News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scala use is less good than Java use for at least half of... by JoachimSchipper on Tuesday September 06, 2011 @08:26PM (#2967831)
Relevant [dead] comment:

fogus 20 minutes ago | link [dead]

    ad hominem rhetoric
Yikes! I seem to have struck a chord with Mr. Pollack. The problem is that I'm not sure that the gap between what he said and what I said is very large. I certainly wasn't attacking him in my post, although I did link to his article. Additionally, I would never question his Scala credentials, but I tend to question those who say that Scala is complicated based on type signatures and syntax oddities. However, I will say in that with his latest post I think the gap between our opinions has widened. His comes off as cynical, but I have to think that I'm misreading the post. I do however find it odd that "ad hominem" would be used by someone who bases a dev's programming potential on the number of hours they choose to work during the day and their familiarity with Zed Shaw.
Re:Scala use is less good than Java use for at least half of... by eengbrec on Tuesday September 06, 2011 @11:06PM (#2968173)
I don't think the gap between what he originally said and your response was large. I was rather surprised by his "ad hominem" remark, but the rest of his last blog was pretty much exactly what I would have expected.

DPP's a freelance consultant, and I suspect one with no shortage of business. He'd rather stick to projects where the technology he is advocating won't get blamed if the project fails. That's not really surprising.

Re:Scala use is less good than Java use for at least half of... by irahul on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @01:57AM (#2968552)
Why is fogus being downvoted? I don't see anything wrong with his comments - he is being civil and rational.
Re:Scala use is less good than Java use for at least half of... by JoachimSchipper on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @05:02AM (#2968866)
He's not getting downvoted, he's getting flagged - mere downvotes don't result in [dead] comments.

I didn't follow the whole discussion (especially since I was on holidays), but the comments I saw were not obviously worthy of being [dead]; hence my repost.

Re:Scala use is less good than Java use for at least half of... by bodski on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @06:09AM (#2969002)
I agree, the only 'rebuttal' to fogus comment seems to be saying that he is tone deaf and bad at communicating with no explanation of why. The flagging of his comments seems to be other politics at work with no explanation of what they are.
Re:Scala use is less good than Java use for at least half of... by ap22213 on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @09:17AM (#2969389)
The anonymous down-voting on hn is really a problem.
Re:Scala use is less good than Java use for at least half of... by andrewcooke on Tuesday September 06, 2011 @08:48PM (#2967883)
the gap between what he felt and what you said is only large because you are, apparently, completely tone deaf. programming and communicating in english are quite different things. you are good at programming, apparently, but not at communicating with the written word. that's ok. after all 50% of people are below average. and just because you're not good at this doesn't mean you can't still chat to friends in the hallway.
Re:Scala use is less good than Java use for at least half of... by JoachimSchipper on Wednesday September 07, 2011 @04:58AM (#2968856)
Another [dead] comment:

fogus 6 hours ago | link [dead]

In the case of my blog post I would say you are 100% correct. Without a doubt I was unable to get my point across since Mr. Pollack, whose work on Lift I respect, thinks that I attacked him personally instead of his point. As for my more general tone-deafness and inability to communicate using the English language I can only say that if I keep at it, then maybe I'll one day be successful.