News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Researchers forecast a hard-to-imagine West – one without... by _3u10 on Sunday December 26, 2021 @08:07PM (#29697962)
Whenever anything related to the weather happens now it’s climate change.

Dry winter? Climate change. Wet winter? Climate change. Cold summer? Climate change. Heat wave? Climate change. Hurricane? Climate change. Doldrums? Climate change.

Every religion has a global flood myth, climate change is just the one of the scientifically religious and its zealots get just as upset if you don’t believe it as if you think Noah’s ark didn’t happen. Similarly there is no way to disprove it.

You can see the ridiculousness of the situation when it comes to how they prove it, consensus.

Science has never involved consensus, it works on hypothesis and evidence. Similarly no one can agree on which model predicts the future so they run 80,000 models with different parameters and then 20 years later pick whichever one happened to randomly generate the outcome and ignore the 79,999 models which were wrong.

I’m not a denier, I’m open to a single hypothesis, and a length of time in which we can analyze the results.

In summary climate change is a global flood myth and the solution is Pascal’s wager.

And predictably no one points to any evidence they just downvote because they have nothing to say.

Re:Researchers forecast a hard-to-imagine West – one without... by BobbyJo on Sunday December 26, 2021 @08:16PM (#29698014)
There are very clear correlations. The scientists aren't pulling the association out of thin air, it's observed. We have satellites that watch the atmospheric currents and temperature fluctuations, how those drag different temperatures of air to different areas, and back engineer why things are moving the way they are.

The primary example is the weakening of the Arctic air currents causing the cold air to escape. The Arctic then warms faster, and causes short-lived, dramatic drops in temperature in the north Midwest.

We do similar back-engineering with the dry spells on the west coast.

The largest computers in the world are routinely used to simulate the weather and predict changes climate change will cause, and we are getting more and more accurate every year.

Re:Researchers forecast a hard-to-imagine West – one without... by haberman on Sunday December 26, 2021 @09:23PM (#29698393)
If the modeling is this good and this accurate, it would be helpful if consensus predictions were published in a prominent outlet that is easy for the public to consume and compare against empirical data as it comes in. I think this is particularly true if you can make reliable predictions about specific regions.

This would help build credibility. Right now, it seems like many are quick to attribute any kind of unfortunate weather to climate change, even if it leads to ultimately contradictory claims.

For example, a few months ago Scott Alexander posed the question of whether climate change could reduce the number of cold-related deaths. In the comments for that article (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28960588), many countered by saying that climate change is actually predicted to make winters colder on average, and/or increase the number of extreme cold weather events. It was no help that you can find news articles from prominent outlets that appear to make contradictory claims on this point (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28963655).

It took a fair amount of digging into IPCC reports to determine that this appears to be incorrect; the consensus prediction is warming winters (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28963266). But in the thread we couldn't come to agreement on whether the consensus view predicts more or fewer extreme cold events.

Re:Researchers forecast a hard-to-imagine West – one without... by thjkgfgrrioppo on Sunday December 26, 2021 @08:44PM (#29698167)
How long have those satellites been watching? It can't be all that long? It seems to me scientists still find unexpected things.

I think when people first tried to model the three body problem, the planets would just fall apart. But in reality they don't, so they knew they had to try harder. I wonder if many doomsday models are like the three body models that fell apart. And newspapers go "scientists show that earth could float off into space soon".

Re:Researchers forecast a hard-to-imagine West – one without... by _3u10 on Sunday December 26, 2021 @08:28PM (#29698081)
Thank you, I appreciate the discussion rather than downvoting.

Do you think that a weakening current with more water in the atmosphere (atmospheric rivers) will lead to more or less snowfall? Not being sarcastic, it’s just that if both things are true it would indicate that the prediction in this article is wrong.

Unrelated, what are your thoughts on the carboniferous period with 800ppm CO2 and 0 degrees difference in average temp. (This is according to Wikipedia, I can appreciate if the answer is Wikipedia is not reliable on this matter)

Re:Researchers forecast a hard-to-imagine West – one without... by BobbyJo on Sunday December 26, 2021 @10:37PM (#29698854)
> Do you think that a weakening current with more water in the atmosphere (atmospheric rivers) will lead to more or less snowfall? Not being sarcastic, it’s just that if both things are true it would indicate that the prediction in this article is wrong.

