News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The roots of the National Cancer Act by narrator on Thursday December 23, 2021 @03:36PM (#29666164)
I read a lot of medical research. A lot has something to do with cancer and the research can be summed up as "We found a new way to kill cells. This may work better on cancer cells than normal cells. Hooray! More study is needed." or "This gene or habit or whatever may have some correlation to cancer."

Kind of wish they would try something different. The book "Tripping Over the Truth" was a good expose of the failed approaches to cancer research over the years.

Re:The roots of the National Cancer Act by inglor_cz on Thursday December 23, 2021 @03:59PM (#29666413)
What else would you do with those cells? Keep them alive?

Our immune system is probably strong enough to whack most cancers before they become a macroscopic problem. Most hopeful treatments of today are in direction of engaging the immune system against cancer cells.

If I had to guess, the ultimate solution would be resolving immunosenescence. Our immune systems are getting worse over time, so the chance of a runaway malignity grows with age. But we might be able to prevent or reverse this loss of function.

Re:The roots of the National Cancer Act by jacquesm on Thursday December 23, 2021 @04:14PM (#29666550)
> Our immune system is probably strong enough to whack most cancers before they become a macroscopic problem.

Cancer cells are your cells. And this is the heart of the problem, the majority of the time the immune system is a-ok with what cancer cells are doing. It's not rare at all to find cancers so big that they have had a major effect on the bloodflow to healthy cells around them simply because they consume that much in terms of resources. They can get so large that they will quite literally rearrange your organs and disrupt their functioning. And all the while not a peep from your immune system. Of course this doesn't hold for all cancers, in all situations, your immune system can and does detect certain types of cancer, sometimes in an early enough stage that it is able to eliminate the threat.

Good read (a bit old, 2002):

https://jlb.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1189/jlb.71.6.907

Re:The roots of the National Cancer Act by folli on Thursday December 23, 2021 @04:35PM (#29666776)
> the majority of the time the immune system is a-ok with what cancer cells are doing

Ok, no. The majority of the time the immune system prevents tumor formation. Immune surveillance is not really debated [1]. Animals where the immune system is shut down and immunosuppressed patients have a much higher chance to develop cancer.

The paper you cite even underlines the point that immune evasion is a failure and not the rule.

[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1857231/

Re:The roots of the National Cancer Act by jacquesm on Thursday December 23, 2021 @04:38PM (#29666808)
That's the third comment that says the exact same thing.

Obviously, we are within the 'war on cancer' talking about the remainder, not the ones that the immune system dealt with successfully.

Re:The roots of the National Cancer Act by inglor_cz on Thursday December 23, 2021 @04:48PM (#29666898)
This is a shifting standard, though.

Our immune systems are much worse in our 70s than in our 20s, and we suffer from many more cancers in our old age. This correlation probably isn't completely random.

I am cautiously optimistic about potential rejuvenation of immune systems in older adults. There already were successful experiments (google TRIIM and TRIIM-X by Dr. Greg Fahy) that restored function of the thymus in older people (people, not mice!).

Active thymus likely translates into a better function of T-lymphocytes, vital soldiers in the immune army.

Re:The roots of the National Cancer Act by jacquesm on Thursday December 23, 2021 @04:56PM (#29666973)
Part of that is simply that the cumulative copy errors of cells several generations old incurs a higher chance of cancer as well as the higher chance of those cancers not being detected by the aging immune system. So there is degradation on multiple axis at once (and probably others that I'm not even aware of).

> I am cautiously optimistic about potential rejuvenation of immune systems in older adults.

That's a worthy goal.

Re:The roots of the National Cancer Act by inglor_cz on Thursday December 23, 2021 @05:19PM (#29667159)
Random errors in DNA are part of the picture, but we have error-correction mechanisms as well. It is possible that those mechanisms go haywire as we age, too.

It is interesting that short-lived animals like mice tend to suffer from cancer a lot, while huge, long-lived beasts such as whales and elephants seem to be very resistant to cancer, even though they have a lot of cells that can go wrong. Their anticancer mechanisms are obviously much better than ours.

We might yet learn something from them.

Re:The roots of the National Cancer Act by jacquesm on Thursday December 23, 2021 @07:27PM (#29668323)
That might be the other way around though: in order to become a large beast you really need that error correction.

Similar with viruses: small viruses are typically RNA because they don't need that error correction as much as their larger counterparts which are typically DNA based giving much better resilience against mutation (and hence a much lower mutation rate).

Re:The roots of the National Cancer Act by folli on Thursday December 23, 2021 @04:50PM (#29666918)
Sorry, I was getting riled up about the "majority" part of your statement and trying to find some references with quantitative estimates (which you were also wondering about in your response to a sibling comment). The other comments snuck in meanwhile...
Re:The roots of the National Cancer Act by jacquesm on Thursday December 23, 2021 @04:58PM (#29666990)
Yes, I should have been more careful in wording that, obviously if the early stage stuff gets snuffed out we won't know about it. But the numerical angle is an interesting one and the ratio between the cancers that are caught versus the ones that aren't (and maybe per age cohort) could be quite insightful.
Re:The roots of the National Cancer Act by inglor_cz on Thursday December 23, 2021 @04:30PM (#29666718)
"the majority of the time the immune system is a-ok with what cancer cells are doing"

This is survivorship bias. Of course we do not detect cancers that were killed early on, much like we aren't aware of all the pathogens that were neutralized before they could cause visible symptoms. We only know about those that escaped the immune system patrol.

