view omicron as about as dangerous as the flu for a much smaller subset of people than the flu is dangerous for. Especially when you account for age and comorbidities. The flu kills children, while covid generally does not.
I have a hard time accepting this premise. Mostly because the flu was somehow eradicated at the outset of mass covid testing, many of the covid tests did not distinguish between the flu and covid. Furthermore, I believe that we actually responded to covid in a way that caused excess covid deaths by over counting deaths and actively suppressing unpatentable treatments for covid. I think we hospitalized people that didn't need to be hospitalized, and we told people not to do anything until they needed to be hospitalized. We then started putting too many people on vents, giving them Remdesiver(toxic with highly questionable efficacy), and putting covid patients in nursing homes with the most vulnerable population. Not to mention lockdowns that pushed a huge portion of the world into poverty, nutritional deficiency, and much more susceptible to adverse effects from disease as a result.
But those are just my thoughts- I don't think we have good enough data, nor will we ever- to actually make strong conclusions either way.
Did you know "the flu" is actually many strains, the most prevalent of which changes season to season? It is not surprising to me that Covid "won out" this season. Plus a record number of people got the flu vaccine during the pandemic. Here is what the CDC says about lower flu numbers [1]
> many of the covid tests did not distinguish between the flu and covid.
That's just not true.
> lockdowns that pushed a huge portion of the world into poverty
What would you do to mitigate the spread of a pandemic?
[1] https://www.cdc.gov/flu/season/faq-flu-season-2020-2021.htm
Issue public health advisory encouraging people to eat healthier, exercise, and possibly even offer subsidies on healthy groceries and vitamins. Vitamin D deficiency is highly correlated to negative outcomes with covid infection. To this day, our federal health organizations haven't even issued statements encouraging people to eat healthier or even do something simple and easy like address vitamin D deficiency. The messaging has been negligent at best.
I would not engage in a fear campaign, and lock people inside. Most spread was occuring between family members confining themselves inside, and stress wreaks havoc on your immune system. We've been subjected to fear induced mass psychosis for the past two years, and as a result have acquired a learned helplessness when it comes to our personal health.
I would also take steps to address to hospital staffing and capacity issues. In the USA, hospitals always run at near capacity, for financial reasons. Instead of refusing to upset that delicate balance game they play, incentives should have been put into to place to bolster staffing so that hospitals wouldn't be overwhelmed. Simply not using hospitals had the effect of killing many more people that were now missing early health screenings.
I would have also liked to see only the most vulnerable be locked down, and only on a volunteer basis. A western, non authoritarian government, has no way to truly implement lockdowns effectively. Partial lockdowns have no benefits, since they didn't actually stop the spread of anything. Instead they caused irreparable harm where they were implemented with very little benefit. Basically security theater. I understand the original intentions, but the prolonged lockdowns, justified by poor metrics of "success" quickly became a political response instead of a scientific response.
Lastly, outpatient clinical attempts at treating covid with repurposed existing drugs should have been prioritized. Trump's warp speed and prep act created insane incentives to actively hamper any attempts to treat covid except pharma approved methods. This whole response feels like the AIDS response all over again, except with more media coverage, widespread corruption, and money at play.
Regarding hospital staffing, I'm not sure where money for that would come from if not largely paid by patients or insurance plans. I certainly wouldn't want to see that whole system become state-owned. We should encourage rather than stifle competition.
What do you mean when you say that tests did not distinguish between COVID and the flu? Are you referring to simultaneous infection? I'm not aware of any PCR or antigen tests for COVID which would produce positive results for flu patients. Nor any antigen or rapid molecular assays for the flu which would produce positives for COVID patients.
Seems much more reasonable that social distancing and masking significantly reduced flu transmission.
https://www.lewrockwell.com/2021/07/no_author/cdc-to-withdra...
Which appears to use one sentence, taken out of context (read the very next sentence), from a CDC post recommending that PCRs be used to test for both flu and covid simultaneously because, well, we're in flu season and people might have either one when they show up at a hospital sick.
So yes, that is perfectly normal and expected.
Perhaps all those basic public health measures implemented to contain and eliminate the spread of air borne diseases such as COVID or the flu is a factor?
I mean,the lockdowns alone have a clear and critical and measurable (and measured) impact in lowering the spread of COVID. Wouldn't it be possible that staying away from people with the flu was also a factor in not catching the flu?
If you go by age-adjusted excess mortality then most countries reached levels last seen about a decade ago, more or less. The UK for example I think was 'rolled back' to 2007/2008 levels of mortality, Sweden back to 2012.
So 10x worse than worst flu years just doesn't seem right at all and I wonder where you got that stat. One thing that is clear is that the general population systematically over-estimates the severity of COVID by orders of magnitude.
https://news.gallup.com/opinion/gallup/354938/adults-estimat...
There's a similar French poll out there, probably they exist for many countries. IFR estimates in these polls are wild, like 100x-200x higher than the correct values. So it's worth checking that you're familiar with the true numbers, as many people aren't, yet think they're well informed.