Depends on where you are. The center of Africa is all desert. If they start getting a lot of rain, and the PNW gets less, the overall amount of rain falling can increase while the west coast of the US falls apart. Weather isn't uniform, and the climate in various locations is going to change. Some places will likely change for the better while others change for the worse. The issue there is that the places that are great now, but will be worse have a lot more people living in them than the places that are bad now and will get better.

> Unrelated, what are your thoughts on the carboniferous period with 800ppm CO2 and 0 degrees difference in average temp.

I don't know much about it. A good way to frame climate stuff in general: Normally things sit at some equilibrium and experiences a slow change to some new equilibrium due to some natural process. Like the most recent ice age ending. The reason man made climate change specifically is dangerous is we can change one aspect of the current equilibrium faster than all the factors can move to match it. That's why you'll hear people say "We could go carbon neutral today and the Earth will continue warming for decades." It's because we are changing one variable of the equation faster than the others can adjust, which has only happened historically during massive die-offs and extinction events. If we want from 200ppm to 600ppm over 200k years, the consequences would likely be pretty much unnoticed for most animal species. Doing it in 100, not so much.

Re:Researchers forecast a hard-to-imagine West – one without... by dahart on Sunday December 26, 2021 @09:23PM (#29698390)
Re:Researchers forecast a hard-to-imagine West – one without... by _3u10 on Monday December 27, 2021 @01:50AM (#29700124)
Thank you, I’m quite interested, I read as much as I can about it as obviously if it is real it’s quite serious.

The first graph in the first link exemplifies the problems I have with CC evidence, the data presented goes back a long time but not far enough to when we know CO2 was higher.

While it does not outright lie it tailors the data to create the impression that it hasn’t been higher. It’s like when graphs don’t have the axis at zero to exaggerate the differences.

For such a serious topic I would expect less disengenous presentation of the data.

Overall, not your links, but the totality of what I’ve read over the years, I get the feeling of being asked to make a decision based on reading advocacy pieces rather than a summary of the available information regardless of what conclusion it points to.

edit: upon re checking the first link I see the graph is also not centered on zero, again to exaggerate the differences between pre-industrial Revolution and now.

Re:Researchers forecast a hard-to-imagine West – one without... by dahart on Monday December 27, 2021 @02:19AM (#29700276)
Why do you need more that 1 million years? Why is that “disingenuous” to stop before 10 million years?

I agree with your concern about the graph’s Y axis not being zeroed, it should be. Still, the jump in the last century is quite large, right? So why does it matter if CO2 levels were higher before humans existed? Isn’t it concerning you to that CO2 levels have jumped extremely suddenly and with very large magnitude to 30% higher (and growing) than the earth has seen in the last million years? Is your contention that CO2 doesn’t necessarily imply climate change?

This page covers a larger time period: https://earth.org/data_visualization/a-brief-history-of-co2/ It shows a correlation between temperature and CO2 for 10+ million years ago, that would seem to justify concern with today’s skyrocketing CO2 levels, no?

BTW, I think your comment above demonstrates a misunderstanding of what “scientific consensus” means. It doesn’t meant that scientists have gotten together to agree on what the collective will believe. It means that many independent studies and investigations have reached compatible conclusions, that multiple different kinds of hypotheses and evidence are all pointing at the same result.

I will add & admit that using “consensus” is an argument by authority. Personally I think the consensus is worth noting, but that point may be having the opposite effect on you by making you feel pressured to accept it. You’re right that the links I posted are advocacy and lay-person summaries, not scientific sources. The answer to this is to follow the citations and read the actual sources.

Re:Researchers forecast a hard-to-imagine West – one without... by _3u10 on Monday December 27, 2021 @02:49AM (#29700417)
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_dioxide_in_Earth%27s_...

I like this article, it’s the stuff I really dig into. I like your idea of reading the sources, perhaps I will go to that for this one as Wikipedia has lots of sources at the bottom.