The good news is that the immune system can be augmented/instructed from the outside, and new cancer therapies do precisely that.

Re:The roots of the National Cancer Act by jacquesm on Thursday December 23, 2021 @04:33PM (#29666742)
If cancer cells didn't occasionally manage to evade detection by the immune system then we wouldn't be having this conversation in the first place so those are the cancers that are in focus because they are the ones that people end up dying from (or needing treatment or surgery with all of the associated risks).
Re:The roots of the National Cancer Act by inglor_cz on Thursday December 23, 2021 @04:43PM (#29666858)
True, but as I already mentioned, immune systems can be trained against those cancers as well, they only need external help.

For example, BioNTech was actually founded as a cancer vaccine research lab, its Covid vaccine is "only" a (very welcome) serendipity.

Re:The roots of the National Cancer Act by monocasa on Thursday December 23, 2021 @04:53PM (#29666950)
There's also Cuba's lung cancer vaccine that's unfortunately illegal here in the states because of the embargo.

https://pulitzercenter.org/stories/cuba-has-lung-cancer-vacc...

Re:The roots of the National Cancer Act by jacquesm on Thursday December 23, 2021 @05:11PM (#29667083)
That's a very weird thing that Cuban embargo, I never really got what's so terrible about Cuba that you couldn't travel there. And in this context it is terrible assuming that that stuff really works.
Re:The roots of the National Cancer Act by monocasa on Thursday December 23, 2021 @04:21PM (#29666617)
The majority of the time, it seems that the immune system does it's job. 'The majority of the time _that it has already become a macroscopic problem_ the immune system didn't do it's job' is sort of a tautology.
Re:The roots of the National Cancer Act by jacquesm on Thursday December 23, 2021 @04:28PM (#29666687)
That's a fair criticism, but those are the cases that people are worried about, not the ones where the immune system generates the appropriate response. Just like we don't really care about regular moderate rain but we do care about rain that overwhelms our ability to deal with it. I'm not even sure what the stats are on the cases where a cancer got nipped in the bud at the single or just a few cells stage, but now I'm interested and I'm going to try to find out if this has been researched or not, that has to be a tricky problem to determine the answer to.
Re:The roots of the National Cancer Act by s1artibartfast on Thursday December 23, 2021 @03:50PM (#29666300)
There is a lot of money to be made if someone comes up with a game changing cancer treatment - so the incentive is there.

It is impossible to treat cancer without killing cancer cells, so I'm not sure why this is troubling to see

Re:The roots of the National Cancer Act by williamtrask on Thursday December 23, 2021 @04:00PM (#29666418)
Not all treatments are equally profitable. I’m close colleagues with the cancer research dept here in Oxford and there’s more than a little cynicism about what types of pursuits get funding amongst grad students.

Diet change, for example, is generally undervalued I’m told.

Re:The roots of the National Cancer Act by s1artibartfast on Thursday December 23, 2021 @07:11PM (#29668197)
I think it is important to delineate treatment from prevention. I would agree that prevention may be undervalued relative to treatment.

My understanding is that dietary effects on treatment have small effects on the margin. They might bump your survival a few percent, but are not going to reverse your stage 4 cancer.

Dietary research is probably good ROI, but is unlikely to yield groundbreaking treatments or silver bullets, like you mentioned in the OP.

Re:The roots of the National Cancer Act by alphaoverlord on Thursday December 23, 2021 @04:14PM (#29666554)
Not all treatments are equally likely as well. Given how good dietary science is outside of cancer, less optimistic at rigorous studies in this area.
Re:The roots of the National Cancer Act by ren_engineer on Thursday December 23, 2021 @04:36PM (#29666779)
>It is impossible to treat cancer without killing cancer cells

best treatment would be to find root cause and prevent cancer cells from growing in the first place, I'd imagine gene therapy will one day be used to help with this.

Early detection would also drastically improve outcomes

Re:The roots of the National Cancer Act by folli on Thursday December 23, 2021 @04:40PM (#29666824)
That's the problem: there's no single root cause to cancer. Every cancer type has an additional dozen subtypes with different causes. It's a mess.
Re:The roots of the National Cancer Act by LinuxBender on Thursday December 23, 2021 @05:40PM (#29667313)
I find this video [1] interesting as it pertains to the root cause of cancer. Compelling theories anyway.

[1] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=06e-PwhmSq8 [video]

Re:The roots of the National Cancer Act by s1artibartfast on Thursday December 23, 2021 @07:16PM (#29668239)
Prevention /= treatment, but I agree prevention is good too. The HPV vaccine is a great example of this, reducing one's chance of cervical cancer by up to 99%, depending on the source