It's a very heterogenous sub, but I don't think you'll find the kind of anti-vax thinking that suggests that, eg, childhood vaccination is unhelpful to a society, if that's what you're asking. If you are asking more strictly about sentiment toward the currently available SARS-CoV-2 vaccines, I think that by and large we think they're a marvel of engineering, but have an array of assessments and opinions regarding pandemic-timeline vaccination, what it's meant to accomplish, and whether genuine public health decisions in such a context can ever be made independently of profit motivations of vaccine makers. As for the mod team, I think I can confidently say that we view the vaccines as very useful tools and owe the engineering teams (both who have worked these decades to make mRNA platforms a reality and those who lost sleep to crank these vaccines out) a debt of gratitude.
> And do you think covid is worse than or same as the flu?
By "the flu", I presume you mean the H3N2 influenza which began as the 1968 pandemic and has since been endemic, causing seasonal outbreaks most years, rather than epidemic influenza which of course happens from time to time (eg, the 2009 H1N1 pandemic).
I don't think there's any remaining need to speculate: the wealth of evidence clearly demonstrates that COVID-19 is far more likely than seasonal influenza to result in hospitalization and death for the elderly with comorbidities, less likely than influenza to do so in young and middle-aged healthy people, and similarly likely as influenza for people in the middle.
This has been evident, and has held true, since last summer, when John Ioannidis published this paper on the topic: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S001393512...
I want to point out that opposition to lockdowns, almost without exception, does not turn on the population mortality rate of the pathogen in question. In fact, if the pathogen were even more dangerous, we suggest that lockdowns are likely to be an even worse idea.
Lockdowns necessarily cause stratification by socioeconomic status rather than by risk. Even in an 'effective' lockdown, we still see spread among the "essential workers" who keep society going, and in their households, which are disproportionately likely to be multigen.
To the degree that lockdowns actually slow spread, this means that people in the high-risk tier (in this case, mostly elderly people) have to isolate _longer_ to wait for the spread to complete among the lower risk tiers. This may be acceptable for affluent households with remote jobs and the ability to have all of their needs met via delivery, but is obviously untenable for our marginalized neighbors who cannot afford periods of extended isolation.
How do you explain countries like Vietnam, China, Taiwan, New Zealand, Australia, where Covid was eliminated from their societies via lockdown (and border control to prevent re-introduction) before the Delta variant spread? It's true that only China and Taiwan have retained Covid-Zero status in the face of Delta, but it seems like the success of lockdowns turns upon characteristics of the pathogen including its population mortality (the more deadly the virus, the more likely the population will support and assist in extreme measures to control and eliminate it within national borders).
As for other places, for some reason COVID seems less severe in east Asia in general. You left out Japan where COVID has not been particularly serious and which also used quite light measures, especially in the early days.
Really, this has been done to death by now. Lockdowns don't have any effect. Some people thought they did because the natural wave pattern happened to overlap with when lockdowns were brought in and epidemiologists - perhaps the most useless form of expertise in the world - were united in believing that COVID wasn't going to be seasonal, for no obvious reason. So they just ascribed the fall in cases to their brilliant policies instead of the true cause. Once COVID came back at different times in different countries much more data became available and it started to show the truth: NPIs like lockdowns, masks, contact tracing etc were all useless. Only very early and very harsh border controls seemed to have much effect, and even then only temporarily.
China now has local transmission in Xian, known for the terracotta warriors. It's arguable they never stopped local transmission and simply stopped reporting cases and deaths accurately once covid took off outside China. They stopped recording deaths at around 4,000 in March 2020.
The latter is not mere fatalism, by the way. It's simply acceptance that at this time, with our current level of understanding and abilities, we cannot stop respiratory illnesses from spreading and frankly, even claims about stopping "severe illness" are all horribly confounded by massive conflicts of interest and a culture of dishonesty in public health. As this paper is now showing, in fact, Moderna was advertised as perfectly safe and an obvious no-brainer tradeoff free improvement. In fact it's not, it's taken a very long time to realize this, and in fact there's certainly a lot of cases that the medical system isn't aware of. As such we cannot actually say whether the vaccines are helping or harming over-all because the damages inflicting aren't being measured properly, or at all. And indeed in many parts of the world excess death is actually positive in 2021, instead of negative as it should be given an effective vaccine (overhang from 2020 pushing it down + effective vaccines reducing COVID excess to zero).
https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2021/12/05/1059828...
As another commenter as has pointed out, the graph in question in included in the PDF version of this preprint (which you can see here: https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.12.02.21267156v...).
I want to add: "this guy" is Vinay Prasad, a professor of oncology at UCSF and an incredibly prescient thinker through the COVID-19 pandemic, and someone with whome I've had the joy to correspond and repeatedly be impressed by his straightforward, evidence-based, dry-witty way of thinking, writing, and speaking.
He's a significant up-and-come in medical science, without a doubt, and someone to follow if you are interested in science-based policy.
We had the pleasure of hosting an AMA with him on /r/lockdownskepticism which you may find enjoyable and educational: https://www.reddit.com/r/LockdownSkepticism/comments/m0ll33/...