News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reverse-engineering a tiny 1980s chip that plays Christma... by zw123456 on Saturday December 25, 2021 @06:33PM (#29688074)
Back in 1980 when I was working on my Masters in EE, my capstone project was a chip that would play music. The problem was; that back then, the amount of ROM you could fabricate (at least at our facility) was limited to about 1K at best.

I decided to take a music class to learn a little more about music and thought that would help me with my project. The professor would play various classical pieces and lecture about them. Our homework was to go in a listening room and familiarize ourselves with the music. Everything was on vinyl so you would put a record on, listen, take notes etc.

When the first exam came, the professor would take out a record, and place it on a turntable and play a piece and you were supposed to identify it. I was amazed that all the other students seemed to be getting all of them and I was struggling. I went to the professor's office hours and I explained to him my project and what I was working on. He was very intrigued and suggested that I consider Bach especially Fugue's which has a lot of repetition and cycles (good advice I ended up using Bach Toccata Fugue in D minor, which is used a lot in old timey horror movies and I just loved it).

Later, after talking with other students, they showed me their "system" which was crib notes with things written on them like "Blue label with yellow text = Bethoven", things like that. In other words, they were cheating. They were making crib notes about the record labels in the listening room and paying no attention whatsoever to the music.

Since the professor was so nice to me, I decided to tell him about it. He listened to what I said, and he just said "I see", then asked me about my project. He asked if he could come when I presented my project and I was thrilled he was interested.

But he seemed to continue to use the records and the same method, until the final exam when he announced to the class he was going to use a new system, a Tape Deck! You could hear an audible gasp in the classroom. Needless to say, a lot of students did not do so well on the final. I got an A.

I also got an A on my capstone and the EE professors were all very impressed I had taken the time to research the music and my music professor got up and said a few words for me. It was a really cool experience in my life. I hope it is OK that I shared such a long boring story, but every time I see something about a music chip like the kind in greeting cards or whatever, it kind of reminds me a little of my project and how much I enjoyed that experience.

As for the technology of the chip Ken covered, it is of course, quite a bit more sophisticated than mine was, at least as memory serves me (pun intended).

Re:Reverse-engineering a tiny 1980s chip that plays Christma... by herunan on Saturday December 25, 2021 @06:45PM (#29688170)
I wish I read more touching stories like this on HN. These are the stories that bring meaning to life. Keep on remembering and keep on sharing. Have a wonderful Christmas holiday.
Re:Reverse-engineering a tiny 1980s chip that plays Christma... by zw123456 on Saturday December 25, 2021 @07:34PM (#29688472)
Thank you so much,

And just a quick aside, Thanks to Ken for what he does, obviously I ravishly read everything he does!

Re:Reverse-engineering a tiny 1980s chip that plays Christma... by Vrondi on Saturday December 25, 2021 @07:12PM (#29688352)
This was such a good story that I read it aloud to a completely non-techie loved one, and we both got some joy from it. Thank for the Christmas gift, friend.
Re:Reverse-engineering a tiny 1980s chip that plays Christma... by zw123456 on Saturday December 25, 2021 @09:00PM (#29688992)
Oh, that is wonderful to hear.

Please have a wonderful Holiday!

Re:Reverse-engineering a tiny 1980s chip that plays Christma... by zafka on Saturday December 25, 2021 @08:02PM (#29688651)
Thanks a bunch for this story! I really like the way you used your music class for research.

If you don't mind me asking- What sort of things are you doing now? Are you able to do much R&D?

Re:Reverse-engineering a tiny 1980s chip that plays Christma... by zw123456 on Saturday December 25, 2021 @08:59PM (#29688988)
After I received my PhD I worked at Bell Labs for a while and did several different things and now I am a Distinguished Research Fellow at a large telcom company and I have many patents and interesting inventions mostly around antenna technology.

I still love music, especially Jazz and find inspiration from it at times.

Thank you for asking.

Happy Holiday !

Re:Reverse-engineering a tiny 1980s chip that plays Christma... by zafka on Saturday December 25, 2021 @09:29PM (#29689128)
Well congratulations on a very cool career. I often lament the fact that there is no more Bell Labs. I try to promote that concept at my company knowing that I am just tilting at windmills. Happy Holidays!
Re:Reverse-engineering a tiny 1980s chip that plays Christma... by picture on Saturday December 25, 2021 @06:42PM (#29688139)
> I hope it is OK that I shared such a long boring story

Definitely okay. I found this story absolutely delightful. Thanks for sharing, and happy holidays!

Re:Reverse-engineering a tiny 1980s chip that plays Christma... by zw123456 on Saturday December 25, 2021 @06:43PM (#29688146)
Thank you. And you too, enjoy the holiday :)
Re:Reverse-engineering a tiny 1980s chip that plays Christma... by intricatedetail on Saturday December 25, 2021 @08:02PM (#29688654)
You really designed a chip at uni? I think mine uni was a rip off then.
Re:Reverse-engineering a tiny 1980s chip that plays Christma... by zw123456 on Saturday December 25, 2021 @09:02PM (#29688996)
Oh no, if you did it then it was not a rip off. As long as you learned from it then it was awesome!

Have a wonderful Holiday!

Re:Reverse-engineering a tiny 1980s chip that plays Christma... by I_Byte on Saturday December 25, 2021 @10:10PM (#29689317)
Thank you for sharing this story! I really enjoyed it!
Re:Reverse-engineering a tiny 1980s chip that plays Christma... by arcticbull on Sunday December 26, 2021 @12:39AM (#29690030)
Well written! That was fun read.
Re:Reverse-engineering a tiny 1980s chip that plays Christma... by whytomatoes on Saturday December 25, 2021 @07:17PM (#29688385)
Thank you so much