News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tumblr has added more strict tag filtering for their iOS app by noahtallen on Sunday December 26, 2021 @05:16PM (#29696910)
One thing I’ve never been sure of is how Reddit has been so successful with NSFW content. It’s certainly not banned from the platform, so how is it able to get away with it compared to the other services? It’s also mostly an ad business, right? Whereas other as businesses like YouTube have historically been very prudish (swearing can demonetize a video and nsfw content isn’t allowed)
Re:Tumblr has added more strict tag filtering for their iOS app by forgotmyoldname on Sunday December 26, 2021 @05:58PM (#29697184)
I really don’t get why big companies buying ads are apparently morally trapped in 1950.

Nobody who was actually going to buy your product is going to care if it appears alongside someone saying “oh shit! Cool!” But we consistently get policies that punish people just for saying simple words, like YouTube apparently demonetizing anything with “foul language” in the titles/first minute or so of the video.

Most people also won’t care if a portion of the website has boobs or something. 99.999% of people won’t decide to never again purchase your soda because it advertised on a site that had a bare nipple on a certain subsection of that site. But policies are enforced like this is true, and it ends up killing platforms once they reach a size mainstream enough to sell fast food and soda ads.

Re:Tumblr has added more strict tag filtering for their iOS app by yaboy on Sunday December 26, 2021 @10:43PM (#29698899)
I used to buy millions of dollars of ads for major brands including Verizon and NBC Universal. You’re right and wrong at the same time. If Clorox accidentally bought $1MM of ads on Pornhub would it hurt their bottom line? No. It might be help it with clever creative.

It’s all about Christmas bonuses or quarterly bonuses. High level executives are notoriously conservative and DO NOT rock the boat. All it takes is enough moralizing hypocrites seeing an ad in the wrong place or emailing the company or whipping up a Twitter cancellation and suddenly their career aspirations are at risk. And they are incredibly replaceable.

Re:Tumblr has added more strict tag filtering for their iOS app by klondike_ on Sunday December 26, 2021 @06:23PM (#29697356)
It's about appealing to the largest demographic possible. The company might not care about such antiquated morals, but a large percentage of the population does.

An example is the YouTube "adpocalypse" from a few years ago. When major national brands have ads showing up to Nazi videos and conspiracies, it's not a good look for the company and journalists ripped them a new one. People don't care that the ads are "algorithmically" placed.

Re:Tumblr has added more strict tag filtering for their iOS app by quartesixte on Sunday December 26, 2021 @08:38PM (#29698131)
I said “fuck” like, twice in a 3 hour hangout with a group of “friends”, all something around their mid-20s.

At the end of the night, I was pulled aside by one of them and was told “we like having you hang with us, but you can’t be swearing like that around us.”

These people exist. In much larger numbers than you think. And they are much more demographically spread out than you’d think.

Edit: I don’t really hang with them anymore.

Re:Tumblr has added more strict tag filtering for their iOS app by kstrauser on Sunday December 26, 2021 @08:49PM (#29698194)
It’s very rare that I’d curse in a business or formal setting. Take me to meet your parents and I can be the picture of civility. If we’re out having casual drinks, well, I’m a Navy veteran and the language may get a bit more colorful. I’m not going to turn the air blue, but if we’re out for 3 hours, you’re likely to hear an f-bomb or two. If that bothers someone, we’re probably not going to hang out together for a number of other reasons.
Re:Tumblr has added more strict tag filtering for their iOS app by thebean11 on Sunday December 26, 2021 @06:32PM (#29697405)
There’s a huge difference between “shows up beside” and “shows up on the same website” though. I don’t think GP was talking about showing ads next to porn, but rather whether unmonetized porn on a NSFW sub poisons the well for advertiser friendly subs.

My understanding is that advertisers had an issue with Nazi videos being monetized with their ads, not Nazi videos being on the platform at all. Obviously nobody wants to pay money to have their brand associated with that.

Re:Tumblr has added more strict tag filtering for their iOS app by jelling on Sunday December 26, 2021 @05:50PM (#29697143)
Reddits revenue per user is terrible compared to Facebook ($0.30 vs $7):

https://www.cnbc.com/2019/02/11/reddit-users-are-the-least-v...

Re:Tumblr has added more strict tag filtering for their iOS app by markx2 on Sunday December 26, 2021 @05:29PM (#29696976)
I have no knowledge of how Reddit handles NSFW content. I have some knowledge of how Automattic does.

From what I have seen as an active reddit user of 10yrs+, the ads I see on - for example - /r/culinaryskills, /r/gamedeals, /r/dogs - are quite different. They are targeted in some way.

All WordPress.com sites - and I assume tumblr sites - could have ads shown. One way to stop ads being shown on those sites is to apply a tag.

Call that tag "mature"

A site tagged as "mature" will

- not appear to other sites

- will therefore experience a drop-off in traffic

- but will still appear in Google but because of the lack of linking will be much much lower in results.

Reddit cannot add those tags as fast and (maybe) as accurately as a blogging service can so it gets away with it. That said, they do have the ability to quarantine sites and I have no idea at all if they hide NSFW content from crawlers.

Re:Tumblr has added more strict tag filtering for their iOS app by evanelias on Sunday December 26, 2021 @11:19PM (#29699146)
The vast majority of Tumblr traffic is via logged-in users hitting the dashboard (activity stream of posts from followed users), global tag pages, etc. It's a social network, and most pages with ads are displaying content from a bunch of different blogs at once. It's just like the Twitter timeline.

Tumblr has already long had a notion of NSFW blogs and content, which are already treated differently than "safe" content. But since the blog network (individual "sites" as you're saying) is a minority of traffic, and not a major source of revenue in the first place, it's not really comparable to isolating mature content on WordPress or Reddit.

Re:Tumblr has added more strict tag filtering for their iOS app by riantogo on Sunday December 26, 2021 @05:40PM (#29697059)
So you are saying there appears to be a way (likely nontrivial) that Tumblr could adopt (maybe same as reddit) to keep both advertisers and community happy?
Re:Tumblr has added more strict tag filtering for their iOS app by markx2 on Sunday December 26, 2021 @05:59PM (#29697195)
No.

A subreddit could, depending on it's (unpaid) mods have a wide variety of content. For example /r/WTF content could be funny or shocking. An advertiser on that sub would have to be okay with their content being alongside either content.

Let's say a tumblr site gets tagged as "mature".

That site does not get the expected ads normally seen on a site

That site is effectively invisible to other sites

Why would you buy ads on a site that no-one will see?

Why would you stay publishing on a site where your traffic falls of a cliff?

What makes a site get that 'mature' tag? It could be one post, it could be a series of posts. But that tag stays until it manually removed.

When you are running a site that has user generated content there are two alternatives:

- Being clean

- Being seen to be clean

Tag filtering helps the latter.

Re:Tumblr has added more strict tag filtering for their iOS app by riantogo on Sunday December 26, 2021 @06:44PM (#29697477)
I think we are saying the same thing. Tumblr could operate the same way as reddit and enjoy similar ad revenue.
Re:Tumblr has added more strict tag filtering for their iOS app by d3nj4l on Sunday December 26, 2021 @07:08PM (#29697630)
Fun fact: Reddit doesn’t allow porn on /r/all and /r/popular. It used to be blocked only on /r/popular, but they blocked it on /r/all too relatively recently.