Presumably the people behind the website are adults. They should be ready to accept criticism. Maybe they'll find a way around these problems, maybe they won't.
But there's no reason that we should avoid criticism because someone somewhere might not like it.
This is a startup community, if you're going to get prickly when someone points out the obvious holes, you're in the wrong place.
It was naieve, simpleminded, baseless drivel, and he called them on it. Cynicism not required.
Hey, if some group wants to create their socialist utopia by building a new town devoted to that cause, great. That's a much better plan that the current one of confiscating my wealth, via police powers, for their lofty and ill-fated goals. I'll be watching with great interest. (Don't get me wrong: I also watch, with more interest, the similar yet opposing plans of hardcore libertarians.)
Well done you (slow clap)
I'm so tired of people shooting stuff down for the sake of it.