Re:Intel apologises in China over Xinjiang supplier statement
by AnimalMuppet on Thursday December 23, 2021 @04:14PM
(#29666552)
There's too many discussions in the past that have gone bad. I mean, there are too many times when the subject is what China is doing in Xinjiang, and people bring up slavery or US militarism or whatever, not because they want to compare and contrast and learn, but because they want to distract from an honest discussion of what China is doing in Xinjiang.
And the exact same thing happens on the other side, for the same reasons. Try to talk about US militarism, and people bring up China and Xinjiang.
So when you're in a discussion about one side of that, and someone brings up the other side of that, the priors lean toward it being bad faith. Because there has been so much bad faith in the past, it's hard to believe that someone bringing it up now is doing so in good faith.
If you want to actually have that discussion, you almost certainly can't do it in a thread that started off talking about one side or the other. You'd have to begin in a neutral place. (I don't know if you can pull it off even there...)
And the exact same thing happens on the other side, for the same reasons. Try to talk about US militarism, and people bring up China and Xinjiang.
So when you're in a discussion about one side of that, and someone brings up the other side of that, the priors lean toward it being bad faith. Because there has been so much bad faith in the past, it's hard to believe that someone bringing it up now is doing so in good faith.
If you want to actually have that discussion, you almost certainly can't do it in a thread that started off talking about one side or the other. You'd have to begin in a neutral place. (I don't know if you can pull it off even there...)