As for why it’s important to go back is because I’m interested in how the previous levels were achieved either the high levels so we can mitigate those natural sources or more relevant to today is how the low levels were achieved. I think the data should go back as far as we know, ideally all the way to the creation of the earth. Or at least the great oxidation event.

My understanding is that the all time global low was achieved by trees ending up in swamps in a high oxygen environment (35%) that essentially caused trees to suck all the CO2 out of the atmosphere.

Like here’s the thing, when we had 800ppm CO2 we had coral reefs in the North Pole (the plates have shifted and those fossils are currently in Alberta).

I think society should be given informed consent, we can eliminate CO2 and have the current climate, or we can go to 800ppm and have coral reefs on North Pole.

Also I think if the public knew it would empower our leaders to go toe to toe with China and India. Like if they don’t want to cut, then we go to 800ppm, call us when it gets too hot / the monsoons too severe and we can talk.

You’re definitely correct regarding consensus, I find it to be an appeal to authority and politicians use it to convey that the science favors a particular policy over another.

Re:Researchers forecast a hard-to-imagine West – one without... by dahart on Monday December 27, 2021 @10:40AM (#29703334)
Society should be given informed consent, I agree. But doesn’t that mean everyone should know and understand that most of the actual science being done is all independently and from many different angles coming to the same conclusion that our industrial activities seem to be increasing the CO2 levels and potentially warming the earth much faster than any time in history, and much faster than any of the natural cycles, save for a couple of extreme volcanic eruptions and large meteors? Doesn’t informed consent in fact mean letting the public know that our policy decisions today might affect whether our grandkids can expect to ever see snow? Your argument here seems totally reasonable, I’m just curious how it meshes with your top comment.

Is it really hard to believe, surprising, or even debatable, that running several billion combustion engines all day every day globally that all emit CO2 would increase atmospheric CO2? Is it really in question whether adding a lot of CO2 to the air for a hundred years might raise the temperature?

Be aware that bringing up CO2 levels from 30 million years ago as some kind of demonstration that today’s CO2 levels might be “normal” is also cherry-picking and exaggerating, similar to NASA’s not using zero as the graph’s baseline, it’s also attempting to frame the debate in a way that downplays what’s happening today. The problem isn’t necessarily the CO2 level at all, it’s the magnitude and velocity of the anomaly today relative to recent history. It doesn’t take data from all time to see that the last century’s bump in CO2 levels might be something to worry about.

The problem in the US is we have a political party that denies climate change exists largely on the grounds that doing anything about it will be disruptive to the economy (without worrying whether doing nothing could be even more disruptive, nor what our long term goals are). The primary climate change skeptic argument in this country isn’t based on investigating the science, it’s currently based on denying science. When you said “climate change is a global flood myth” without providing any evidence of why our current published science is wrong, I interpreted that to be a political stance and not one based on science. You do seem genuinely interested in the science though, so it may be important to stop reading material from politicians and focus on investigating primary sources, and understanding what exactly the scientific consensus really is.

What if the politics of climate change denial undermines our ability to have informed consent? What if climate skeptics are winning the debate despite the science, and convincing policy makers to not take action? What exactly are the risks of taking action to reduce emissions, in the cases where the effects have been overstated vs understated? What are the best case and worst case scenarios? Why not reduce emissions anyway just because breathing pollution is causing health problems? The earth is going to survive whatever happens, with or without humans. Life will go on even if we kill ourselves. All the questions and debate are only about what’s good for us humans, and mainly in the short term. We’re fighting over how much money to spend this week and not really talking about what life will be like in a hundred or thousand years.

BTW, your top comment also complained about calling any and all weather anomalies evidence of climate change. FWIW, there is a plausible scientific argument called “global weirding” that centers on the fact that higher temperatures is literally more energy in the system that causes more strange things to happen that haven’t been happening historically. Any single event, single storm, single season, regional weather in a single year, you’re right that none of these by themselves indicate climate change. However, taken as a whole, the increasing frequency of odd/extreme weather events over many recent years is an indicator of change. I like how it’s described here: https://news.northeastern.edu/2012/03/20/globalweirding/