"Numbers in commit messages don't really make any sense. I don't understand what value they might have."
I like to refer to 'commit 347' rather than 'commit a3bh'. There's an implicit sense of how old a commit is.
Then if you later decide to shuffle the order of the commits, squash, or do other interesting things, you run into GWBASIC line numbering problems.
I like to commit (quite) frequently when working on something, but later I feel that work-in-progress commits are just hindrance. When looking at project history after two year, I'll be glad if there is a single, larger commit "implemented feature x". Rebase is your friend.